3 ms·
I got the same impression. Flatpak seemed much more like 21st century static linking with some slowly evolving security features bolted on top. The other thing
by pydry 6y ago
I got the same impression. Flatpak seemed much more like 21st century static linking with some slowly evolving security features bolted on top.
The other thing I didn't get about the flatkill rant was why it didn't put flatpak in context. It makes much more sense compare the security of flatpak to that of appimage and snap than to look at flatpak as an isolated thing.
- stuaxo 6y agoYep - perfect is the enemy of good. For me the advantage of flatpak is that it makes things a lot easier to install, abstracting away all the detail between different Linux distros. The layering is good + because of immutability, you have a system that is a lot closer to the one the devs actually used. There is a little more security, which is a bonus too, but that's not the main draw.
- lrvick 6y agoTo be fair the default software supply chain integrity story and sandboxing of docker, snap, and appimage are also terrible. They all solve the same "problem". Without dedicated parties to maintain updates... like a distro, most of the packages distributed with these tools just make Linux less secure even if the tools themselves are useful in right context. The docs and authors of these tools are trying to bring to Linux the "go on the internet and get a random .exe" model of Windows which is a proven security nightmare.
- rkeene2 6y agoIf you like that concept, then AppFS [0] is even more interesting since it removes the "install" step. CernVMFS [1] is very similar to AppFS, though AppFS has more features. [0] https://appfs.rkeene.org/ https://appfs.rkeene.org/ [1] https://cernvm.cern.ch/fs/ https://cernvm.cern.ch/fs/