37 ms·
Eh, this goes too far. Old organizations grow slow, new organizations can cut corners and the survivorship bias makes it seem like what they do is obvious and
by colechristensen 6y ago
Eh, this goes too far.
Old organizations grow slow, new organizations can cut corners and the survivorship bias makes it seem like what they do is obvious and anyone not doing it should have known better.
There are problems with these old organizations that had much of their foundations built on an initial project with unlimited funding to get to the moon as fast as possible. Those problems aren't easy to fix. Some of those problems are because funding is dependent on continually changing legislation and on top of doing things, the government-space-industrial-complex has to manage the government relationship.
- Azrael3000 6y agoI disagree. SLS has nothing to do with the Apollo program. It's built mainly from Shuttle parts, so everything they need is somewhat there already. If you compare that to SpaceX's starship which needed to develop a completely new engine from scratch, it's laughable how slow the progress is. But as somebody said it's a jobs program. And just because you need to manage a relationship with the government doesn't mean your engineers can't do a good job and there are clearly several issues (see e.g. https://mobile.twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1371488500902727687 https://mobile.twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/13714885009027...)
- chriswarbo 6y ago> Old organizations grow slow, new organizations can cut corners and the survivorship bias makes it seem like what they do is obvious and anyone not doing it should have known better. Startups cutting corners certainly has some truth (e.g. the drama around SpaceX's last-minute flight approval for its Starship tests comes to mind). However, that doesn't mean the incumbents' processes are free from such problems. For example, Boeing's new crew capsule encountered problems during testing. Investigating those problems exposed more problems which hadn't been spotted, and this worried NASA enough to launch an independent investigation into Boeing's development processes. https://spacenews.com/starliner-investigation-finds-numerous-problems-in-boeing-software-development-process/ https://spacenews.com/starliner-investigation-finds-numerous... Even this SLS test could be argued as 'cutting corners': it's a repeat of an earlier test, which aborted early due to the hydraulic gimbal/steering system going outside an acceptable safety margin. The difference between that aborted test and this successful test is that they changed the acceptable safety margin.