10 ms·
UK 'heading towards digital skills shortage disaster'
- steveprocter 6y agoreally! how? every person and their dog is becoming part of the gig economy, selling their everything online and finding ways to create a newsletter or some kind of tool. who are these people without digital skills?
- bambataa 6y agoEntirely anecdotally, a lot of younger people who grew up post-smartphones are adept at using tools they know but have a very poor understanding of how computers actually work. Teacher friends say they see kids not knowing how to use a mouse and jabbing at the (non touch) screen instead, which is kind of what I’d expect my computer-phobe parents to do. Knowing how to use a few apps is not digital literacy.
- cameronh90 6y agoI have heard exactly the same thing. The other thing to bear in mind is that we grew up in an era where nothing worked. Simply keeping my computer up and running on a day to day basis required a "computer whiz". Nowadays, phones and computers work properly nearly all the time. It's the same as when boomers make fun of millennials for not knowing how to diagnose and fix a faulty alternator in a car. That said, why don't most computers have touch screens by now? For many, many users, a touch screen is a far more accessible and intuitive way of using a device. My elderly grandparents can use a touchscreen but don't have the dexterity to use a mouse.
- cutler 6y agoEver tried writing code on a touch screen?
- cameronh90 6y agoYou know you can plug a keyboard and mouse into an iPad?
- cutler 6y agoBut your original point was about the advantages of using a touch screen, no?
- cameronh90 6y agoI was comparing it to a mouse rather than a keyboard. And also suggesting that being able to use a touchscreen but not a mouse isn't really the fault of the user when most consumer devices now are touch-based. But I'm not saying computers should go touchscreen only, just that it's probably time that a touchscreen is a standard feature on desktops and laptops. Microsoft Surface and Lenovo Yoga seem to be well liked by their users, yet there are very few desktop touchscreen monitors on the market. A touchscreen is just another input option, and you could continue to use your mouse and keyboard if you prefer. I certainly would stick to my kb/m - even if that makes me an old fuddy-duddy.
- runawaybottle 6y agoIt’s bullshit is how. The shortages are always bullshit and there is always a shit ton of competition anywhere shortage is described.
- colesantiago 6y agoanything with the headline of 'shortage' can be distilled into this translation: employers want people with high tech 'digital skills' for less pay. The UK is infamously known for not appreciating programming skills.
- emteycz 6y agoIs it? They still have best earnings (post-tax) in Europe... You have to count in contractors though. Where are better offers than in the UK? I didn't find any better even in Switzerland.
- colesantiago 6y ago> Where are better offers than in the UK? I didn't find any better even in Switzerland. India. Uber's doing very well there, lay the best engineers off and go there instead.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iagovar 6y agoNo offense, but you have to be quite adventurous for living in India.
- noir_lord 6y agoIt's very heavily dependent on where you are in the UK though (as with most countries) the delta between best/worse places is quite large.
- lmm 6y ago> You have to count in contractors though. Who the UK government made a very deliberate effort to squeeze with the IR35 changes. Now they're shocked-pikachu-face-ing that those contractors are leaving.
- yrgulation 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. No other european country pays as much as the uk for experienced tech workers. Although ir35 is taking a bite, from what i hear daily rates are going up to counterbalance the issue. However, the risk of outsourcing is real thanks to some silly measures.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoThe UK is eager to open up to its ex-colonies (India mainly).
- varispeed 6y agoEspecially now that our chancellor family owns Infosys and he already pushed changes (against expert advice and damning report from HoL) that put small local IT business at disadvantage. Telegraph also wrote they are looking for skilled workers in India indeed. Looks like these will be golden years for Infosys at the expense of locals.
- unishark 6y agoI was surprised when the article didn't pivot to the typical immigration proposals and narratives. Instead it actually did some interesting digging into what motivates young people to choose their career.
- Robin_Message 6y ago> The Learning & Work Institute says the number of young people taking IT subjects at GCSE has dropped 40% since 2015. 2015 being the year the IT and ICT GCSEs (which featured potentially little or no programming) begun being phased out and replaced with a more academically rigorous and programming-focused Computer Science GCSE. Unsurprisingly, this led to a drop in the number of schools offering "IT subjects" at GCSE because it is harder to find qualified teachers for it; and any change like that is likely to depress numbers at least temporarily, and maybe permanently if the new syllabus is objectively harder.
