7 ms·
A Brief History of the Hedge Fund
- donaldo 6y agoGod bless them. Take so much flak yet are inarguably the backbone of our society.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LordOfWolves 6y agoGiven your username, bio, and the article itself, you’d think your comment is sarcastic, though it does not come off as such.
- bhupy 6y agoYou’re being downvoted, but hedge funds’ positive impact on price discovery is under-rated. Matt Levine (Bloomberg’s extraordinary finance opinion writer / jokester) had a pretty good articulation of this in a recent post about GameStop and Melvin Capital (https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-28/knowing-when-to-sell-gamestop-stock-at-the-top-is-impossible https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-28/knowin...): “The point of the stock market is to Enable Price Discovery or Encourage Capital Formation or something boring like that. Stock markets exist so that companies can raise money to fund their projects, and so that the smartest analysts of companies can work diligently and compete fiercely to put the proper value on those companies so that we as a society can know what projects are most valuable. Stock markets exist so that regular people can invest their savings in those companies, making everyone better off: Companies get funding to pursue socially beneficial projects; regular people get an ownership stake in economic growth. Or whatever. This theory has some obvious flaws in its real-life application, but it’s a decent theory. It is, if not exactly true, true-ish; it describes the fundamental underpinnings of the market if not necessarily its everyday operation. It posits a social purpose for financial markets, beyond making funny memes on Reddit. It is just the case, just inevitably the case, that if you are going to have financial markets that are optimized for those purposes—that are liquid and complete, that attract smart people, that are open to everyone—they are also going to have a certain amount of nonsense. It’s not like WallStreetBets invented financial nonsense! Financial-market nonsense is, like, 70% of what we talk about around here on a normal day. How many times have I written about hedge funds tricking each other using credit default swaps? Financial markets exist to foster price discovery and capital formation, but the way they do that is mostly by letting smart people mess with each other all day. WallStreetBets is a new class of smart people messing, quite effectively, with the old ones.”
- fulafel 6y ago(quoting your quote) "Stock markets exist so that companies can raise money to fund their projects" This is said a a lot but surely things like it just exist, and any purpouses we assign are stories. The majority of the effect on the world of the stock market seems to be what happens with existing stocks and not IPOs & share issues.
- bhupy 6y agoIn the same post I linked, Matt Levine actually provided an example of exactly that happening to another similarly over-hyped company, AMC: “In talking about GameStop, I have occasionally tried to tie the goofy stock-price dynamics to corporate finance. I suggested that maybe GameStop could sell stock at these absurd prices and use the money to, you know, be a better company. It’s tricky, selling stock at these prices, but in theory that’s what the prices are for: People are telling you that they want to buy your stock to fund your projects, so you might as well sell them the stock and do the projects. AMC has done that! On Monday it announced that it had raised $506 million of equity (and another $411 million of debt) in various transactions that “should allow the company to make it through this dark coronavirus-impacted winter.” Good work. Even better, that same day AMC launched an at-the-market offering to sell up to 50 million shares into the market at prevailing prices, allowing it to sell opportunistically to any redditors who wanted to buy. Yesterday it announced that it had finished the offering and raised $304.8 million from that and a previous stock sale, at an average price of about $4.80 a share. Of course yesterday the stock closed at $19.90, so AMC would have done better to wait a day, but nobody’s perfect. When redditors are clamoring to buy your stock you should sell it to them before it’s too late; there’s no reason for the company to try to time the endgame perfectly. Also yesterday holders of $600 million of AMC convertible bonds converted them into stock at a conversion price of $13.51 per share. Six hundred million dollars of debt, vaporized by Reddit enthusiasm. “In the absence of significant increases in attendance from current levels, there is substantial doubt about our ability to continue as a going concern for a reasonable period of time,” AMC warned investors on Monday; four days and a billion dollars later, there is somewhat less doubt. A week ago it was not crazy to think this company was doomed; now it is entirely possible that it will survive and thrive and show movies in movie theaters for decades to come because everyone went nuts and bought meme stocks this week. Capital formation!”
