3 ms·
I'm not sure you can reduce it to traits in the method you mean. I think mostly it severity. I do think stress can have something to do with it. I mean, there
by Noos 6y ago
I'm not sure you can reduce it to traits in the method you mean. I think mostly it severity. I do think stress can have something to do with it.
I mean, there is no "neat freak" trait; that's something people who don't have OCD use because they think that's part of what it is. It's more intrusive thoughts about contamination, and there isn't a spectrum of those traits. Like you can't really "train" yourself to not be contaminated, in the way autism people talk about training to deal with social conditions. Trying to argue against it reinforces the behavior. It happens despite you knowing its totally irrational
I think I get BAP if you mean "the condition isn't severe enough to significantly impair your life," but I can see similarities between my checking behavior and people suffering the same but worse; I'm just fortunate enough that it doens't occur frequently. The talk about autism though is a different kind of talk; the moderate or severe sufferers are different.
Like the person I mention never got better or could use coping stuff; he would if anything just end up unable to talk possibly because he was medicated sometimes. I understand I'm not a clinician, but there's a lot of "spectrum" behavior in things now; you have gender spectrums, sexual spectrums (asexual, demisexual, sapiosexual), and I'm not sure the concepts aren't just medicalizing normal variation or individual temperament. I wish i could be doing this for me, if anything.
- skissane 6y ago> It's more intrusive thoughts about contamination, and there isn't a spectrum of those traits. There is a continuum of intrusive thoughts – the continuum of frequency and intensity of those thoughts, the continuum of how easy it is to move on from them, etc. And a single individual can move back and forward along that continuum over time, in response to life events, development/maturity/ageing, and other factors. We say they have OCD if (a) they have enough frequency/intensity/etc of those intrusive thoughts, (b) the intrusive thoughts are sufficiently impairing in their everyday life, (c) there isn't some other disorder which better explains those intrusive thoughts. We draw a line on the continuum, and say this side is "OCD" (or maybe some other disorder), and the other side isn't, but that line is inevitably a subjective clinical judgement call > The talk about autism though is a different kind of talk; the moderate or severe sufferers are different. You mention "moderate" and "severe" – what about "mild ASD"? I guess what used to be called Aspergers syndrome? > Like the person I mention never got better or could use coping stuff You can't draw a lot of conclusions from a single person. You can't say that people with milder, less noticeable symptoms don't exist.