4 ms·
>For better or worse, people are individuals, not members of a collective. Huh? There might be a few "individuals" living individually in the history of the wo
by coldtea 6y ago
>For better or worse, people are individuals, not members of a collective.
Huh? There might be a few "individuals" living individually in the history of the world. Isolated from the world, forgotten in some jungle, retreated to some cabin in Alaska, or so.
Some not by choice (e.g. due to some accident with their boat or something), others by choice but only after they've first been raised and prepared by living in communities.
The huge majority has always been members of communities and collective entities.
Without living together with others, collaborating with them, inheriting traditions and knowledge from the past, you don't even have language, culture, science, or anything, not even a cuisine. You're like some animal...
>Collectives of people don't work, and it isn't for a lack of trying
Between famillies, villages, cities, companies, churches, armies, nations, and so on, I can't even think what you had in mind as "not working"...
- WalterBright 6y agoI explicitly said that people still organize. Not as collectives, though. Perhaps you're missing what a collective is - it's an organization where people share equally in the results. It's characterized by self-sacrifice for the collective benefit. The huge majority of organizations are set up for selfish benefit, not collective benefit. Cooperation in mutual self-interest is NOT the same thing as cooperation in self-sacrifice. Company members, for example, certainly cooperate. But the employees are doing it out of self-interest.
- ganafagol 6y agoMaybe it's you that has a too narrow definition of "collective". It's a cooperative organization. Nothing in that definition demands self-sacrifice.
- WalterBright 6y ago> Nothing in that definition demands self-sacrifice. Sure it does. In a commune, everything produced is shared equally. That's self-sacrifice, as in if you produce more than the mean, that is taken from you.
- coldtea 6y ago>Sure it does. In a commune, everything produced is shared equally. Is this thread about some naive US conception and fear of "socialism" and such? Heck, not even in USSR "everything produced was shared equally". Not to mention really existing communism is hardly the main example of the idea of a collective (or a good one)...
- WalterBright 6y ago> Heck, not even in USSR "everything produced was shared equally". That was the plan. Of course, it didn't work. > Not to mention really existing communism is hardly the main example of the idea of a collective (or a good one)... Existing communism is when people try to implement communes, and wind up having to rely on force to do it.
- smolder 6y agoI'm not here just to pile on, and for the record I didn't downvote you. Like some others, I never took the word "collective" to mean the same as commune, which ~explains my reply earlier. I'm not interested in starting a commune where everyone gets strictly equal treatment. Fair, meritocratic treatment is great. I could debate about what a fair accounting of merit looks like from my POV. Back to the point I wanted to make here, though: It's possible in a commune, as with other organizations, to contribute more than the mean and still get back more than you would get for your effort independently. That's the nature of cooperation, that the whole can be more than the sum of the parts, through economies of scale like specialization.
- ganafagol 6y agoYou realize that "collective" and "commune" are different words right?
- leto_ii 6y ago> The huge majority of organizations are set up for selfish benefit, not collective benefit. What on earth are you talking about? For most of human history we lived in small bands of hunter-gatherers where selfishness could lead to ostracization. Even nowadays we organise in nation-states which try to (artificially) extend tribal loyalty to larger groups. Sometimes this leads people to commit the very self-interested act of dying for their country (note the sarcasm). And how about families? Have you heard of those?
- WalterBright 6y agoEven the Native American tribes did not operate as communes. > we lived in small bands of hunter-gatherers where selfishness could lead to ostracization. Are you sure they were communes? Slavery goes as far back as we can tell. The head of the band didn't get the best food? Nobody owned their horse, weapons, etc.? They certainly traded. Why wouldn't they trade amongst themselves?
- leto_ii 6y agoI recommend Jared Diamond's 'The World Until Yesterday' ('Guns, Germs and Steel' also covers some related topics), or Frans de Waal's 'The Bonobo and the Atheist'. In general I think there's broad agreement that in bands and small tribes of up to a few hundred people there's basically no hierarchy. Even when a chief emerges, he/she doesn't have a lot of power over others - they're more like mediators, they alleviate conflict etc. I think you're making a mistake that I've seen often (Steven Pinker does smth similar), namely assuming that hunter-gatherers behaved like settled societies. They didn't. Most of the increase in violence comes after the agriculture revolution and the development of large settlements. For most of our history we roamed the land in small packs that rarely interacted with outsiders. This is not to say that hunter-gatherers lived in heavenly harmony, just that they mostly lived in collaborative equality. They were also strongly independent (note that independence/individualism and collaboration do not exclude each other. Individualism however is not the same as selfishness, collaboration is not the same as collectivism).
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]