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LordOfWolves 6y agoI like to think that most of us folk on HN can agree that hedge funds have had very little to do with the progression of the world beyond the growth of its key members’ pockets and convoluted new “investment methods”. Pension funds - and similar - can easily be moved to ETFs and other asset classes without the management fees from these funds.
- hollowcelery 6y agoIf an investor wants returns that are orthogonal to the market or that avoid exposure to specific factors, then ETFs aren't really an option. This is why pension funds etc. will have some investments in index funds but will also diversify into hedge funds and alternative investments. Hedge funds and related investment vehicles aren't for most people, but they do perform an important function in the markets. Not everyone can invest passively -- someone has to actually enable price discovery.
- smabie 6y agoMoreover, in a highly correlated world it is unsurprising that institutional investors are eager for less correlated sources of return. The problem is actually finding it: as an allocator you are being adversely selected against. If a hedge fund is willing to take your money, we'll maybe it isn't that great of an opportunity after all.
- smabie 6y agoAlternatives don't make up the core portfolio of large institutional investors such as pension funds. Instead, they represent a percentage of the portfolio. The purpose of this percentage is to mix in uncorrelated (or less correlated) return streams in order to boost the return/risk ratio of the portfolio. It would be foolish in my opinion to just replace an entire pension fund portfolio with a couple ETFs. This isn't to say the pension funds are doing a good job (I don't think they are) in their allocation, but to say that everyone should just take out all of their money from hedge funds and put them into ETFs is irresponsible and not something any large investor would ever consider.
- xyzelement 6y ago
- cfitz 6y agoI first thought the article was a joke when I saw its length. Their sympathy for Melvin Capital despite said “fund” seeking to make money by sinking American companies into the ground via massive “short” positions, as with GameStop, is just disgusting. You don’t have to put others “down” to be “up”. There’s a way for us all to win. We certainly don’t need hedge funds to help us accomplish that. EDIT: “How they did it”: Melvin Capital purchased substantial volume of short positions (many billions), collaborated with Wall St on how to best design the downfall of a business employing thousands during a pandemic, and even put out fake news articles & tweets to fool the Reddit mob out of fooling themselves. Did not work out in the end. (No, I do not agree with Reddit’s current valuation. It is merely a remnant of the whole GME fiasco.)
- ryan93 6y agoGameStop is incredibly overpriced. Incredible waste of capital being poured into it.
- midasuni 6y agoThat’s your view. A thing is worth what someone will pay for it, be that gamestock, tesla, a gallon of gas, bitcoin, an NFT, or a kilogram of rice.
- samatman 6y agoIf it were as simple as that, speculation wouldn't exist, because no one would ever buy anything thinking that it's worth more than the price on the table. He's saying he doesn't think the market price for GME will hold, a position I happen to agree with. Might be more juice left in the rollercoaster, but I'm not buying it.
- fakedang 6y agoGamestop was also incredibly underpriced when Melvin was shorting it.
- gruez 6y ago>Their sympathy for Melvin Capital despite said “fund” seeking to make money by sinking American companies into the ground via massive “short” positions, as with GameStop, is just disgusting. Can you elaborate on how this is done? Did Melvin driving the stock price down empty GameStop's coffers or something?
- Chaffin11 6y agoThis is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. https://www.mybalancenow.review/ https://www.mybalancenow.review/
- paxys 6y ago> In the midst of a global crisis, the hedge fund has prospered. The opening line itself should give away the bias. Despite the pandemic and everything else going on, there was no market crisis last year. Quite the opposite in fact. It was basically impossible to lose money, no matter what you invested in. The article talks about hedge fund managers making record amounts of money – that's because that is what hedge funds are designed for. In an era where you can buy pretty much any security for free with a few clicks, their standard 2% of assets/20% of profits annual fee structure is absurd. Sure hedge funds have made their investors money. The S&P 500, small caps, crypto, commodities, treasuries, currencies all have as well (and for a lot cheaper). Here is a much more neutral take – https://www.investopedia.com/managing-wealth/hedge-fund-over/ https://www.investopedia.com/managing-wealth/hedge-fund-over...
