9 ms·
“Facebook was not an uninvited interloper to a communication between two separate parties; it was a direct participant,” the company said in a legal filing. Th
by nerdponx 6y ago
“Facebook was not an uninvited interloper to a communication between two separate parties; it was a direct participant,” the company said in a legal filing.
There's gotta be some existing legal doctrine on what constitutes a "direct participant", right?
Suppose I visit the website of Company A intending to do business with them (perhaps this is the only way to contact them). Their website contains the Facebook "like" button somewhere on the page. Is Facebook really a "direct participant" if I have no way to know that their widget is even on the site until I visit it, at which point they have already participated and I have no way to avoid it?
Likewise, does the law/precedent on "expectation of privacy" have anything to say about who specifically I should/shouldn't expect privacy from?
- fotbr 6y agoSome states allow "one party consent" to recordings of communications (ie, phone calls). Extending that, as long as Company A is aware of FB's practices, then your wishes are irrelevant as far as the law is concerned. I have no idea what California's laws are regarding the matter, or the laws governing any of the other participants. I'm just speaking in the general case, that some states allow it, and the argument that could be made.
- TrinaryWorksToo 6y agoCalifornia is a two-party consent state for wiretapping laws.
- rsstack 6y ago"California's wiretapping law is a "two-party consent" law. California makes it a crime to record or eavesdrop on any confidential communication, including a private conversation or telephone call, without the consent of all parties to the conversation."
- nerdponx 6y agoTwo-party consent is a funny thing. It's empowering to individuals in their interactions with corporations, but in this case it's clearly disempowering to individuals. Is "asymmetric" one-party consent a thing in any jurisdiction?
- tobylane 6y agoThe UK only requires notification from the company in a commercial call. The recipient can do so without permission.
- cgriswald 6y agoOne-party consent seems far more empowering to me. It lets me record any conversation I'm a party to whether the other party likes it or not. In a two-party consent state, the corporation just has a message that the call may be monitored or recorded and me staying on the line qualifies as 'consent'. I'm not provided with an option to talk without being recorded and for many functions companies won't deal with you except through these specific phone numbers. However, if I tell the company I want to record them, they have very little reason to humor me. In practice, this means I'm almost always being recorded anyway, but I can't generally record them back. It looks to me very much like corporations get one-party consent, and I don't. I've heard it argued that "This call may be monitored or recorded..." can be interpreted as consent, but I'm not sure how that works out in practice, especially since I'd be recording the individual employees (who may have consented to their employer, but haven't to me).
- prepend 6y agoOne tactic that seems legal is to play a similar message while the company’s robot is playing their message. Since the company doesn’t disconnect it means consent. Not aware of this being legally tested but seems like a stupid hoop to meet the two party consent jurisdictions.
- mindslight 6y agoThe message itself ("this call may be recorded") has given you consent the record the call, without needing to play your own version. The point was that this doesn't mean the employee themselves has consented. Then again, the caller could use similar reasoning of saying their assistant placed the call and waited on hold, and only then did they get on the line. Or really any phone conversation where a new party comes on the line after the recording has started. I think the call center employee would have a pretty hard time arguing some expectation of privacy regarding your recording, when their employer has made it clear that the call can be recorded. I'd be interested in any precedents to the contrary though. However, talking in terms of "consent" might just be a red herring. A company hasn't actually obtained your consent by playing a notice that they are recording the call. What they have done is destroy your expectation of privacy.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoGeorgia is the only state where only one person needs consent to record. I just heard that.
- whichquestion 6y agoThis is false. There are many other one party consent states. See https://recordinglaw.com/united-states-recording-laws/one-party-consent-states/ https://recordinglaw.com/united-states-recording-laws/one-pa... for more info.
- caymanjim 6y agoNot so. Only 12 states require two-party consent to record conversations. Federal law is one-party. There are caveats and rules around all of it, but on a board scale, most of the country only requires single party consent.
