29 ms·
Kidnapping provides a useful service and should be legal. Schools, kindergardens and parents with poor security practices deserve to be punished for their negli
by detaro 6y ago
Kidnapping provides a useful service and should be legal. Schools, kindergardens and parents with poor security practices deserve to be punished for their negligence.
- bena 6y agoIt also ignores the perverse game being played. Defense has to work every time. Attackers just have to get through once. That's a game that favors the attackers.
- 7786655 6y agoGame 1: Every time offence scores, they get $100 of defense's money. Game 2: Every time offence scores, they get $100 of my money. Defense loses nothing. Neither is fair to defence, but game 2 is unfair to me, and that's what's important.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bena 6y agoBut what you are advocating for is a game in which if you aren't perfect, you are harshly punished. I just hope no one ever holds you up to the standards you demand of everyone else.
- djmips 6y agoIt's a wonder our own immune systems work as well as they do...
- pyrale 6y agoThe thing is, it doesn't. Also, the thing is, our immune system isn't exempt from false-positives. I'm not sure we want a society with as many false-positives.
- ChainOfFools 6y agojust as fences must be erected to encircle the entire property they guard, rather than just one or two small segments erected to block specific approaches.
- 7786655 6y agoSchools, kindergartens and parents have a legal responsibility for children under their protection. However it has been repeatedly proven that businesses who allow enormous amounts of user's personal and financial data to be leaked will suffer no meaningful consequences. See: Yahoo!, Target, Experian, etc.
- detaro 6y ago"I don't like how these people aren't punished how I want, so let's sanction crime against them" is a ... questionable concept, to phrase it nicely. Lot's of nasty precedents. Are you sure kindergardens are punished reliably enough for lapses of security? Also: Ransomware gangs also target companies that do not have "enormous amounts of user's personal and financial data". Since too many companies didn't pay ransomware gangs now have taken to stealing data in addition - are you fine with a ransomware gang selling your personal data then, because they are "helping"?
- 7786655 6y agoNo, but the alternative is that they would have stolen the data anyway. So it's either neutral or positive. >let's sanction crime against them If it were legal it wouldn't be a crime. >Are you sure kindergardens are punished reliably enough for lapses of security? Given that I rarely hear about children being kidnapped out of kindergartens, I would assume so. I'm not well educated on this, though, since I don't have a personal stake in the matter.
- detaro 6y ago> No, but the alternative is that they would have stolen the data anyway. No it's not, but because random data stealing is a lot less lucrative than ransoming.