- robjan 6y agoThe market corrected around Q1/Q2 last year and this is one of the events which causes hedgies profits to soar.
- smabie 6y agoI think both articles kind of miss the point: people aren't usually allocating to hedge funds in order to earn monster return. I mean that would be nice as well, but if a hedge fund delivered about the same returns as the market net of fees but with lower volatility and/or correlation, people would be happy with that as well.
- sadfev 6y agoWhy would anyone give more fee to basically perform like market but for less volatility?
- perl4ever 6y agoI think the word "correlation" is the more important one. Lack of correlation can be very valuable even if the returns are mediocre to poor. I don't remember or understand how it works, but I think I read once about how a fund manager claimed to be able to take more risk with the "long" part of a portfolio because of the uncorrelated "short" part, even though the returns of it were unimpressive.
- tedunangst 6y agoI'm not sure what conclusion I'm supposed to draw from the implications here. Melvin lost money because they misapplied the Black-Scholes formula?
- karaterobot 6y agoI took away the message that traders keep trying to make a perfect system in which there is no chance of losing money, but events like the GameStop fiasco prove they haven't managed to get there. He says this as though it's a meaningful conclusion to draw, even though earlier in that same article he wrote that 2020 was "the industry’s best year of gains in a decade."
- nubbins 6y agoFor all the focus this article seems to put on "hedge" I can't imagine there are many hedge funds left that are really market direction neutral are there? With the performance of the SP500 being what it is in the past few years you'd have to think you have some wickedly smart strategy to match that without going net long. Plus almost all assets, even things that were supposed to be countercyclical have been trading together so when the market really dumps even gold and silver get sold, if only to provide liquidity to cover other positions.
- valuearb 6y agoYea, the “hedge” part has seemed to have been lost to history long ago.
- reducesuffering 6y agoWhen the market really dumps, it's generally been quite temporary. All fundamental asset's have their time, cash's is just shorter and worse over time. If you think that's interesting, take it one step further and you have ultra cash: physical bills, not just bank IOU's and electricity. It has even a further niche time and even worse over time, 0% interest.
- MrMan 6y agoGlobal macro did well last year i think but long short equity not, it's like an existential crisis.
- xadhominemx 6y agoExact opposite
- Jackson12 6y agoI don't think this is right at all. I would be surprised if Alfred Winslow Jones or Warren Buffet (who were some of the earliest "hedge fund" managers) were significantly influenced by Bachelier's ideas. Buffet is famously neither especially quantitative in his investment style nor a believer in EMH. Financial "technology" pretty seldom actually originates in academia. It's more common that academics formally describe or justify something that market practitioners are already doing. The piece briefly mentions Bachelier doing this. There's good evidence that option prices were (relatively) efficient several decades before Black-Scholes was discovered. And Jones arguably came up with the notion of "beta" before CAPM was a thing. The only real exception I can think of is factor investing. This might seem kind of petty. But the notion that academia drives (or should drive) finance is not a benign myth. The LTCM crisis and the 2008 GFC were arguably caused by the uncritical application of ideas developed in the academy. I expect more.
- smabie 6y agoThe fact that Ed Thorp made such a killing trading warrants suggests that warrent prices were not very efficient before BS.
- Jackson12 6y agohttps://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3444897 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3444897 As far as I know Ed Thorp also made a lot of money after B-S was published. So it doesn't necessarily follow that B-S made the market more efficient. Also, doesn't his discovering B-S before it's publication and using it to make money support what I'm saying?
- zeckalpha 6y agoBuffett is fairly quantitative but on measures of fundamentals rather than technicals.