- LinuxBender 6y agoCalifornia is 2-party-consent [1] [1] - https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/california-recording-law https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/california-recording-law
- philip1209 6y agoPresumably - if states are defining 1-party vs. 2-party consent laws, then doesn't the 10th amendment imply that this matter shouldn't be handled federally?
- rossdavidh 6y ago...unless the communications cross state lines, which in this case they mostly do.
- legitster 6y agoThe key here for the purpose of the Wiretap act is that the website was the participant - they wanted the Facebook like button there. And the argument will likely revolve around whether the companies were cognizant of the implications of adding Facebook scripts to their site.
- kstrauser 6y agoNo one’s asking me to, but I’d testify that I absolutely didn’t know the implications back when I had share buttons on my site. It was a fun thing that almost everyone was doing, for the sole intention of making it more convenient for visitors to share my content that they enjoyed. Period. It absolutely wasn’t so that I could make it easy for FB and friends to track my visitors. It all seems so obvious in retrospect, but at the time there wasn’t a lot of pushback from people explaining why it was a terrible idea.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoImagine Mark Zuckerberg saying something like: You were stupid enough to not devine my intentions 10 years ago, so now I think the US Supreme Court should decide you are that stupid now too.
- oarsinsync 6y ago> whether the companies were cognizant of the implications of adding Facebook scripts to their site. I’m inclined to believe Backblaze were not cognisant of the implications of adding Facebook scripts to their site, given the speedy (~12hr) turnaround on resolving once brought to their attention. If tech companies are unaware, what are the odds that the majority of other companies are? Discussion from here earlier today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26536019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26536019
- legitster 6y agoThe lawsuit only applies to 2011, Although in Backblaze's case it looks like a situation where their web team made a mistake building a custom Facebook tracking pixel. They are 100% intending to send tracking information to Facebook.
- ehnto 6y agoHm, it's challenging because of the new medium but maybe we could discuss a real world analogue: You walk in to a home expecting to meet your friend, when you enter there is a man from the TV network there. You didn't expect him, his intention is just to watch you and your friend talk about television shows. Perhaps an example that gets closer to the crux of the problem: You're at a restaurant with a friend, and an unrelated stranger nearby can overhear the conversation. Not a participant, right? Now imagine they were sent to listen to you, and report back to the TV networks. I would say that, they have a very clear intention to participate in the conversation.
- nerdponx 6y agoYou walk in to a home expecting to meet your friend, when you enter there is a man from the TV network there. You didn't expect him, his intention is just to watch you and your friend talk about television shows. Maybe the analogy should be: you go to meet a local contractor, and a representative from the cable company is there to help advise on the work. Neither of you are aware that he is recording the whole conversation, and that will use that information to send you targeted junk mail.
- inetknght 6y agoYou're moving the goalposts. Here, let me refocus the goalpost for you. > I have no way to know that their widget is even on the site until I visit it You can ask, and expect an honest answer, from your friend about any TV news crew. And you don't really have an expectation to privacy in many restaurant settings.
- ehnto 6y agoThe analogy wasn't really about that though, I was trying to explore whether or not the third party is considered a willing participant or not, which changes the implications of the data collection. A stranger in a restaurant can't help that they heard you talk about something private, but it was entirely the fault of the person sent to intentionally record a conversation so you could say they willingly participated in the ordeal. Backing out of the analogy, Facebook willingly collected the data, it was entirely their intention to collect the data. So the responsibility of that data collection is theirs, and they were an active participant. I think it's important to set that precedent, because we all know the technology was entirely indifferent to what it was collecting, but we can't use the inadequacies of a technology and process as a way to excuse companies from responsibility. Holding them accountable would force them to get better processes and improve the technology so it doesn't happen again.
- nextlinemail 6y agoThe "direct participant" is the key phrase here. This is going to come up again and again unless we get this legally defined better. "Expectation of privacy" is yet another quagmire. Similar to obscenity - difficult to define, but I know it when I see it.
