4 ms·
>In its appeal to the Supreme Court, Facebook said it is not liable under the Wiretap Act because it is a party to the communications at issue by virtue of its
by duxup 6y ago
>In its appeal to the Supreme Court, Facebook said it is not liable under the Wiretap Act because it is a party to the communications at issue by virtue of its plug-ins.
That would be kinda scary if allowed. I would think / hope that as an individual that I would need to actually know that someone is a party to the conversation... the idea that Facebook could just say "well you logged in this one time so now we're party who god knows what ..." would be pretty horrible if legally accepted.
Granted, from a tech standpoint, that's also kinda how it is :(
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis is an incredible opportunity to set the legal precedent to make the tech standpoint no longer acceptable, and hence, compel it to change.
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoThis is a dangerous plan. The same logic applies to "Let's make sure that other party chooses the worst possible candidate, thus compeling everyone to vote for the candidate we prefer in the general election." Or "let's present our boss with two options, the correct one and also an absolutely awful one, thus ensuring that they will select the correct option."
- duxup 6y agoIn this case Facebook already is the worst possible candidate ... and is doing the thing and arguing they're a party to the conversation.
- alistairSH 6y agoI'm not sure how telling Facebook (or Google) "you can't spy on people just because a page has a link to your widget" is even remotely the same as gaming an election?
- anticristi 6y agoWould this have implications on Google Analytics? I didn't agree to them knowing what URLs I visit.
- alistairSH 6y agoPossibly. I'm ok with that too. If a site wants that info they can pay for it (vs trading their own visitor's data for the service). IANAL, IMO, etc.... in terms of how I feel personally about the use of my browsing data, a lot depends on the scope of what/where/who I'm visiting. I don't have much expectation of privacy for simply visiting a site - some unique tracking ID gets passed around, ok, I can live with that. To me, the meatspace equivalent is a neighbor telling another neighbor they saw me at the supermarket. But, once I start actively engaging on the site - buying things, entering PII for some reason, posting in a forum - my expectation of privacy is higher (even if the reality isn't the case). I don't want that info traded without my consent.
- Griffinsauce 6y agoGood, we need some plans that are dangerous to the status quo.
- IncRnd 6y agoThe two situations are entirely separate. What you, essentially, wrote is that there is no difference between gaming an election and the privacy afforded by a wiretapping statute.
- nicefedora 6y agoThis is a textbook false dichotomy. We could change the laws around digital privacy to reflect an infinite combination of policies, it is not a choice between two options. The point is that Facebook's position should not be the default policy. What makes this case particularly exciting to me is that it feels like a step in the direction of bottoms-up protections for citizens, as opposed to top-down regulation of corporations, which I believe is the better path forward.
- cwkoss 6y ago> The same logic applies to "Let's make sure that other party chooses the worst possible candidate, thus compeling everyone to vote for the candidate we prefer in the general election." Interestingly, wikileaks dumps revealed that exactly this occurred in 2016. Google "pied piper strategy" for the relevant coverage. Spoiler alert: didn't work out quite as they expected.
- btown 6y agoTypically when you hear "This call may be recorded for quality assurance" you don't hear the brand name of the telephony product used to record the call, or the system that might transcribe the call, or the regulatory auditing system that takes those transcripts and makes them searchable across users for words that might raise red flags. Nor would you expect to. But therein lies the slippery slope: where does that system end, which places people into buckets based on the content of those calls, and a system begin where data sharing between these "wiretapped calls" is used for ad targeting? If you extend this to the web - must every site where clickstream data ends up in a hosted version of Snowflake, visually display that it uses Snowflake? We can use intuition to "call it when we see it" but that's very hard to ensconce into law in a consistent and predictable way, without ending up in a situation where there's an even worse overload of disclaimers than American drug commercials. And nobody wants that.
- ByteWelder 6y agoI think it's less about the data, but more about the consent regarding the usage of that data. At least the call message is honest about its intent, so you know what you're consenting to. The Facebook button, however, doesn't state that it's there to track your interests to advertise to you more effectively.