3 ms·
Or as if monopolizing a distribution channel allows you to charge rents way in excess of your costs.
by pydry 6y ago
Or as if monopolizing a distribution channel allows you to charge rents way in excess of your costs.
- ChrisKnott 6y agoWho are you accusing of doing that? YouTube?
- pydry 6y agoDo you know of any other video platforms with 2.3 billion active users?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChrisKnott 6y agoDo YouTube charge rents way in excess of their costs?
- viro 6y agoNo they don't charge rent.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThen it’s a good thing no one has monopolized distributing videos across the internet.
- pydry 6y agoThe 2nd biggest video sharing website has 10x lower reach and no ad network. I'm curious to know what counts as a monopoly if not that. The network effect has been good to google.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoConversations are futile if we’re not working with the same definitions and context. You wrote: > Or as if monopolizing a distribution channel allows you to charge rents way in excess of your costs. Defining “distribution channel” as a single company’s website rather than the internet would make “distribution channel” meaningless in the context of this discussion. It’s trivial to distribute a video with anyone all over the world in this day and age. It’s not trivial to make money from it. Google might have a monopoly on the mechanism that can be used to make money from videos, but that’s a different discussion than having a monopoly on distributing video.
- pydry 6y agoIf you're distributing ad supported video content where else do you go? Vimeo is the second biggest video sharing platform. They have 200 million eyeballs they can push to your content as opposed to 2.3 billion and no ad network. I don't think it's an enormous stretch to say that youtube own this market. >that’s a different discussion than having a monopoly on distributing video. I neither stated nor implied that they did.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI can entertain the idea that YouTube currently has a monopoly (or “owns the market”) on the service of connecting advertisers to small time content creators. Whether or not it harms society is something I have not concluded. I am aware there are negatives for medium size content creators who lack negotiating power, but also huge upsides to individual content creators who almost always cause YouTube to lose money. And I’m not sure what any alternative is, other than a taxpayer funded version of a YouTube, but that also opens a can of worms. > I neither stated nor implied that they did. Sorry, I interpreted “monopolizing a distribution channel” in the context of YouTube compensating content creators to mean YouTube monopolizing distribution of videos by content creators.
- pydry 6y ago>huge upsides to individual content creators who almost always cause YouTube to lose money. Not seeing the upside nor the evidence of YouTube losing significant amounts of money. >And I’m not sure what any alternative is Applying antitrust laws. We can thank the explosion of Internet startups and innovation to their judicious application to Microsoft in the late 90s (it tied their hands significantly).