6 ms·
How Politics Tested Ravelry and the Crafting Community
- brighton36 6y agoI think this is the problem that 'original sin' fixed. It seems that everyone believes they themselves are good. And thus, they know what's good. But, I doubt that any of us are good. And I don't think good objectively exists, in any case.
- fortran77 6y agoPeople don't realize that if you want to be the most inclusive, sometimes your focus needs to be brutally narrow. Stick to yarn and patterns and be scrupulous about telling political discussions to go elsewhere.
- nerdponx 6y agoThis. Political activism is important. Stand up for what you believe in. But political activism does not mix with an inclusive, warm, welcoming hobby community. If you feel so strongly about your political beliefs that you can't let them rest even in your knitting club, then for the sake of the knitting club you're going to either have to turn it into a political knitting club or watch it fall apart. Maybe that's a sacrifice in pursuit of a greater cause.
- wussboy 6y agoWhat’s frustrating as well is that if they would have stuck to knitting, they probably would have done more to advance their various moral causes than explicitly calling things out. The community of knitting builds trust and friendship which is much more effective at changing people’s minds than shouting at them.
- nemo44x 6y agoIt’s hard to do when a very vocal and intimidating group of activists insist everything is political. “Silence is violence”, after all. One of the commands the various Critical Therories have is to find ‘X’ in everything and expose it. Don’t ask if ‘X’ happened but rather find how ‘X’ happened. ‘X’ can mean racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, etc. And often these terms, like racism, have been redefined to mean something different than what most people think. So, you can’t just have a nice hobby community according to these therories. You absolutely must unmask the “problematics” in them or else you are perpetuating systemic racism or the patriarchy, or whatever. Any denial that ‘X’ was somehow present is further proof it did happen. Denial is further evidence of guilt. If you don’t join in on the pile-on then you will be cast out and accused of ‘X’ as well and at best have to find new friends and at worst having your livelihood destroyed. So there’s a lot of incentive to “do better”.
- auntienomen 6y agoThe problematics usually unmask themselves. Ravelry is, I think, struggling with the question of how to deal with their more irascible members.
- nerdponx 6y agoYou're being downvoted, but this is true. The disagreement is over whether it's a good thing (break a few eggs, make a better-society-overall omelette) or a bad thing (anyone can get canceled at any time, everyone divided).
- baryphonic 6y ago> Political activism is important. Stand up for what you believe in. But political activism does not mix with an inclusive, warm, welcoming hobby community. If you feel so strongly about your political beliefs that you can't let them rest even in your knitting club, then for the sake of the knitting club you're going to either have to turn it into a political knitting club or watch it fall apart. I disagree. Just about anything else is more important and productive than political activism. Almost all political activism (in America at least) is either pointless group therapy (e.g. Women's March), astroturfing (e.g. the "election fortifiers") or actually destructive and thus evil (choose your own "mostly peaceful protestors"). Activists have a tendency to indulge a totalizing vision of their activism. Many of the most hard-core activists would see a request to tone down their activism as akin to being asked to remove their limbs. Activism has become the core identity of some of these people. And if activists' goals are actually achieved, activists usually have trouble letting go of their crusades, and so invent new ones or just become pure grifters. I can see no other explanation for why the most progressive institutions in America, universities for instance, are among those most frequently labeled as bigoted, racist, white supremacist or otherwise "problematic." Yes, highly contrarian take, but if we ended all political activism tomorrow, we'd be better off.
- nerdponx 6y agoI share your cynicism about what political activism usually is, but I find it hard to share your conclusion that we'd be better of without it.
- will4274 6y agoI can't say I agree fully with you, but there's definitely something about today's activists that seem odd. MLK protested in suits and ties to convince the american public blacks were respectable citizens who deserved equal protection under the law. When BLM rioted, activists went on TV to tell the lay public that "riots are the language of the unheard" and that white America basically deserved it. Whether that's true or not... It seems to me that the core aspect of political activism in a democracy is *convincing other people*. I see very little focus on this aspect and far more focus on accusing others of wrong think.