- reducesuffering 6y agoTook the words out of my hands. I feel like few people are as mindful of the raw fundamental financial metrics of companies. As you said, that's just not the same math PhD type technical stuff that hedge funds and others work on.
- kristianp 6y agoIs there a problem with this article? It's only two paragraphs long. Seems like most of it is missing.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/cd0QL https://archive.is/cd0QL
- ur-whale 6y agoThank you, and man, HN should do this automatically..
- tim333 6y ago>the efficient-market hypothesis, the meaning of which can be grasped by an oft-repeated saying on Wall Street: for every person who believes a stock will rise—the buyer—there will be some other equal and opposite person who believes the stock will fall—the seller is quite wrong really. The efficient market hypothesis implies market prices correctly discount the future and so you can't make money by figuring they are too high or too low. You still have a buyer and seller even if the prices are stupid.
- bhupy 6y ago> You still have a buyer and seller even if the prices are stupid. First of all, this is broadly untrue. It's really only true for a certain set of meme stocks, but that's because the market allows for fun stupidity. But just because the market allows for fun stupidity, doesn't mean the mechanism doesn't work wherever there is an absence of fun stupidity. Also, the status quo is arguably not a "market", at least as the efficient-market hypothesis defines it. Fed monetary policy basically breaks the usual flight-to-safety mechanism by providing no other alternative than to park capital in equities due to inflation and low interest rates (QE, basically). Additionally, Fed bailouts of junk bonds essentially removes all downside risk associated with risky assets while preserving the outsized reward; effectively guaranteeing stupid prices for certain assets.
- rsync 6y agoPlease subscribe to the New Yorker. It is a shining light in US journalism. I am not much of an e-reader and prefer physical objects but I do subscribe to the kindle version of The New Yorker and find it pleasing to consume in that way. I think it's $1.99/mo or something ? You couldn't spend a better two bucks ...
- xenocyon 6y agoYou must have a special deal. The price I see (USA, Kindle store, current pricing) is $9.99/mo after the first month. That said, I agree that journalism deserves to be paid for, and even the price I mentioned above (about $2.30/issue) is very reasonable.
- rsync 6y agoHmmm .... you're right. I see I am being charged $8.99 each month for the New Yorker. Yes, indeed - very reasonable. Again, I don't like the idea of reading on the kindle but somehow it works just fine, aesthetically, with this particular magazine...
- Projectiboga 6y agoFirst big options trader was Russel Sage, the instrument were called privileges at the time, late 19th century into the very early 20th century. Hedge funds and Hedging have little to do with each other besides that both can involve derivatives, leveraged speculative contracts. Hedge funds took off in the 1990s after a quite rise in the 1980s. SEC Regulation D is what set off this economic catastrophe from the USA to the world. Reg D was implemented to enable venture capital. Proprietary traders like Paul Tudor Jones had been doing speculative trading in financial derivatives since the 1970s using various often offshore locations to base the supposed business presence. Reg D was intended to fund startups with a nice help to the manangers who took the risk to carry forward their gains from one successful project to the next tax free as a balance to the frequent losses. The carryforward amount only gets taxed when it exits the investment fund. The Prop Traders kept the carry tax break to them selves and passed their monthly wins and losses over to their investors, in the 1990s long term capital gains got a lower tax rate and a new scam arose where these and so called private equity funds passed all gains, even short term trading gains over to the investors as long term capital gains this exploded the Hedge fund scene and are at least partially responsible for the crashes of 1997, 1998, contributed to the dot com bubble and pop, and the early 2000s real estate bubble and pop and on to our current tax cut fueled bubble. The joke is Hedging is supposed to reduce risk exposure While Hedge Funds are risky and speculative with the incentives for the investor and manager misaligned, the only hedge these funds provide to an average rich person is it balances the conservative take most fund manager's take with investment funds. Hedge funds also often use more leverage than a retail investor is allowed to.