4 ms·
As a materials physicist, I have no idea what you mean by this: > As an example, calculating the exact screening effect of a metal lattice from theory has not
by kergonath 6y ago
As a materials physicist, I have no idea what you mean by this:
> As an example, calculating the exact screening effect of a metal lattice from theory has not been performed to anyones satisfaction, particularly if you account for hydrogen moving within the lattice, or the lattice undergoing some deformation.
Screening effect from what? There is nothing surprising in the way hydrogen behaves in a metal. We can simulate that with great accuracy, in fact we do it all the time as hydrogen embrittlement is an important issue in metallurgy.
This type of cold fusion would require two nuclei overcoming humongous energy barriers to get close enough to each other. No form of motion within a crystal lattice or no amount of deformation is going to provide that. The energies involved are about 6 orders of magnitude short.
Heat is trivial to measure, we’ve been doing that since the 19th century. Neutrons are not particularly difficult either, we’ve been doing that since the 1940s.
- drran 6y agoThe idea of LENR is not to move hydrogen protons in a lattice, but to make it jump over imperfections, with hope that it will land into nuclei.
- kergonath 6y agoYes, but that’s not how it works. There still is an energy barrier to “land into” a nucleus, and tunnelling through that is just not plausible with the energy of a proton in a crystal lattice, again by more than 6 orders of magnitude. Structure defects do not magically create energy to give it to nearby ions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- drran 6y agoThe mass of the proton is 1.67E-27, so we have about 20 orders of magnitude to spare.
- kergonath 6y agoI can see one way the mass is relevant in this case: it changes the particle’s wavevector. It does change the probability of tunnelling through the energy barrier (lighter particles tunnel mor easily), but that effect is completely negligible compared to the height of the barrier. The energy you get from the reaction has nothing to do with the mass of the particles; not all mass is “converted” to energy. The mass energy of a proton is 931 MeV. The energy you get from a deuterium-tritium fusion reaction is ~14 MeV. Besides, this is irrelevant, as there is a ~1 MeV energy barrier preventing the reaction, which you still have to go through. If you’re implying that the energy from one reaction could be used to make another reaction happen, then yes. But when your atoms emit 14 MeV each, you don’t have a crystal, you have a plasma. And this is not cold fusion, it is just regular fusion, same as in a star or in a tokamak.
- drran 6y agoElectric field can easily create plasma at tips. Effect known as St. Elmo's fire. If material have impurity in the form of a tip in a cavity, then an electric field can create plasma in this cavity.
- kergonath 6y agoNo, it cannot. There is not a single instance reported of spontaneous plasma formation in a defect in a crystal, charged or otherwise. The electric field within a conductor is effectively zero: you cannot have the kind electric field required. This would be very easy to see if it were happening: the brutal expansion of the plasma would create huge stresses and its high temperature would melt the material locally. This is just not happening. You are also moving the goalposts again: there is no such thing as protons getting accelerated by a MeV just by interacting with defects; the mass of a proton is irrelevant; and you don’t have spontaneous plasma in a crystal. Nothing you’ve written in this thread is supported by reality.
- drran 6y ago> This would be very easy to see if it were happening: the brutal expansion of the plasma would create huge stresses and its high temperature would melt the material locally. This is just not happening. Local melting reported from the beginning for 20+ years. Quotes: Occasionally, energy density is sufficient to cause local melting.[87] Melting is possible because many impurities lower the melting point well below that of pure palladium (1554.9°C).[105, 106] In the course of these experiments, the Japanese researchers verified the existence of other phenomena frequently reported from cold fusion experiments, such as occasional releases of energy in the form of sharp bursts. Formation of small craters on the surface of Pd cathode during electrolysis in electrolytes based on heavy water is sometimes interpreted as a consequence of low-temperature nuclear reactions. In this note we discuss the validity of these statements. And so on.