- coldtea 6y ago>Is Facebook really a "direct participant" if I have no way to know that their widget is even on the site until I visit it, at which point they have already participated and I have no way to avoid it? If you meet someone at some office for an interview or a negotiation or something, and a third party is there whose presense was not announced beforehand, aren't they a "direct participant"? And didn't you also had "no way to know that they would even be there" until you visited that location?
- gwerbret 6y agoIn the example you gave, I have the opportunity to interact with this third party, demand to know why they're there, and may choose to leave, with my privacy intact, if I don't like their presence. This is all part of the process of informed consent. Clearly this analogy, particularly with respect to "informed" and "consent", does not apply to a Facebook widget on a site.
- seanalltogether 6y agoCouldn't you apply this same logic to google analytics which has been embedded in most sites for over a decade?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Suppose I visit the website of Company A intending to do business with them (perhaps this is the only way to contact them). Their website contains the Facebook "like' button somewhere on the page. Is Facebook really a "direct participant" ..." The term "direct particpant" is not from the statute. Those are the words of Facebook's defense lawyers. The statute provides an exemption for a "party" to communication, but it does not define the term "party". The 1st and 7th Circuits, when faced with cases similar to this one involving third party "tech" companies that subsist on internet advertising, have interpreted the term "party" to exclude third parties such as Facebook. The 3rd Circuit however has interpreted it to include them. The 9th Circuit on hearing Facebook's case followed the 1st and 7th Circuits. Facebook wants the 3rd Circuit's interpetation to be the law of the land. The Supreme Court denied Facebook's appeal. As such, the hypothetical requires some more facts. Where is Company A domiciled? Where do they do business? What state do you live in?
- cwkoss 6y agoLol, imagining facebook's lawyers arguing, "Is a party really a party if not everyone is invited?"
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"... and I have no way to avoid it." There are of course ways to avoid sending a HTTP requests to Facebook, but not within the confines of the expectations of web developers where the user is expected and even prodded to use a browser deployed by an advertising company or one that tries to match it feature for feature. These browsers are ideal for serving ads. You could check for the "Like" button by first retrieving the page from an alternate source, with Javascript disabled, e.g., the Internet Archive. Even if you retrieve the page from Company A's site, unless you have Javascript enabled and use a browser that automatically loads resources, you can check for the "Like" button poiting to Facebook's servers by inspecting the contents of the page. (Note I have seen some websites host a Facebook "Like" button image on their own servers.) Checking for things in the contents of a page can of course be automated. But putting technical solutions aside, it is worth reading the 5th Circuit case that suggested Google was a "party" under the Wiretap Act.^1 In that case Google tricked iPhone Safari users into believing third party cookies were being blocked. Meanwhile they disabled third party cookie blocking in Safari by sending a cookie from a hidden form in an iframe.^2 The 5th Cir Court of Appeals noted that using fraud to become a "party" to the communication has no effect on the Wiretap Act exemption. If law enforcement can use deception to become a "party", Google can too. This is not to suggest Google was innocent of malfeasance. When Google's behaviour was first disclosed by a Stanford grad student in 2012,^2 the WSJ picked up the story.^3 This attracted the attention of the DOJ who filed a complaint. Google ended up paying a $22.5M civil penalty. State AGs also filed a complaint against Google. Google settled for $17M with 38 states. It was only when private lawyers in multiple states attempted to bring a class action suit on behalf of users that the Wiretap Act claims failed. 1. https://web.archive.org/web/20160126074106/http://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/134300p.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20160126074106/http://www2.ca3.u... 2. https://web.archive.org/web/20120217235344/http://webpolicy.org/2012/02/17/safari-trackers/ https://web.archive.org/web/20120217235344/http://webpolicy.... 3. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970204880404577225380456599176 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970204880404577225... curl https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/SB10001424052970204880404577225380456599176|grep -o "<p.*</p>"|sed '1s/.*/<base href=https:\/\/www.wsj.com\/amp\/articles\/ \/>/' > 1.htm firefox ./1.htm