5 ms·
Governments should just close the loopholes. In some cases, the loopholes people talk about are less loopholes and more the intentional way the law works. Thos
by bawolff 6y ago
Governments should just close the loopholes.
In some cases, the loopholes people talk about are less loopholes and more the intentional way the law works. Those in particular are the govs fault.
- neaden 6y agoAn accountant once told me a loophole is just someone else's deduction. I don't think you can even just go with the intent of the law, 401ks famously weren't intended at all, they were a loophole that are now viewed as a pillar of most American's retirement plans.
- jjeaff 6y agoYa, but there are a lot more ways to avoid taxes than just deductions. Sometimes going way out of your way and doing things like renouncing your citizenship or creating shell corporations or never paying dividends and just using corporate profits to buy back your own stock forever.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> > I think at a certain point it's fair to shame people for seeking out loopholes, even if they're technically legal. Not that they probably care. > Governments should just close the loopholes. Calling attention to the existing wrong — its existence, it's wrongness, and it's connection to the present state of the law — is a key part of changing the law, so such public shaming is directly part of that process in a democratic republic, though perhaps not in a regime where “the government” is an aloof dictator unconcerned with public opinion.
- bawolff 6y agoDo they do this though? I don't see anyone making specific policy proposals, just blaming "loopholes". What is the moral wrong here? Can anyone state it in a way that doesn't also apply to everyone else. I suspect that people are less concerned about loopholes and more just jealous that some people make massively more than them.
- londons_explore 6y agoMany of the loopholes were 100% known by everyone passing the law. They were often an agreement to keep certain stakeholders happy. For example, this year in the UK there is a special question on the tax form for if you are a deep water diver. Why? Because divers have a different taxation system put in place as a sweetheart deal for BP (who employ a lot of divers for their offshore oil rigs)
- jjeaff 6y agoI don't care in the least if someone makes more money than me. Good for them. But if they make significantly more than me and yet pay a significantly lower effective tax rate than I do, well then I get a bit annoyed.
- innagadadavida 6y ago> public shaming is directly part of that process in a democratic republic When the wealthy can collectively lobby their way out of paying taxes, this process is pretty much useless. The middle/lower class don’t care so much to do public demonstrations.
- brundolf 6y ago"Were I the government, I would simply close all the loopholes" "Were I the programmer, I would simply fix all the bugs"
- bawolff 6y agoI don't blame my users for my bugs.
- brundolf 6y agoNot for the ones they fall victim to, but what is hacking but the exploitation of bugs for personal gain? I assume you or your company would blame a user who exploits a security bug and uses it to compromise your product/business/other customers
- bawolff 6y agoMaybe yes, but generally if the company has been informed about the issue for a reasonable amount of time and refused to fix it, we blame the company
- stuaxo 6y agoYep, and yet the people in power often use these very loopholes and defund their tax departments.