3 ms·
> despite not actually trying to replicate the Fleischmann and Pons experimental setup accurately They (Fleischmann & Pons) did not prove anything in the first
by kergonath 6y ago
> despite not actually trying to replicate the Fleischmann and Pons experimental setup accurately
They (Fleischmann & Pons) did not prove anything in the first place, so after that the “not the true experiment” thing is a fallacy. There will always be too much of something or not enough of anything. You can never replicate exactly an experiment, but this does not prevent all of science from progressing and reproducing results. Physics does not care about who operates the experiment. So if something works only when specific people try it, it does not give any confidence in the results. In other words, it does set the bullshit alarm ringing.
There is no theoretical foundation for cold fusion, and no known mechanism for it to work. So even if it does exist, their stance of “just trust us, and let us move the goalposts about replicability” is just voodoo and, yes, bullshit.