9 ms·
Growing up I absorbed all the space stuff I could find. But it wasn't until recently that I realized that the solar system didn't just form into some static na
by duxup 6y ago
Growing up I absorbed all the space stuff I could find.
But it wasn't until recently that I realized that the solar system didn't just form into some static natural state where it largely didn't change until say the sun was finished with it's lifespan.
Rather it evolves, changes, planets are habitable, then not, moons are formed and break up, even frozen planets are geologically active and are changing, Saturn's rings are relatively recent and etc.
Not sure how I didn't pick up on that.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNot sure how I didn't pick up on that. The sheer scale of it makes it hard to perceive, so probably you aren't the only one and probably a lot of the literature has similar blind spots which implicitly signals "this isn't happening" and we pick up on that and it gets implicitly repeated until it's hard to give any kind of push back in our own minds.
- spacemark 6y agoFor sure. You'll find that our notions of our own world and societies are also very outdated on average due to how rapidly they're changing (and by and large improving). A wonderful, easy to read book on this that I recommend is Factfulness. https://www.ted.com/playlists/474/the_best_hans_rosling_talks_yo https://www.ted.com/playlists/474/the_best_hans_rosling_talk... https://www.amazon.com/Factfulness-Reasons-World-Things-Better/dp/1250107814 https://www.amazon.com/Factfulness-Reasons-World-Things-Bett...
- mc32 6y agoUntil we started sending probes out there, we didn't know much about those bodies. Tectonic plates on Earth were not confirmed till the '60s or so, so... it's not surprising.
- chrisco255 6y agoI think it's the way it's presented. We still have a sort of Newtonian "clockwork" view in primary education of astronomy.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe "clockwork" view is objectively incorrect due to being the wrong scale. (Some) Accurate scale models of the solar system get played out across city blocks. If it's a tinkertoy style model or a drawing within a book, it's made up BS. There are no books large enough to actually show it to scale. Edit: For the pedants of the world, I have added "(Some)" to my sentence. "Not all accurate scale models" of course. Some are even larger than that. 2nd edit: Folding another comment in here as well that I deleted : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_System_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_System_model The Sweden solar system scale is listed as 1:20,000,000. Others have used a different scale and been fit into less than an entire country. There are several around the world. In York, it is spread across 6.4 miles: https://astrocampus.york.ac.uk/cycle-the-solar-system/ https://astrocampus.york.ac.uk/cycle-the-solar-system/ There's another in Greater Boston: https://foursquare.com/eric_odea/list/museum-of-science-boston-community-solar-system https://foursquare.com/eric_odea/list/museum-of-science-bost...
- irrational 6y agoCity blocks? Sweden has a scale model of the solar system that stretches across the entire country - north to south. And even then it isn’t actually big/long enough for the entire solar system.
- minitoar 6y agoDepends how small you’re willing to make the bodies. In Sweden the Sun is a huge spherical building.
- marshmallow_12 6y agoand if it was smaller the planets would be invisible.
- minitoar 6y agoIt could be made smaller without risking invisibility of any of the planets. The smallest planet is Mercury at 25cm.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIn a geology class we learned what very few people realize, that Earth's landscape is constantly changing. Only on a scale humans generally can't perceive.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Growing up I absorbed all the space stuff I could find. Yeah well, when I was growing up Pluto was still a planet.
- cookiengineer 6y agoWhat's mindblowing is the search for planet 9...once you start to realize that we are surrounded by thousands of dead solar systems (brown dwarfs that very likely were red dwarfs before) in our immediate neighborhood. Imagine what we could accomplish by mining their resources!
- chairmanwow1 6y agoWhat does this mean? Surrounded by thousands of dead solar systems? Like nearby (dark) stars?
- cookiengineer 6y agoThey are called brown dwarfs... but it's better to link the NASA backyard worlds project directly for the curious: https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/marckuchner/backyard-worlds-planet-9 https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/marckuchner/backyard-wor...
- cambalache 6y agoI suspected so. But all those objects are in this solar system.Brown dwarfs are sub-stellar bodies.
- cookiengineer 6y agoTouche, you are technically correct. Though some might argue that in the changing nature of fusion reactions and body mass, this sorting of sub-stellar bodies is only true for as long as our star is a red dwarf. Once that's over (thinking in the larger timescale of things) and it becomes a brown dwarf, what then? Wasn't it a solar system at one point in time?
