2 ms·
The concept of low-temperature fusion in itself is not absurd necessarily, but there is a whole lot of orders of magnitude to overcome. And it cannot be easy or
by kergonath 6y ago
The concept of low-temperature fusion in itself is not absurd necessarily, but there is a whole lot of orders of magnitude to overcome. And it cannot be easy or common, or we’d have seen it already: one particle releasing ~1 MeV in a crystal leaves traces, which we can interpret very well. So the proofs need to be solid, not just hand-waving “it must be fusion, because we haven’t got the faintest idea”.
The fuzziness about how you’d have fusion reactions by just putting protons in a metal is a bit dodgy. Everything else about it was a huge red flag. Yes, HTS are a bit different than older superconductors, and yes, we don’t know everything about them. But again, it’s not a huge stretch to imagine that there could be some mechanisms that could move the critical temperature by a factor of 5 to 10. Fundamentally, it’s still an exotic form of collective behaviour. Cold fusion amounts to getting ~0.1 MeV (the order of magnitude to tunnel through electrostatic interaction to reach a nucleus) out of ~0.05 eV (the energy of a proton at room temperature). That’s about as plausible as saying that you’d reach Earth’s escape velocity by running down a mountain. Of course, you’d be more credible with a rocket strapped on your back. Cold fusion is missing that rocket.