- flir 6y agoTo avoid the subject is to, implicitly, side with the status quo. "Everything is political", even the choice to avoid politics.
- gedy 6y agoOnly in your belief system. Not mine and others.
- nerdponx 6y agoConsider that this might be a privileged perspective. Not everyone has the luxury of being able to carry out their lives regardless of what happens in politics.
- will4274 6y agoIn my experience, the people saying "the ability to not pay attention to politics is privilege" are typically privileged rich white women, not oppressed minorities - those people don't like talking about politics in knitting club. Just a sample size of one.
- nerdponx 6y agoAnd in my experience, it's trans people, DACA recipients, people with dark skin, and people who identify as queer.
- KittenInABox 6y agoI very much agree with this in principle, but I think there are limits to it too. If a user who uses they/them joins your community and talks about yarn and patterns, referring to the user will always be political unless you ignore them or don't use pronouns around them, which is also political. And then whether or not the user is allowed to participate might be political- some users might be highly uncomfortable with a they/them pronoun user even participating and want a community "without those politics".
- leoedin 6y agoWhy does that user have to reveal any pronouns on the web? The default state of web based communication is ungendered. I have no idea what your pronouns are. If I was referring to you in a comment thread I would have to use "they/them" (or maybe "KittenInABox"). That's not a political stance, that's just English.
- KittenInABox 6y agoIf the policy then has to be that everyone has to be they/them or no one can have pronouns/correct anyone else about pronouns, then that itself is a political stance. Some things are just unavoidable.
- luckylion 6y agoThat feels like an artificial problem though. On the internet, nobody knows you're a dog. It's relatively easy to pass as any gender, age, race or whatever you want to. Yes, it will be more difficult if you call your account Transwomxn or request that people use xe/xir to refer to you, but if you're SarahKnitting, everybody will just assume you're Sarah and into knitting and will use she. At that point, it might be the right call by the community to not accomodate those that want to focus their membership on their political identity so they can provide a friendly community about knitting for the SarahKnittings of the internet.
- KittenInABox 6y ago
- zefool 6y agoHere is the real clue in the article: > Cassidy has noticed a growing dynamic. “The knitting community has a big issue with people being very concerned that, if they don’t support a callout, they’ll be called out themselves,” she told me. “Not joining it seems scary to people.” I really have to say, I think this is a bad article. Not because it is badly written, or because it is factually wrong. But because an unfamiliar reader would get the wrong impression about what is really going on. Ravelry and the knitting community do have a big problem. But it is not primarily with political polarization per se. It's the community-oriented mindset that does not work at scale. The knitting community is experiencing what we all will experience wherever this mindset becomes dominant: homogenization and the enforcement of conformity. We need distance and live-and-let-live in society. It's not a family.
- PeterStuer 6y agoEvery problem can be modeled as an instance of a class of problems. This can be useful, but it does also detract from this specific instance of a totalitarian ideological attack on a specific community. In game theory the 'punish those that do not actively join in punishing outsiders' is a requirement for group stability, and it has been a staple tactic in every totalitarian regime.
- smt88 6y agoIt's not a family, but it is a republic, and there are people across the country from me who are not letting others live (using their votes). "Live and let live" doesn't work when we have people trying to deprive us of rights, either with their vote or by doing things like traveling across the country to attack the federal capitol.
- busterarm 6y agoAlternatively, people in Oklahoma and people in New York don't want the same things, don't share the same values and should be free to choose to self-govern in different ways. "Right to Travel", as in the right to move and relocate between states, is a well-established legal doctrine. Go live where it suits you. Don't force other people to live how it suits you.
- flir 6y agoGermane: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041 I like the model proposed. But... unherd. Read critically.
- baryphonic 6y ago> But... unherd. Read critically. I'm not quite sure I understand. Are you saying this because UnHerd confirms your priors? Or is there some reason to demur on their credibility?
- flir 6y agoIt's one of those "follow the money" deals. The theory's really attractive, I like the theory, but its starting point is to assume everyone acts in bad faith.
