14 ms·
For those who do not know RMS personally: "I worked for RMS longer than any other programmer. ... This was an own-goal for RMS. He has had plenty of opportuniti
by wmf 6y ago
For those who do not know RMS personally: "I worked for RMS longer than any other programmer. ... This was an own-goal for RMS. He has had plenty of opportunities to learn how to stfu when that’s necessary. ... I can confirm the unfortunate reality that RMS’s behavior was a concern [in the 1990s], and that [Marvin Minsky's] protection was itself part of the problem. He was never held to account; he was himself coddled in his own lower-grade misbehavior and mistreatment of women. He made the place uncomfortable for a lot of people, and especially women. ... RMS’s mere presence on the scene in this way has served to make it harder to deal with other cases of bad leaders’ bad behavior. It is time for the free software community to leave adolescence and move to adulthood, and this requires leaving childish tantrums, abusive language, and toxic environments behind." — Thomas Bushnell https://medium.com/@thomas.bushnell/a-reflection-on-the-departure-of-rms-18e6a835fd84 https://medium.com/@thomas.bushnell/a-reflection-on-the-depa...
- r3856283 6y agoHe didn't work with or for RMS longer than any other programmer, there are many who have longer. Gerald J. Sussman is a programmer and hired him at MIT and is still on the board of FSF and still working with him, that is over 40 years. And RMS has grown over the years. This is from over 20 years ago.
- joshuamorton 6y ago"for" and "with" are different words.
- numbers_guy 6y ago"making women uncomfortable" Right wtf does that mean? Clearly there was no actual sexual harassment. So you mean he was ugly and hit on you once? God forbid. We need to fire this man and make sure in the future that only attractive men are allowed to act like men lest we make the women feel uncomfortable.
- tadfisher 6y agoThis may be referring to the widespread rumor/account of RMS propositioning women for sex in his office at MIT, where he kept a mattress. I have no idea if this is true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ogurechny 6y agoJust imagine being so clueless that you don't understand someone having a mattress in his office. “What, do you even sleep next to a computer? EWW, NERD!” And these are the people who are the loudest about their intent to steer the whole industry “the right way”. To be honest, the motto that you don't need the skill to make decisions about the work requiring that skill, or that you don't need understand people doing it (the misleadingly formulated “anti-meritocracy” ideology) could only be taken without laughing out of politeness. And, as far as I know, the lack of mattress in the room never stopped any stereotypical harassing boss, so what's the point here exactly?
- gruez 6y ago>and that [Marvin Minsky's] protection was itself part of the problem So if your friend was accused of heinous crime, the right thing to do is to distance yourself as far as possible?
- tptacek 6y agoYou can stand by a friend without minimizing the harm they cause.
- etiam 6y agoWhen the actual harm was zero? And perhaps more importantly when the accusations go well beyond anything evidence warrants?
- hutzlibu 6y agoYep. That thinking is part of the problem. Because you did not feel bothered by him you assume no one has a right to it? And justified or not, there was real harm done to the reputation of FSF.
- hutzlibu 6y agoYou mean marginalising? Because minimizing harm is nothing bad as far as I am concerned.
- jrochkind1 6y agoSo I'm not sure there are any "heinous crimes" here, so what we're talking about is hypothetical, not this situation. If you believe your friend has committed a heinous crime (assuming this isn't just a quote "crime" but actually involves heinous harm to others), the right thing to do is support your friend as a human being and support and encourage them to take accountability for the harm they've done and try to repair it, and either way support what is necessary for them to be taken out of a position where they can continue to do harm, while trying to make sure your friend is okay too (as far as still having a roof over their head and food to eat and emotional support and dignity etc). I know this isn't the way our society works right now. It is the right thing to do. Come to think of it, it's the right thing to do even if the harm is less heinous. Part of the problem is that our society has taught us that the only choices are a) total abandonment of someone, throw them away completely or b) that "supporting" them means helping them deny the harm they've caused avoid any consequences and continue to do harm. Neither one will work to reduce the amount of harm done or build a culture where we can be human.
- malwarebytess 6y agoThat sounds like a rant from someone just don't doesn't like RMS rather than any substantive argument against him.