4 ms·
It's absolutely certain that Dual_EC_DRBG was used as an NSA back door. The NSA went out of their way to force it into a bunch of products, which is weird enoug
by jiggawatts 6y ago
It's absolutely certain that Dual_EC_DRBG was used as an NSA back door. The NSA went out of their way to force it into a bunch of products, which is weird enough. Many "experts" dismissed the risk, because they claimed that the only real "danger" was that if the internal state of the RNG were to leak out over the wire, it would be trivial for the NSA (given their private key) to crack encryption of VPNs. No leak, no risk.
Juniper had a vulnerability in their VPN products. That little fiasco involved Chinese hackers having replaced the Dual_EC_DRBG public key with their own backdoored public key! When that was disclosed many security researchers suddenly took a keen interest in the Juniper VPN code and discovered that it "accidentally" leaked just the right number of bytes of RNG state into the initial connection packets.
Look.
Just... sigh.
If you're outside of the United States and you purchase any security product made by a US company, just assume that device has an NSA back door and is being used to spy on you. Juniper VPNs definitely were. Similar VPN products from Cisco most likely were. RSA hardware tokens had an insane design where they used a "tree" of keys where RSA had a root key to could be used to emulate any key fob. Three guesses as to why they needed to do that instead of simply generating standalone unrelated key pairs per fob?
Similarly, anything you store on Azure, AWS, Office 365 or G Suite should be considered compromised by the US. Encryption my ass. They have a copy of your encryption key!
- EMM_386 6y agoIf anyone is curious, here's some info on the Juniper situation: https://www.wired.com/2015/12/researchers-solve-the-juniper-mystery-and-they-say-its-partially-the-nsas-fault/ https://www.wired.com/2015/12/researchers-solve-the-juniper-...
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> just assume that device has an NSA back door and is being used to spy on you Any reliable way to detect this?
- jiggawatts 6y agoIn the past, before pervasive telemetry and HTTPS everywhere it was possible for some kinds of spying. For large, complex corporate networks with a significant cloud presence, it is now impossible. A Cisco backdoor was found by a paranoid system admin about a decade ago. He didn't trust the vendor firewalls, so he passed everything through a Linux firewall and compared the logs using a script. Every "flow" reported by the commercial firewall was matched against the packet log of the Linux firewall. He noticed that when he called Cisco support, the logs diverged. There were suddenly inbound and outbound flows from his Cisco gear that it wasn't logging, only the Linux firewall logged the flow. He captured the traffic while calling Cisco support and quickly figured out that there was a hard-coded back door. When he raised a stink, Cisco released a patch... which just changed the password. When pressed, they basically said in a press release: "We were forced to do this, other vendors have similar configurations, and we cannot legally say anything more." Reading between the lines: Cisco support figured that it was oh-so-convenient to use the NSA-mandated back door for their own troubleshooting purposes.