3 ms·
I find this write-up enlightening : https://blog.gruffdavies.com/2017/12/24/newtonian-physics-is-deterministic-sorry-norton/ https://blog.gruffdavies.com/2017/1
by sudosysgen 6y ago
I find this write-up enlightening : https://blog.gruffdavies.com/2017/12/24/newtonian-physics-is-deterministic-sorry-norton/ https://blog.gruffdavies.com/2017/12/24/newtonian-physics-is...
It seems the equations given by Norton really are unphysical, so actually it's not a proof on indeterminism, but simply incompleteness - newtonian physics cannot model some really really fucky situations - its incomplete.
- leephillips 6y agoThat’s a brilliant analysis of the Norton’s dome; thank you.
- selimthegrim 6y agoWhy is virtual work not taught anymore?
- leephillips 6y agoWho says it’s not? I suspect most courses in advanced classical mechanics still cover it, although probably briefly.
- ceceron 6y agoThanks. It's a great piece of writing!
- randphys 6y agoI can recommend taking this blog post with a grain of salt. I'm a physics masters student and after working through the math myself I believe the Lipschitz continuity violation that Gruff rejects as a red herring is actually the real source of the nondeterminism, and is not just some mathematical fluff. The first law and stitching arguments he makes appear to both be flawed. Having non-zero derivatives of force in combination with zero velocity and zero force is perfectly in accordance with Newton's first law. And in his frictionless ball counterexample, his equation is incorrect because it violates Newton's second law, not because two solutions are stitched together. Lipschitz continuity is required for guaranteed uniqueness of differential equation solutions, and non-uniqueness can appear as nondeterminism or incompleteness. I think he reaches the right conclusion but his reasoning is flawed.