- hnlmorg 6y agoInterestingly my wife is a school teacher and frequently leans on me to create IT lesson plans for her school. She's smart so the issue isn't her capability to understand the subject, the issue is the lessens require teaching Python (originally) and Javascript (later) and the source material isn't very good at explaining programming languages to non-programmers who teach. So I ended up creating a new series of lessons for them that was easier to teach, still taught the fundamentals of programming languages, but was also more fun for the kids to learn. She works at a large school and had that school not been lucky enough to have a spouse who's a developer, I'm not sure what 120+ kids (per year group) would have ended up being taught. Not all schools are so fortunate.
- bertil 6y agoI would hate to oblige you, but if you could share either the principles behind that lesson plan, or the plan itself, that would help a lot of teachers. They might not always be strong on respecting intellectual property, but they sure love some on-line organisation. I know I’d love it to help “non-technical” colleagues understand that software is not a priesthood.
- tim333 6y agoThere are some good online resources. Udacity 101 and 102 for example https://www.classcentral.com/course/udacity-intro-to-computer-science-320 https://www.classcentral.com/course/udacity-intro-to-compute... Maybe the answer is for teachers who don't know the stuff to follow something like that? Not quite sure how that particular one would work with school kids - might be pitched a bit too high level.
- AndrewDucker 6y ago"British businesses aren't willing to train their staff in the skills they need, want universities to do it for them."
- maest 6y agoDigital skills really should be taught in schools/universities; at this point, they're something the average person should have at least a passing familiarity with.
- konjin 6y agoDon't forget paying reasonable salaries.
- iagovar 6y agoThis happens in Spain too, and I bet more countries are on the list. Universities can't train people in the lastest tech. It's not what they are for. That's the job of "Professional Formation" as we call it in Spain, and I know other countries have similar programs (Community Colleges, Trade programs?). Now, if you want someone with deeper theorical knowledge (uni) + hands-on training, you're either looking for people who engage in programming very early (not many, you have to compete for them) or you're looking for someone who wen't through both Uni + FP which is probably way less people. In the end, you'll have to spend money in juniors, like it or not. It's a fact of life. Which mean you'll have to hire senior developers (who can teach & mentor) and allow them to spend time and resources on this people. This isn't new, it's what trades have been doing for thousands of years. If you have the money, don't be a lazy fuck and do it.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoTo be fair, I think the role of universities has evolved but universities are still stuck in the past. Such a large proportion of the population goes to university these days that they aren't really just academic institutions anymore. Either they should be more selective, embrace their role as a more vocational institution or at the very least create courses/degrees that distinguish between academic and industry/vocational pathways.
- varispeed 6y agoThe problem is that salaries in the UK are not attractive as you quickly get on the higher tax bracket. This was made worse when changes to IR35 passed and now if someone works on a b2b basis is likely going to be caught by new rules and it means no more business expenses, having to pay employer's NI, apprenticeship levy etc. and no employment rights. Effective tax rate is above 50% in this case. Independent contractors were competing with companies like Infosys (of which Chancellor wife is a significant shareholder) and these changes pushed by the chancellor make independent developers less attractive for companies. In the end, especially during current situation, where it doesn't matter where you work, companies just seek talent overseas as the recent changes make whole thing too bureaucratic, expensive and the fines for non-compliance can be life changing.
- obayesshelton 6y agoThis is exactly my issue! I started contracting on £x per day, a year ago they put me In-Scope of IR35 and my day rate went down by 13% due to a cost natural approach by the client. I then have to pay tax on that. Before I didn't pay myself the whole amount as I wanted to save money in the company for a rainy day! I am now thinking about moving to the UAE
- varispeed 6y agoThis is indeed another consequence - you cannot raise capital for your company with your own work anymore. For example if you have a little start up idea you could have done some contracting and then have funds to develop it. Now you can either lend money to your company or look for an investor - it means you'll have to share your business with someone or be at mercy of banks. I can imagine this cut so many wings...
- Nursie 6y agoThis does seem to preclude developing a company from being a one-person thing to a bootstrapped entity in its own right. I know someone who did that around 05, it was very effective. Eventually he grew it to around 10 people, all of whom could be farmed out for contracts when the company itself wasn't quite cutting it. Perhaps a model of contractors collecting together in small groups to carry on, will work.
- bertil 6y agoI’m surprised to have not read anything about Brexit. I’ve worked at half a dozen software companies in the UK, and the majority of my colleagues were from the EU — many in situations that made leaving tricky. Other cause for concern, the lack of investment in the NHS: many have a spouse who is a health worker, or they have specific medical needs.
- Pmop 6y agoI'm more inclined to believe that the pay is just not attractive. Or, maybe there's some kind of tax legislation trap that prevents employers from offering attractive salaries, and/or drives people with high digital skills away to other markets.
