6 ms·
Britain is one of the fastest vaccinating countries in the world. Maybe THE fastest (they're over 50% adults vaccinated already), ignoring smaller countries lik
by dragontamer 6y ago
Britain is one of the fastest vaccinating countries in the world. Maybe THE fastest (they're over 50% adults vaccinated already), ignoring smaller countries like Israel who don't have to worry about scale quite as msuch.
Britain erred on the side of faster rollout: many countries criticize them for rushing AZ's vaccine approval process actually.
Because Britain somewhat rushed the vaccine rollout, its probably not a fair comparison to other countries. USA vs EU is probably a better comparison (but maybe not, because USA has a *dominating* industrial base and can physically make more things than most other countries)
- tinus_hn 6y agoMost western countries could have easily afforded to build their own factories but they cheapened out and didn’t want to spend the 10 million for a one off factory. That’s a lot harder to defend than throwing 100 million a day out of the window on lockdowns.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe factories needed to be set up last year, before the vaccines were approved. IIRC, there were well over 20+ vaccines in the USA alone that were being developed. I dunno about other countries... it turned out that the mRNA (Pfizer / Moderna) and adenovirus (J&J / AstraZeneca) seem to have been the fastest at production. Everyone who spent $Millions on other vaccines are still waiting for those tests to finish. Only if you were lucky enough to pick Pfizer / Moderna / AZ / J&J are you actually winning in the vaccine race right now. At this point, its looking like if you bet on the wrong vaccine, you lost your entire investment. ------------- USA spent billions on building "all the above". We have millions of AZ-doses sitting on the shelves, waiting for final approval (final tests just finished this past week). UK ordered 4-doses per person (when only 2-doses are needed, and even though its not known if children can safely take the vaccine yet). That's another reason why UK is so fast: they aggressively bought extra vaccines at an extreme rate. UK plans to either sell, or donate, those extra vaccines later on. By buying so much extra vaccine, UK ensured that they are at the front of the line when it comes to vaccine supply from the various companies.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoCanada ordered 9.6 doses per person, and we're substantially behind the US/UK.
- bluGill 6y agoYeah, six months ago I thought Canada would do best because they ordered the most choices. In hindsight I now know they should have ordered less and instead invested in a supply chain for what they ordered. It would have been more of a gamble though. I wonder if they could have built a MRNA plant that could flex to moderna or Pfizer, and similar for the other 4 vaccine technologies (that I can't spell), even though only two are significant so far. (With promising futures for the others )
- bryanlarsen 6y agoConsidering it's taking 18 months to build a NovaVax plant, I don't think a plan based on domestic production would have helped.
- bluGill 6y agoPlants can be built faster if you are willing to pay more.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoCanada is spending $170M on this one. I don't think more money would help.
- oezi 6y agoThe US didn't spend significantly more than Europe, nor did the UK, but both did so a bit earlier and with more nationalistic approaches. Due to the production ramp this leads to 2-4 months delay for Europe. Still better than Canada or Mexico. That German Biontech was allowed to partner with Pfizer will probably have cost 100000 European lives at the end, while saving 200000 American ones.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIt takes more than money to build a factory. Canada started refitting an old GSK factory to make vaccines in May 2020. It'll be ready November 2021. I'm not sure where your $10M number comes from, Canada is spending CAD170M (USD135M).
- pacificmint 6y ago> Maybe THE fastest Almost, but not quiet. As of 3/21 Britain has done 44 doses per 100 people. Israel is leading with 112, followed by United Arab Emirates with 74 and Chile with 44.31. These countries are all smaller than Britain though, as you point out. No country as big or bigger than Britain is doing it faster. For comparison, the US has done 37 per 100, while most of the EU countries are between 12-13. Hungary is at 21, because they have not only used the EU provided vaccines, but also using the Russian vaccine.
- phnofive 6y ago112/100?
- dragontamer 6y ago2-doses needed per person for Pfizer, Moderna, and AZ vaccines. So 200 doses per 100 people is the finish line. (Except now that USA just released J&J's single-dose vaccine, things got complicated...)
- ars 6y agoFor Israel it's actually 140 is the finish line because kids under 16 can't get it yet. They are pretty close - around 115 right now. They are hoping to start immunizing 12-16 in about 1 to 2 months.
