3 ms·
One thing that always striked me was the mad willingness of soldiers in WWI to jump over the parapet and plunge into the hail of enemy bullets. Where does such
by inglor_cz 6y ago
One thing that always striked me was the mad willingness of soldiers in WWI to jump over the parapet and plunge into the hail of enemy bullets. Where does such suicidal bravery come from?
But this article made me realize that it might be just preprogrammed in some of us, a legacy of the long forgotten ages when our forefathers regularly faced a ton of galloping angry beef with just spears. Possibly the tribes that would not even try died out from lack of food.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThere were many new technologies introduced in WW1. It's common to see film footage of soldiers in France walking slowly uphill into heavy enemy machine gun fire, so tactics hadn't kept up. Those technologies were perfected by WW2, using the Spanish War as a testing lab. What's interesting is that barbed wire is far more resilient to explosives than you would expect. Either you blow the fence posts out of the ground, or your infantry has to spend time cutting it.
- Leherenn 6y agoWell, refusal was considered desertion, and usually punished by death. Also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1917_French_Army_mutinies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1917_French_Army_mutinies, soldiers were still in the trenches but refused attack orders.
- ReadFList 6y ago>Where does such suicidal bravery come from? If that is something you're interested in, you would probably enjoy reading Ernst Jünger's Storm of Steel. Make sure to read the 1929 version. I believe there is only one english translation, by Basil Creighton. All the other editions available in the market are subsequent edits the author made, each one with a more pacifist tone, as the author got older.
- inglor_cz 6y agoI can read German. Thanks for an intriguing suggestion, will do!
- natmaka 6y agoIn the French army soldiers were served, before such assault, a fair amount of alcohol. Source: my maternal grandfather, who was a French soldier during WW1.
- wil421 6y agoThey had two choices be shot by the enemy or refuse an order and be shot by an officer.