3 ms·
The fact NPR and every other news source had to break it down for begrudging acceptance really hurts it's message. Not necessarily. Provocative statements can
by jfengel 6y ago
The fact NPR and every other news source had to break it down for begrudging acceptance really hurts it's message.
Not necessarily. Provocative statements can drive engagement by the extremes without costing you the moderates. This has worked really well for the right wing in the US, whose moderates flocked to a candidate who often offended them and worked against their stated priorities, rather than vote for a moderate candidate from the other party.
Moderation is good governance but often bad politics. It's boring, and people can't be enthusiastic about it.
The left and right are not symmetric with respect to that, and it's hard to tell whether "defund the police" is a slogan that usefully shifts the Overton window or merely demoralizes the center-left. It is certain, though, that it doesn't really matter what it does to the center-right: they are very unlikely to vote for even the most centrist candidate from the nominally left wing party.
So you could say that the fact that NPR has to explain it is more useful than more moderate measures that would get less airtime. It's nearly impossible to quantify that, but it shouldn't be dismissed out of hand, either.