5 ms·
Collectives of people don't work The existence of armies and corporations suggests otherwise. I think you may be over-stretching the meaning of the term here t
by anigbrowl 6y ago
Collectives of people don't work
The existence of armies and corporations suggests otherwise. I think you may be over-stretching the meaning of the term here to suggest some sort of entity that displaces individual cognition.
- WalterBright 6y agoCorporations are not collectives. They are organizations of people with self-interest, not selfless-interest. Armies consist of people forced to cooperate, usually under threat of death or at least imprisonment. Such cooperation isn't very efficient, and indeed armies tend to be extremely wasteful of lives, treasure and property. (Volunteer armies tend to be less wasteful of lives.)
- anigbrowl 6y agoAll organizations involve a certain pooling of individual interest for collective gain, whether that's the profit of the corporations owners and employees (which may overlap) or some altruistic purpose in the case of nonprofit corporations. And these are just two among many examples. While I thought this Guardian article was rather hyperbolic and tells us more about the author's personal views than about whales, it seems to me that you're taking the same approach from something like an objectivist standpoint. Perhaps it would be more insightful to look at collectivism vs individualism as a continuum rather than a binary choice.
- WalterBright 6y ago> Perhaps it would be more insightful to look at collectivism vs individualism as a continuum rather than a binary choice. I already did in this thread: "The more the country tries to run the lives of its citizens, the worse the country does."
- coldtea 6y ago>Corporations are not collectives. They are organizations of people with self-interest, not selfless-interest. Which is neither here, nor there. First because nobody said people on collectives can't also have self-interest: just that they work together for the benefit of the collective too. That said, there are also collectives where self-interest comes second (to the point of sacrificing yourself for them) and they work just fine. In fact the whole of human history they have been instrumental: families, armies, countries, and so on.
- WalterBright 6y ago> armies We tend to give medals to soldiers who self-sacrifice, because it's unusual. Not many are interested in dying for their country. If you refuse an order to advance on an enemy stronghold, you'll get shot. Remember those Soviet blocking battalions? How does that relate to self-sacrifice for the collective? You overlooked the rest of what I wrote about armies.
- leto_ii 6y ago> Not many are interested in dying for their country. If you refuse an order to advance on an enemy stronghold, you'll get shot. Actually, what that shows more than anything is that not many people are willing to kill for their country. Killing other humans, even in self-interest, is often very hard to do - this is actually further evidence that people are quite collaborative and non-confrontational by nature.
- WalterBright 6y agoTalk to a combat veteran. One who has really been in combat and under fire. You won't find many who are eager to advance under fire. The 8th AF was suffering 80% casualties when my father was in the air war. He would talk sometimes about the terrible, gut-melting fear, and how it would crush some of the men, and how some of the men dealt with it (like heavy drinking). They weren't reluctant to kill the enemy - I asked him about it. He said the enemy was doing their damnedest to kill him, and he was trying to survive, not die. If you refused to go on a mission, the threat of execution was there, although they didn't do it. There was surely prison and utter disgrace, though, which many would consider worse than dying. My father dealt with it by looking at the numbers and resigning himself to death. He figured that while he lasted he'd do his duty and his best. When he signed up, I think he thought of it more as an adventure than a death sentence, like most young men do. Young men imagine themselves to be immortal.
- leto_ii 6y ago> Talk to a combat veteran. One who has really been in combat and under fire. > You won't find many who are eager to advance under fire. I have actually, my grandfather fought in WW2. His stories were usually short, grim, brutal. He, however, emphasized the importance of fighting for the country, of reclaiming occupied land, of putting the greater interest ahead of your own personal fears. Incidentally, while I fully admire his behavior, I don't think 'fighting for the country' is a particularly natural thing for humans to do. > They weren't reluctant to kill the enemy - I asked him about it. As far as I know lots of evidence points to the contrary. People often go so far as to deliberately miss shots in order not to kill somebody. > My father dealt with it by looking at the numbers and resigning himself to death. He figured that while he lasted he'd do his duty and his best. This sounds quite selfless to me. It may have been done through social pressure, but what this shows is that the fear of opprobrium is greater than the fear of dying - moving against the group is more unpleasant for humans than death.