- twic 6y agoGreat header image!
- h2odragon 6y agoSurely, other competing "crafting" communities aren't subject to subversion and propaganda from, say, Etsy, for example. Or other, competing, more lucrative organizing efforts. My wife was a cheerful producer of original knitting patterns, free and commercial, for several years before this stuff started to happen. She just stopped talking about knitting online altogether, for a while. Now she's careful to only post knitting on Facebook to a limited audience.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI subscribe to the Unix Philosophy when it comes to groups/institutions, "do one thing and do it well" and "It just does exactly what it says on the tin and no more". My ideal knitting community is all about honing the craft and experience of knitting. Politics does not belong in a knitting forum. Besides being irrelevant to needlework, it's the most polarizing and contentious subject for a group to adopt. Why risk a schism, or make people feel marginalized based on an irrelevant worldview? Sadly, contemporary activists want politics to permeate through every aspect of society because they believe that's the best way to advance their agenda. Maybe they're right, because it forces people to tribalize and it makes the 'enemy' in the culture war easy to rally against.
- compiler-guy 6y agoKnitters often include political messages in their patterns. From rainbows to certain shades of purple to flags to actual text. So if the site is to allow arbitrary patterns—and that is its whole genesis—it will have to deal with political messages.
- paulgb 6y agoThat's fine as a Platonic ideal, but I don't understand how you get there in practice. In the context of the OP, is your stance that the pink hats should have been banned from the site because they have a political message?
- BitwiseFool 6y agoYes, I realize that my conception is a platonic ideal and the real-world application of my ideal is bound to be messy and there will be disagreement. In this situation it would come down to a judgement call. I would allow the patterns because they are knitting related. I don't want to restrict any user's freedom to upload a pattern - even if it's political. And I don't want to restrict anyone else from downloading those patterns. I suppose my desire to let people share needlework patterns outweighs my desire to exclude politics. I'm more concerned about user behavior around political patterns rather than the political message of the patterns themselves. To this point, I would be weary about any user who starts to agitate and evangelize. The key is how these users are behaving outside of those particular pattern pages. Are they intentionally trying to inject politics into other knitting discussions? Are they trying to recruit like minded people, or shaming other users who disagree? If so, that's when I would warn the user to stop, and then ban the user if they aren't making a sincere effort to be less contentious.
- jamesrcole 6y agoKathrine Jebsen Moore wrote three excellent, eye-opening articles about the knitting wars: https://quillette.com/2019/02/17/a-witch-hunt-on-instagram/ https://quillette.com/2019/02/17/a-witch-hunt-on-instagram/ https://quillette.com/2019/06/07/instagrams-diversity-wars-revisited/ https://quillette.com/2019/06/07/instagrams-diversity-wars-r... https://quillette.com/2019/07/28/knittings-infinity-war-part-iii-showdown-at-yarningham/ https://quillette.com/2019/07/28/knittings-infinity-war-part...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- compiler-guy 6y ago[Moving this to a top-level comment because ~everyone is commenting, “Just don’t be political.”] Knitters often include political messages in their patterns. From rainbows to certain shades of purple to flags to actual text. So if the site is to allow arbitrary patterns—and that is its whole genesis—it will have to deal with political messages. This isn’t even the old trope, “Everything is political.” This is people making political statements and propaganda via knitting. Don’t be political is not a great option. The article even talks about the history of hidden messages in knitting. Getting rid of all or even most of it is not an option.
- speeder 6y agoThe article mentioned a redesign issue with t he site. I got curious, never been a user of the site, so I went to the login screen, saw the "play" button in the corner, and pressed it. The animation is nothing special, just using scaling I think to make baloons look like they are moving... But whoa, how I felt sick looking at it. And I have no clue why, tested a couple more times, press play, get sick, stop animation, I feel fine... The contrast looks fine-ish to me, the drawings are fine, there is nothing flashing, yet as soon I see the baloons becoming big and small repeateadly, I get sick. I am a designer, so now I am very, VERY curious about how that happened, I searched all over the place but no answers sadly.