3 ms·
Ugh. There is no real Discord alternative. Matrix is comparatively lacking in features, tends to be somewhat slow, and is not a platform that any kid can sign
by nerdponx 6y ago
Ugh. There is no real Discord alternative.
Matrix is comparatively lacking in features, tends to be somewhat slow, and is not a platform that any kid can sign up on for free and be chatting on any device within minutes.
I hope things will improve with Matrix, but for now I also hope that MS doesn't totally fuck up Discord.
Also slightly terrifying are the privacy implications. I never expected privacy with Discord, but now that MS is involved I expect that every interaction with the interface will be tracked, analyzed, and used to target ads at me. And is waiting to be exfiltrated in a data leak.
- cblconfederate 6y agoI would like to see an easy way to integrate Matrix to existing communities, and i think that is the niche they should be targetting, not standalone matrix servers that come and go. The federated login thing is really not something that web services should be doing, it should be provided by the browser or some public system. I currently use mattermost as discord backup/replacement
- kuschku 6y agoMatrix won't run forever (they're also burning through cash right now), and neither will Discord. All these platforms are only "better" than IRC because they're giving investor money away to kids. By the time the VC money is gone, we'll all be back on IRC. And all the effort spent on integrations with platforms that used predatory pricing to destroy competition, could instead have been spent on open protocols.
- nerdponx 6y agoMatrix is an open protocol. The problem with Matrix right now is that it's too difficult to self-host and Matrix-the-organization doesn't have the resources to offer seamless, Discord-like performance on their default/official instance.
- stryan 6y ago>Matrix won't run forever (they're also burning through cash right now) Matrix is an open protocol; it doesn't need a company behind it to continue existing, unlike Discord. If you mean Element (formerly New Vector), are they? I'd believe that they're not raking in the dough or anything, but they've gotten some good government contracts in the past few years so I'd assume they have some money.
- nerdponx 6y agoEdit: I misread the pricing page, see the reply below. Keeping my post for archival purposes. One problem with Element is that there's no "individual $5/mo" plan or a "you and your buddies pool your pocket change every month to keep a server up" plan. And the free hosts all have bad performance which leads to a bad experience. The minimum plan is $20/mo for 10 users. That's a bit steep for a group of kids to pool their money for, compared to old-school Teamspeak hosting. And I don't know of any company that I can pay for personal Matrix hosting, or any company that offers a Discord Nitro equivalent, where I can pay a few bucks a month and get this or that extra perk. Where is the Fastmail of Matrix? Also, the UX of Element flat-out sucks. It's like those "we have X at home" memes.
- stryan 6y ago> The minimum plan is $20/mo for 10 users. That's a bit steep for a group of kids to pool their money for, compared to old-school Teamspeak hosting. I'm not sure where you got that number, as the minimum enterprise plan is Nickel, which is $10 a month. They also have Element Home[0] now, which is $10 a month for 5 users, plus custom domain.element.io server. Costs $2 a month for additional users, and I believe they're adding more options. > And I don't know of any company that I can pay for personal Matrix hosting First google result leads you to matrix.org/hosting which lists Ungleich.ch as a non-Element option. I've seen at least one other place also offering it, but admittedly I do not remember their name and that's still a small number. > the UX of Element flat-out sucks Eh, to each their own. I don't mind it too much (the Android app is great for me) and it's getting better over time. [0]: https://element.io/pricing https://element.io/pricing
- pndy 6y ago> Matrix is comparatively lacking in features I'm curious, what features exactly you have in mind? The basic text chat feature is here, in both public and private form (tho, the concept of rooms for private messages is kinda weird) so is audio and video but I haven't tried that yet.
- nerdponx 6y agoIt's the little things. Integrations with Twitch and gaming platforms. Rich support for "bots". Fun custom emotes that you can use across all servers. Change your nickname. Server roles. Not to mention the default Matrix experience is somewhat slow and clunky. The client ecosystem just isn't great yet, and there's no free-as-in-beer homeserver hosting that also has good performance. Broke teenagers who want to talk about Javascript, anime, and keyboards aren't going to pay for or self-host a homeserver.
- kevincox 6y agoMatrix has much better bot support than Discord. Discord bots are nerfed users, you can't mention them (well you can mention their role, but that doesn't relate to the names that they are using in chat). Matrix as an open protocol has full bot support. In fact this is what makes bridging work so well, bots have access to everything that a regular user has.
- DreamScatter 6y agoZulip chat is better than discord