4 ms·
So, in the context of the bay, rather than paying my $3k/mo rent, I should buy a $1 million dollar home?
by whimsicalism 6y ago
So, in the context of the bay, rather than paying my $3k/mo rent, I should buy a $1 million dollar home?
- microtherion 6y agoIf you can afford a 20% or so downpayment (big if, I know), the two options might work out to fairly comparable (after-tax) monthly payments right now. In the longer run, buying will leave you potentially with equity and with a fixed rate mortgage will assure fixed payments. Even in a mildly inflationary economy, making fixed nominal payments on a salary rising more in line with inflation for an asset valued more in line line with inflation can be a fairly attractive deal. But none of the above is meant to be investment advice. Homeownership has its risks and certainly loses flexibility.
- pedrosorio 6y agoJust checked Redfin, a condo in SF for $1M with a 30 year mortgage at a nice 3% interest rate and 20% downpayment would be: - $3300 in principal + interest - $1000 property tax - $500+ HOA - $200 homeowners insurance That is $5000+ monthly and requires $200k upfront (and significant upfront cost as the brokers are paid off). How is that comparable in after-tax payments to renting a $3000 apartment?
- munk-a 6y agoThe math might be a bit different for SF - there are a lot of local factors to keep in mind (like that 500 HOA + Homeowners seems steep to me for a property that isn't near EOL) - but the biggest different at the end of the day is that the 3300 you're paying into principal + interest is still your money (well minus the interest) when you rent all 3000 you're paying is essentially throwing money into the void.
- o-__-o 6y ago5-10 years later you have equity, a portion of value of the home not tied up by a mortgage. You can refinance or sell and extract this money. You can then use this money to move into the $2M house you had your eye on.
- refurb 6y agoThe difference is appreciation. Otherwise owning is probably 150% the cost of renting in SF. And with rent control you don’t have the issue of rent going up.
- microtherion 6y agoI've never owned a house in the US, but my understanding is that the interest portion is tax deductible (whereas rent is not), which at the kind of salaries necessary for this housing is likely to make a sizable dent in this payment. I must admit that I had forgotten how high property taxes in the US can be, though. HOA surely depends a lot on what exactly you'd be buying.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoIIRC that was changed -- the interest payments being deductible -- as part of the Trump tax cut. The standard deduction was increased for everyone to compensate for it.
- refurb 6y agoNot only that, a 5% return on that down payment is a $833/month opportunity cost. Owning in SF is generally more expensive than renting. Why? Because house prices have appreciation assumptions already priced in. Plenty of people lose money every month versus rent but appreciation more than covers it.
- munk-a 6y agoYou should only ever rent if you intend to live in a property an amount of time so small that the rent you're paying out doesn't cover the exchange cost. And that assumes that property prices aren't increasing which they almost always are and generally at a pretty firm pace. Basically - you're trying to avoid the scenario where you live in a place so short that the exchange cost you pay to flip it on the far side exceeds the amount of rent you'd pay to reside in it. Determining the exchange cost isn't always straight forward - the 6% given above may or may not be realistic for you, there are some brokers that will take a 1% cut and those folks are more common in hot markets, and there may also be taxes you need to take into consideration. Also, there is a risk of getting stuck with a lemon - if you purchase a house which seems fine but actually has extensive water damage and mold you could lose a portion of the value, this is a really significant consideration in quiet housing markets (like the midwest) and less important in areas like SF where most of the property's value is likely the land itself - in either case you're taking a big chunk of the value of the structure out of the equation when reselling the property but in the later case the value of the structure is rather minimal while in the former case the land is essentially free. Basically you almost always want to buy if you are able to. The money you're spending on housing when you own a property is accruing as equity instead of being siphoned off by a landlord.
- frongpik 6y agoIf it was just about the money, it would be better to invest the downpayment into a margin trading account with 1 to 5 leverage.
- vkou 6y agoNo, because if you're investing on a 1-5 margin, the market dropping by 20% in two weeks, and then going up by 80% over the next five will leave you flat out broke. Meanwhile, someone not investing on margin will be up 60%.
- MontyCarloHall 6y agoNitpick, but they’d only be up 44%. 0.8*1.8 = 1.44, not 1.6.
- hedora 6y agoI faced that choice years ago, and chose to rent. It was a $500k mistake (over ~5 years). The condo was near Google, and it was a bit after 2008; your results will probably vary.