- btach 6y ago(I'm not an astronomer, my understanding is not absolute, please correct if I'm wrong) I believe our Sun is a type G, yellow dwarf. A red dwarf is usually much smaller, if considering "red dwarf" being a type M, then usually no more than 0.6 solar masses, usually much smaller, and a tiiiiny fraction of the luminosity of Sol. Brown dwarfs are not massive enough to fuse hydrogen, where red dwarfs generally are. According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_dwarf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_dwarf, above 0.25 solar masses, they should evolve into red giants, otherwise will shrink into a white dwarf once hydrogen fusion is ceased. The universe isn't old enough to have any red dwarf of 0.25 solar masses to do so, however as their lifespans are so long.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'm not sure how old you are, but a lot has changed, recently, in our knowledge of Earth, its evolution, the solar system, and astronomy. One of the books I had growing up was a Patrick Moore juvenile book on astronomy, probably Seeing Stars (1970). That had a ... pretty good ... description of the state of knowledge at the time, but it was published only about five years after the 4.5 billion year figure for the age of the Earth, and plate tectonics as a geological mechanism, were formally adopted. The Viking missions, Voyager, Mars rovers, New Horizons, the Hubble Space Telescope, Keck observatory, LIGO ... were all in the future. The degree of development in the field of geology in the 20th century alone has been staggering. Credible scientific estimates of the age of the Earth in 1900 were as little as 30 million years (Lord Kelvin's gravitational collapse/cooling calculation). Interestingly, parallel developments in physics (notably radioactivity) helped give us the clocks we finally needed to measure geological time. We could trace landmass movements, make some determination of interior structures using seismic (and I suspect nuclear blast) waves, and more. Much of the more interesting physics (and some chemistry) Nobel Prize awards of the past 50 years have been in sensing and detecting, at large and small scales, again, giving tools to measure, detect, and distinguish patterns, structures, and phenomena. Within my own lifetime notions such as the asteroid hypothesis for the mass extinction of the dinosaurs have passed from wild theory to accepted fact, we've got evidence of 300 million-year snowball Earths, strong evidence concerning early Earth evolution, atmospheric composition, and life. We have detected thousands of extrasolar planets (a value still strongly limited by what sizes, types, orbits, and distances at which such detection is possible). Pluto's been un-planeted, and imaged. We've kissed the face of comets and returned their dust to Earth. And we're starting to get some idea as what the long-term stability of planetary orbits might be --- the notion that planets may wander not only in the skies but in their orbital characteristics ... would change things markedly. So it's quite possible that what you didn't pick up wasn't there to pick up when you were learning it.
- benlumen 6y agoVery good point. I'm in my 30s and it's even come a long way since I was a kid. We didn't know until recently that there were planets orbiting other stars. We suspected that there might be, but we didn't know. The idea that there could be other "earth-like planets" was a hopeful guess. When the headlines started coming in from Kepler, that was huge. Very exciting and huge.
- gverrilla 6y agoThere was a very interesting thinker in the 18th who wrote that eventually the Earth would gain a planetary ring. He talked about how everything changes, even though our lifespan is so short we don't see it. And he was particularly speaking about society: afterall, he was a very progressive member of the generation that indeed abolished slavery, even though a lot of people said before: "Slavery's been going on for 80k years, it will never end". I learned a lot from his writings, and I believe our society could learn a lot from them to this day. The wikipedia article is very poor compared to the depth of his work/thought but here it goes anyway for reference: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Fourier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Fourier
- paulz_ 6y agoAny books or writings of his you would reccomend in paticular?
- gverrilla 6y agoI love almost all his work tbh - actually I've been translating a compilation of some of his writings from spanish to portuguese and I also contributed to his page on portuguese wikipedia :) You can dive in from wherever, and you will be able to know his cohese and wonderful universe of thought - it really doesn't matter, because it's a single entity, so you can start from his thoughts about family, work, slavery, astronomy, architecture, higiene, urbanism, politics, religion, sex, tolerance, women, commerce, law, philosophy, love, etc I should warn you to beware of the translation because there are bad ones - he's a guy coming up with words and concepts and always playing with language and meaning, so you gotta be able to read between lines. I wish you a good reading, if you can find them because they seem to be kinda rare, and mind = blown! If you'd like to exchange some ideas about it later, feel free to get in touch!
- Raaasmus 6y agoMy limited understanding says that his prediction is spot on as we seem to be building a planetary ring of space junk.
- tim333 6y agoI sort of got the impression it was static as a kid as that's how all the books were written. I think its changing nature is a relatively recent discovery. I remember a lot of debate as to whether a meteor could have done for the dinosaurs because people were skeptical that sort of stuff happened but it turns out chunks of rock smashing into planets is quite common and basically how they got here. I also got the impression Earth was more unchanging than it is. It was a surprise to find you could walk from England to France 10,000 years ago or so.
- lbblack 6y agoHighly recommend anyone to look into Oceanography! The ocean floors reveal a lot of ancient geological history and the Earth is much more dynamic than what meets the eye. Sea floor spreading, plate tectonics, and much more can be studied simply by observing the ocean floor!
- jliptzin 6y agoA lot of things we think are static do actually change quite a bit. Tiny changes add up to a lot over time. I once buried a little canister with some money inside (in a shallow hole next to a distinctive tree) in the woods while hiking, just to see if anyone would find it. I came back a couple months later, took me a very long time to find, I did eventually, and it was much, much deeper than I had buried it. The soil must have shifted way more than I thought it would in that short period of time but it's not something you would ever notice from day to day.