3 ms·
Thanks for the thoughtful writeup. But I don't get specifically how this doesn't prove too much--even though climate is a complex system, we know (right?) that
by scarmig 15y ago
Thanks for the thoughtful writeup. But I don't get specifically how this doesn't prove too much--even though climate is a complex system, we know (right?) that throwing it into the center of the sun would increase mean global temperatures. But if I said that chaos and information theoretic arguments prevent us from making any predictions, I'd rightly be laughed off the stage.
What is the differentiating factor that makes those arguments apply to models looking at CO2 concentrations as exogenous forcers but not being-in-the-center-of-the-sun?
- jerf 15y ago"But if I said that chaos and information theoretic arguments prevent us from making any predictions, I'd rightly be laughed off the stage." "Information theory bounds our ability to predict" is not the same as "Information theory prevents us from giving any predictions". You could predict the temperature of "the Earth" (for some suitable definition) within some bounds, but if you tried to do it to within a tenth of a degree Celsius for a hundred years you would continue to encounter difficulty... rather more than you have right now, actually, I'm quite confident the Sun's Lyapunov constant will strip bits from you much faster than Earth's current climate does. Also, you're engaging in a bit of tautology without realizing it. The entire concept of "forcing" is one divorced from a chaos-informed concept of weather, it's part of the reason I really don't think they understand chaos. The "forcings" are themselves subject to the prediction problem, so you may be able to predict what the system will do immediately after the application of them, but you don't know what will happen later. In Earth's specific example, what if the hotter climate ends up triggering Yellowstone? Or that methane clathate catastrophe? Or something entirely unexpected? Much more realistically, what if the "forcings" tend to cancel themselves out over longer times? There's been a couple of good papers that suggest that all the water on Earth (oceans, etc) are very, very strongly effecting the climate by virtue of cloud production in the tropics such that it is extremely strongly forcing the climate to look the way it does now, and all your "forcings" may be nothing next to it. Or that may be totally wrong. By the time you're done caveating "forcings" in light of what a chaotic system can do, they aren't a very useful approach to the problem.