4 ms·
>> Basically they were chemists, and their claims of fusion were based on misunderstandings of the physics. That's an interesting interpretation. My interpreta
by phkahler 6y ago
>> Basically they were chemists, and their claims of fusion were based on misunderstandings of the physics.
That's an interesting interpretation. My interpretation at the time was that they are chemists and ruled out chemical reactions as the heat source. They concluded it must be physics. Physicists then said "It can't be nuclear, it must be chemical" - forgetting who was doing the experiment. They seemed really arrogant to me.
And here we are 30 years later with it unsettled.
- gus_massa 6y agoThe problem of Cold Fusion is the lack of a reliable experiment. Compare this with high temperature superconductivity. If you get a time machine and go to 1985 and try to promote high temperature superconductivity, nobody will take you seriously. But a team discover one material and published a clear recipe to built it. Other team tried some variations, and discovered an easier recipe to build them and published it. So soon everybody and their dog was making new variants, and new variants, and new variants... A few years ago, they gave one in the physics' lab for undergraduate students, and we made a few measurements for a month carefully because they don't tolerate humidity. Until someone put it in a glass with water and ice to measure the properties at 0°C. Also, now you can also see the recipe in a video in YouTube by "Applied Science": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLFaa6RPJIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLFaa6RPJIU , the guy has some advanced lab, but nothing too advanced. The problem of Cold Fusion is the lack of a reliable experiment.
- phkahler 6y ago>> The problem of Cold Fusion is the lack of a reliable experiment. That certainly seems to be the case today, but it was not the case when physicists rejected the claim outright. In other words, the rejection came before the reproducibility problems.
- gus_massa 6y agoI can tell you exactly what the editor said after reading the first paper about high temperature superconductivity: fake quote> Nah. The nice thing about physics is that it doesn't matter if the community reject the idea. If you have a nice experiment that is reproducible and has clear and easy instructions, sooner or later the community will accept it, and you may get a Nobel price. If the experiment is weird and you are unlucky, it can take a few decades. Here is another weird experiment, with another weird result, but it's reproducible and has clear and easy to follow instructions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wu_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wu_experiment
- kergonath 6y agoThis is entirely unlike high-temperature superconductivity, though. We knew superconductivity was a thing in some materials under a give material-dependent critical temperature. Looking for compounds with higher critical temperature is not a major shift, or surprising in any way. Why would any editor say no when someone writes “look, we’ve found a crystal with a high critical temperature”? Had they published something along the lines of “we’ve seen this cool thing; we think it works that way; could anyone replicate this?”, there wouldn’t have been any controversy. But they did not offer any insight, their results were unreliable, and their interpretation was doubtful. It’s not because you don’t understand something that fairies must be involved somehow.
- gus_massa 6y agoWe had an explanation of superconductivity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooper_pair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooper_pair but it didn't apply to high temperature superconductivity. It took many years to get a good enough explanation of high temperature superconductivity, and IIRC there are a few details that are not understood. So it was surprising that someone made a high temperature superconductor. As far as I know, there is no theoretical reason to discard cold fusion. There are a few "cold fusion" method that work, like using muons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion but it's so expensive to create muons and they are short lived, so you expend more energy than the useful energy you can collect from the device. So (in 1985) both phenomena were in the same class, it was not theoretically impossible, but no one had shown a good experiment were they happened. > Had they published something along the lines of “we’ve seen this cool thing; we think it works that way; could anyone replicate this?”, there wouldn’t have been any controversy. But they did not offer any insight, their results were unreliable, and their interpretation was doubtful. It’s not because you don’t understand something that fairies must be involved somehow. Perhaps we agree, the problem of Cold Fusion is the lack of a reliable experiment. (And too many scammers publishing bad experiments and trying to get investors.)
- Robotbeat 6y agoNot every outlandish claim should garner the attention and respect from scientists. If you hide your "discovery," refuse to publish in scientific journals and be subject to peer review, if you claim "secrecy" is why no one can replicate your result, well, you'll be tossed on to the tall pile of folks claiming this or that physics breakthrough. Physicists have to deal with this kind of crackpottery a LOT. They don't owe you their time unless you have some solid evidence and full transparency. Don't want full transparency? Be prepared to be called a fraud. That's how it goes.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> That certainly seems to be the case today, but it was not the case when physicists rejected the claim outright. The claim was of specific results which were inconsistent with the people performing the experiment having survived it. The experimenters being alive to give press appearances was sufficient reason to reject that claim out of hand. That something else very interesting, but unknown, might have been happening wasn't rejected until after robust reproduction attempts failed to produce any evidence of that.
- selimthegrim 6y agoNate Lewis IIRC was at the press conference saying it wasn't chemical either.
- simonh 6y agoThe nuclear physicists were simply pointing out that the evidence F&P offered of detecting a fusion reaction, was not actually evidence of fusion. I dont really see what’s arrogant about that.
- drran 6y ago> The nuclear physicists were simply pointing out that the evidence F&P offered of detecting an [unknown] fusion reaction, was not actually evidence of [known] fusion reaction. See it?
- simonh 6y agoNo I don't, even if there is something unknown going on that has none of the known characteristics of fusion, why even say it's fusion? Why attach that label to it, especially when you have no actual theory of what is happening and why? To put it another way, why are you calling this an unknown fusion reaction? What's the basis for the claim that it was fusion of any kind? F&P thought that the evidence they had found demonstrated fusion. That it was known evidence of fusion. They were simply wrong. Saying 'well it might be some unknown form of fusion' is post-hoc rationalisation (for which you have no evidence or theory). That's not what they were saying at the time. It's so infuriating that 30 years later we're still fighting these fundamental misconceptions about what was going on.
- drran 6y agoWhy America was called West India? Why + is used for absence of electrons? Why atom called atom("unbreakable")? And so on. Discovery is not a science, but it is the part of science.
- simonh 6y agoExcellent thanks. That's very helpful as those analogies are very apt. The West Indies has nothing to do with India. Atoms are no unbreakable. Cold Fusion has nothing to do with fusion. I'm glad we got that straight.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Physicists then said "It can't be nuclear, it must be chemical" - forgetting who was doing the experiment. No, what lots of people (many of them far more prominent chemists than P&F said, not just physicists) is that, if honest, it had to be measurement error, not only based on abstract analysis of the described setup and results, but also based on robust attempts to replicate the claimed results.