4 ms·
He didn't say he agreed with it. He said "I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily pedophilia harms children." There is a wide gap between being sceptical
by roenxi 6y ago
He didn't say he agreed with it. He said "I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily pedophilia harms children."
There is a wide gap between being sceptical of a claim, and supporting its negation. Anyone who is applying critical thinking will occasionally be sceptical of things which are obviously correct. People were sceptical of the wheel. People have been sceptical of money since the creation of money. People were sceptical of soap. Many software engineers appear to still be sceptical of soap.
The age of consent in, eg, Brazil is 12 [0] so it isn't like the opening salvo of that paedophile party is so radical an idea as to be unthinkable. Stallman linking it is not an extremist position.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_age_of_consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_age_of_co...
- pseudalopex 6y agoHe dismissed opposition to it as "parents who are horrified by the idea that their little baby is maturing". And he said it's "illegal only because of prejudice and narrowmindedness".[1] The article says what most people would call the age of consent in Brazil is 14. [1] https://stallman.org/archives/2003-may-aug.html#28%20June%202003%20 https://stallman.org/archives/2003-may-aug.html#28%20June%20...()
- roenxi 6y agoStallman routinely misjudging what other people are thinking and why they are acting is not a matter of debate. Everyone agrees that he is bad at that. Terrible, even.
- pseudalopex 6y agoMocking anyone who opposes something goes beyond skepticism. So does saying people oppose something "only because of prejudice and narrowmindedness".
- roenxi 6y agoIf you want that to be the standard you can try to uphold it but you'll have little luck. These are political opinions and we just finished the Trump presidency. Political scepticism is frequently uncivil. There is a real and difficult skill to telling someone they might be wrong politely and Stallman does not have it. Furthermore Stallman isn't mocking them. He is making a claim about why people are acting the way they are and is probably serious in his claim. He's also probably wrong, but being wrong and mocking someone are different things. The full quote you're referencing is about a long list of things including "prostitution, adultery, necrophilia, bestiality, possession of child pornography, and even incest and pedophilia". Most of that is disgusting, but not anyone's business. I vehemently disagree with the idea that prostitution should be illegal, especially if my money is being wasted prosecuting it. Talk about bailing out a sinking ship trying to stop prostitution. Stallman was also probably wrong on pedophilia - even then depending on what he meant, he didn't flesh that one out very much. It isn't exactly a damning case against the man when there is one questionable (and vague) addition in an otherwise non-notable list midway down a very long page of random political opinions. Stuff like that being a major line of attack is why he is back on the board of the FSF - the attacks are over trivialities, especially compared to the remarkable success and prescience of his life's work.