- dragontamer 6y agoI'm under the assumption that child-vaccinations will be proven safe within the next few months, so the finish line at that point will be moved to ~200 doses per person.
- ars 6y agoIn the next few months will only be 12-15. Younger ages will follow (next is 6-11), but not that fast.
- DrBazza 6y agoThe AZ was the second vaccine to be approved after the Pfizer one at the beginning of December, and then Moderna was approved days later. All of the vaccines passed through the standard clinical trials and phases and were approved by the MHRA using the same process that would be applied to any other vaccine. The vaccine testing and approval was fast because layers of bureaucracy were removed (e.g. writing proposals, securing funding, finding volunteers). It's not fair to say that the UK rushed either the approval or the rollout. It's a bit like saying Usain Bolt rushed to win the 100m. Someone has to do it first. The UK approval process is one of the most stringent in the world.
- dragontamer 6y ago1. USA only finished its trials this past week of AZ's vaccine, and those trials took place basically the same time as the UK's. In contrast, UK approved the vaccine in December 2020. The 3-months of difference between the two countries is pretty pronounced, no matter how you look at it. 2. https://www.businessinsider.com/uk-approved-pfizer-covid-19-vaccine-too-quickly-eu-politicians-2020-12?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/uk-approved-pfizer-covid-19-... I remember articles at the time that highly criticized the UK's rollout of AZ vaccine. 3. It probably doesn't matter: the USA has found AZ to be very safe and highly effective: in fact, the USA's trials suggest a 79% efficacy rate (while the UK's own trial numbers were in the 60s). So if anything, the AZ vaccine has been proven to be safer and better in the tests on our-side of the Atlantic. The issue is that extra 3-months of difference. Whether December 2020 approval was premature or not.
- DrBazza 6y ago> The issue is that extra 3-months of difference. Whether December 2020 approval was premature or not. And yet the USA approved the Pfizer vaccine on Dec 11, only a week after the UK. I'm not sure why there's a 3 month difference in approving the AZ vaccine, but I do know that the USA has some particularly draconian import rules on foreign medicines, especially untested ones, so perhaps extra bureaucracy, and almost certainly a different testing regime for medicines to the UK and EU. I'm satisfied that the UK MHRA and JVI have satisfactorily assessed the data from AZ, Pfizer, Moderna, (and Novavax). They're world experts in their fields.
- dustinmoris 6y agoI'm not British, but I live in Britain and I can guarantee you that the vaccine rollout hasn't been rushed. The difference was that Britain invested early on in multiple vaccines, created a whole new government task force with the only job to get the country vaccinated, they collaborated between AstraZeneca and the University of Oxford in trials and the MHRA (which itself is one of the best if not the best medical regulator in the world) was running a lot of the approval checks in parallel which the EU and other regulators didn't do. Additionally the UK evaluated all data regarding the new COVID-19 vaccines and what we historically know from other vaccines that the chances of an initial one-jab strategy were extremely high almost to a point where it would be irresponsible to not first vaccinate as many people with one jab as possible. For once the UK put science and common sense above red tape and nationalistic rhetoric unlike many leaders in the EU like Macron or Ursula Von Der Lying.
- noir_lord 6y agoExactly, they botched multiple other things but on this they got it right. I had my first AZ Oxford shot on Tuesday, I’m 40 and have health issues but nothing that is directly affected by COVID (though coughing is dangerous for me). Second one is due June 2nd, the first dose to as many people paid off, evidence was good it would but it was still a gamble with so many lives on the line.
- pmontra 6y ago> they botched multiple other things but on this they got it right This was the single most important thing to get right since 1945, by a large margin. As a EU citizen I must say that the multiple layered structure of the EU is not worse than any other one in normal times but it was a disaster in these exceptional times. Too many indirections, nobody responsible for anything, the people in charge of the vaccination procurement not there because of elections.
- benlumen 6y ago> This was the single most important thing to get right since 1945, by a large margin. Well said. It's obvious to me that the reason that the EU (and leaders of EU member states) are acting unpredictably at the moment is that they very well understand the gravity of this fuck up. It is an existential threat to the project. Pandemics have ended civilisations in the past.