3 ms·
...yes? In fact I don't see anything that's the same as real art. Real physical art is unique in the vast majority of cases and NFT's do literally nothing to
by crazygringo 6y ago
...yes?
In fact I don't see anything that's the same as real art.
Real physical art is unique in the vast majority of cases and NFT's do literally nothing to authenticate a physical object anyways.
- jedimastert 6y ago> Real physical art is unique in the vast majority of cases Forgeries are a thing, thus "authentication" > NFT's do literally nothing to authenticate a physical object anyways What does? If I got some kind of physical object that came with a physical piece of paper that says "This is totally legit" how is that any different?
- insert_coin 6y agoThere is no way, other than to actually watch the artist make the art piece in front of you and with no trickery to make sure something is in fact the original. When you realize that you'll understand why NFTs make no sense. Authentication is just the process of other people putting their reputation on the line to claim something is in fact what it claims to be; it is not absolute proof of anything. Authentication is not the word of god.
- lifeformed 6y agoBecause you're buying it for the object, not the peice of paper.
- phs318u 6y agoForgeries have been a thing yes. And many were so good that they fooled (and continue to fool) some of the foremost experts on particular types of art/artists, for years and years. And then an advance in a technique may mean the forgery is unmasked many years later. For a moment, let's leave aside digital art (NFT's have a role there). There is no way at all that an NFT can be reasonably "tethered" to a specific physical object in order to prove its authenticity. None as far as I understand it. Therefore, what's to stop me from creating a forgery a decade later (say for some art that's disappeared into a private collection), and claiming that the NFT relates to that? How does the NFT prove anything at all other than at a point in time, the actual artist used a digital signature to sign a ... a what? How do you create a digital representation of a physical object that you can tie to a specific object? It's not the signing that does it. And if we knew the answer, we wouldn't need NFT's in the first place. Let's say that the thing that the NFT signs, is a document of the provenance of the physical art. So? Experts get it wrong and provenance can be faked. The best thing that we've got that authenticates the physical art is the analysis and expertise that goes into its assessment - even though those assessments are occasionally wrong. They can in future be corrected. What does an NFT add to this?
- stephen_g 6y agoI can't tell if you're disagreeing or agreeing with the poster you've responded to. You both seem to have made arguments for why the NFT is useless in either scenario?
- crazygringo 6y ago> What does? ...how is that any different? That's exactly my point. NFT's aren't any different from the scraps of paper used today. I'm confused because by your tone it seems like you're disagreeing with me, but by what you're actually saying you're completely agreeing with me?
- berberous 6y agoYou seem to be using the phrase "real art" as an unstated code word for physical art, i.e. paintings, sculptures, etc. Is photography or digital art not art? What do you think of http://deafbeef.com http://deafbeef.com. Is that not art? In any case, I would disagree that an NFT does _nothing_ to authenticate a physical art. While, to be sure, an unscrupulous NFT holder could theoretically swap out a physical painting it is meant to represent with a fake, a holder of a claimed-to-be-original painting surely has substantially more credence to his or her claim if they also hold the non-forgable NFT that proved they acquired it in a legitimate chain of transactions.
- crazygringo 6y agoNo I'm not, I'm using it for any kind of art. I don't know what led you to believe otherwise. (I clarified "real physical art" because those are generally, though not always, sold as unique originals rather than signed replicas.) And yes, the whole point of authentication is about unscrupulous people swapping something out. Holding an NFT lends zero additional credence precisely because that's what the fraud is -- selling the real one to someone else without the NFT, while selling a fake one to someone with the NFT, and increasing your money. NFT's provide zero protection against such art fraud. Heck, if anything they make it even easier to perpetrate if the person buying the forged work with the non-forged NFT is led to therefore naively overlook the forgery!