6 ms·
There's a lot of IoT stuff which doesn't reach out to the internet. You can also reflash some commercial solutions with open firmware. Also, there's quite a few
by viraptor 6y ago
There's a lot of IoT stuff which doesn't reach out to the internet. You can also reflash some commercial solutions with open firmware. Also, there's quite a few local only solutions using ZigBee / zwave that you can manage from Home Assistant.
- chrisBob 6y agoI think the I in IoT is really for Internet, so I am not sure if it counts if it is local only.
- tehlike 6y agoVpn
- unethical_ban 6y agoLiterally yes, but come on. "connected home" and IoT are so close in use case, and _because_ most connected home things are Internet-only, let's not pick at terminology too much. I would love to have a connected home that did not require _any_ external connectivity or web accounts. Why did I need to login with my Google account and enable location services to set up a Chromecast Audio?
- 8note 6y agoI imagine it enables Google to enforce location based licensing for where you can listen to certain songs at a given price point. Listening to a song in the forest is free, listening to it in a bustling street costs 10¢ per play because you're performing it to people walking by
- NegativeLatency 6y agoIntranet?
- Mordisquitos 6y agoSurely it would be IntranetS of Things.
- prower 6y agoOr you could just flip the switch with your actual thumbs. There's a discussion to be had to on placing every basic action on our daily lives on a finicky smartphone.
- tehlike 6y agoAutomation is what you are missing. I love that my light turns on in the hallway when sun sets. Or the lock locks/unlocks as I leave or approach the house. Or that I can see my camera over vpn.
- prower 6y agoI totally understand it for security, as ironic as it is (given the topic). For everything else though, I feel like there's a "honeymoon" effect in place, where the theoretical and immediate convenience overshadow the implications. To make a silly comparison, it's like buying digital videogames on a console instead of their physical versions, knowing you're trading immediate convenicence while giving away control, ownership and future availability. I would have much less problems processing IoT if the "I" was scrapped and optional by default. I guess I have an hard time understanding people relying on the internet at all.
- tehlike 6y agoCorrect. Most people like myself go with no cloud versions of smart home gear. And use vpn to have a lot more control. A camera that works only locally (dafang hacks + wyze), home assistant, zigbee/zwave for example.
- jabroni_salad 6y agoThat's definitely a popular stance in the community of people who care enough to join the home automation and general electronics community, but if 'most people' is a factor, Amazon's best sellers are all "works with alexa" and "no hub required", and all of those products will surely die when their cloud tenancy is turned off.
- GuB-42 6y agoYou probably mean home automation. IoT is connected to the internet by definition. Home automation is a mess, IoT or not. There are standards like KNX, but the problem is the same as it was 30 years ago when the idea of home automation arose: manufacturers want captive markets and can't agree on a single standard. As a result, I can't buy any A/C unit, rolling shutter, light fixture and thermostat and just connect them to my home network, the selection of "smart" appliances is actually very limited. I mean, home installation is thought out on the scale of decades, because renovation is a pain. People want something simple and reliable, that is the reason why some taps, switches, sockets, etc... are 10 times more expensive than others while looking the same and people still buy them. It is the complete opposite from what Silicon Valley is pushing.
- Qwertious 6y ago>but the problem is the same as it was 30 years ago when the idea of home automation arose: manufacturers want captive markets and can't agree on a single standard. I think the "solution" to this is some sort of open hardware system, where instead of someone manufacturing and selling for a profit, the design includes a standard set of parts you order, and then there's a very simple assembly, Ikea-style.
- viraptor 6y ago> You probably mean home automation. IoT is connected to the internet by definition. Home automation was just an example. I take IoT to mean networked not-general-purpose devices. The internet part is meaningless. If you use that IoT device in the same server room as the controller does it become strictly LANoT? What about private overlay networks? It was never about the internet as in public accessibility.
- cesarb 6y ago> IoT is connected to the internet by definition. Those who are old enough remember that the Internet is just one example of an internet. Quoting Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalization_of_Internet#The_Internet_versus_generic_internets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalization_of_Internet#The...): "The Internet standards community historically differentiated between an internet, as a short-form of an internetwork, and the Internet: treating the latter as a proper noun with a capital letter, and the former as a common noun with lower-case first letter. An internet is any set of interconnected Internet Protocol (IP) networks. The distinction is evident in Request for Comments documents from the early 1980s, when the transition from the ARPANET, funded by the U.S. Department of Defense, to the Internet, with broad commercial support, was in progress, although it was not applied with complete uniformity." So an IoT is an internet of things, not necessarily the Internet of all Things.