2 ms·
100% sure is not possible, but there is some good circumstantial reasons. Let's use the bad model that an electron is a small ball made of some magic material.
by gus_massa 6y ago
100% sure is not possible, but there is some good circumstantial reasons.
Let's use the bad model that an electron is a small ball made of some magic material. And that the material inside it is even, there are not more dense parts. Also the charge is distributed evenly, it's not concentrated in some parts.
The electron is spinning, so you imagine that the ball is spinning. So you can calculate the angular momentum of the electron, assuming it's an even ball of a magical material. The angular momentum can be measured experimentally, so you can calculate how fast the electron is spinning, assuming it's an even ball of a magical material.
It has charge, and the charge is moving, so it is like a small magnet. You have calculated how fast it is spinning, and you can calculate the magnetic moment of the electron, assuming it's an even ball of a magical material.
Now you go to the lab and measure the real magnetic moment of the electron and it is twice the value of the number you got assuming it's an even ball of a magical material. This number is called g, so for an electron g=2 (actually almost 2).
You can repeat the same calculation for protons, and the g of the proton is g~=1.410606...
For an elementary particle, there are theoretical reasons to be sure that g=2. So the conclusion is that the electron is an elementary particle and the proton is a composite particle.
---
Bonus: Actually, you can get a perfectly isolated electron alone, because there are nasty virtual particles floating around. You can't see the virtual particles, but they cause small corrections in the experiments with high energy particles. In particular, the g of the electron is not exactly 2 because these virtual particles cause a small correction. The value is approximately g=2.00231930436182(52) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_magnetic_moment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_magnetic_moment
If it smell to much hand waving, don't worry. There are very good models for all the nasty virtual particles, and you can make a long calculation of the effect of them, and calculate these correction. You can make the theoretical calculation and the experimental measure and they agree with 10 significant figures. They prefer to publish a=(g-2)/2 and
a_thoretical = 0.001159652181643(764)
a_experimental = 0.00115965218073(28)
So the model of a electron as an elementary particle with some virtual particles floating around is quite accurate.