- Nursie 6y agoOutside of parts of London (notably the startup-friendly zone in Shoreditch and the financial centre in The City to the south), and a few other places like Cambridge, programming is not that highly rewarded in the UK. Nor is it particularly well respected as a skilled discipline, developers are treated just like any other office worker and tend to be paid similarly. The programmers you find in most SMEs are probably not underpaid for their skill level and productivity though, they tend to be plodders, being paid to plod. It's a vicious cycle of low pay, low expectations and low productivity. If you want to be part of something that moves fast and pays well, you try to get into those places, or leave for another country (mostly the US, the pay in most EU countries is worse AFAICT). There used to be the option to contract/consult on an independent basis, but the tax authorities are doing their best to entirely kill that business model right now.
- qu4ku 6y agoThere is no such thing as IT skills shortage. There is a shortage of skills in some manual labour sectors, where you need to wait a few weeks to do the job because there is not a single (even non-)competent person WILLING to do the job. There is no shortage of skills in markets where employers can filter people by 'culture fit'.
- ppod 6y ago>a difficulty in making many technical profession seem appealing to young people, especially young women I wonder what is the effect of having the media tell people constantly for a decade that tech companies are evil organisations trying to invade everyone's privacy and mislead everyone as much as possible. They people who work in tech companies are "tech bros" who have no morals, and only care about making money, stealing private information, or spreading damaging and false political information. They are also sexist and racist work environments. That's the impression that a young person would get from media coverage (coverage written by the direct competitors of many of the tech companies). I'm not downplaying the problem of sexism and racism in tech companies, I just think that it gets outsized attention in the media compared to any other industry. For example, does the energy industry have a racism problem? Or the pharmaceutical industry? Yes the impression one would get from the media is that these issues are particularly bad in tech. It's not just the traditional media that portrays tech as evil either, its also the culture more generally in shows like Silicon Valley or the Social Dilemma.
- kfk 6y ago"We need digital literacy and common sense, not someone who can program a Raspberry Pi to control a robot," Mr Howell told the BBC. What is lacking most of the times in university hires is common sense or a good grasp of foundational concepts. People struggle with simple data structures or naming things or how to take notes. I think some University is still good but once you are 21-22 it is much better to move into an apprenticeship program or a job. Unfortunately for young people most companies are terrible at training new personnel so that is not an easy route either. I cannot speak of bootcamps but being detached from "real business" I struggle to believe they would work.
- ZephyrBlu 6y ago> What is lacking most of the times in university hires is common sense or a good grasp of foundational concepts In my experience, that's because universities don't care about teaching you critical thinking or making sure you actually understand things. I often see people say things like "university taught me how to think". Maybe at MIT, Harvard, etc they truly do. But my experience was that they just care that you pass your tests. Having any sort of fundamental understanding or being able to think for yourself was not a requirement, which is why I dropped out.
- kfk 6y agoThey also teach very siloed thinking so if I studied "Mechanical Engineering" I am not supposed to know how to do "Python Programming" unless I take courses. I think on top of everything else we need people that are not afraid to deeply learn new domains and can go a bit beyond the top 10 search results on Google.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoYeah definitely. I think the fact that degrees often have relatively strict structure also causes this. It's hard to do papers outside your domain.
- cutler 6y agoThe last time I heard about IT shortages in the UK I sent 30 letters to London secondary schools offering to teach Python classes and train staff. Didn't get a single reply and I have 20 years' experience. The UK education sector has its head up its ass - that's why there's a shortage.
- Nursie 6y agoWhen I was at school we did 'computing' classes, around 1993/4. They were effectively an intro to word processing and a paint package. Anything that looked anything like programming was feared as "hacking". Nobody had any inclination to look further and there was certainly no mention to us kids that one could have a (lucrative) career in the area. Wouldn't surprise me if little has changed.
- cutler 6y agoYes, I tutored my daughter through her PowerPoint GCSE around 2009 when all the schools had a crack deal with Microsoft and wouldn't allow OpenOffice.
- stuartbman 6y agoI learned Computer Science at A level (high school) on a new course specifically aimed to produce technically literate students to compete with the US and Japan. I enjoyed the course and I still use the skills I gained, but it really wasn't recognised at the time- many of my friends did the much easier IT A-Level which (more or less) involved knowing how to use MS Office products. They received the same recognition by universities and employers for much less effort.
- cutler 6y agoUnbelievable. I mean, I have experience of the Powerpoint GCSE with my daughter in 2009 but I had no idea it was also rampant at A-level.