8 ms·
I do not. Being unusual does not free you from the burdens of being a decent person, especially while in a public leadership position, especially when your vio
by colechristensen 6y ago
I do not. Being unusual does not free you from the burdens of being a decent person, especially while in a public leadership position, especially when your violations are a repeated trend over a very long period.
With the right diagnostic criteria just about everybody who is an asshole could be diagnosed with some mental disorder or another and that is more or less the present state of psychology, that kind of reasoning is asking for a consequence free society.
The kind of person RMS has shown himself to be, regardless of diagnosis, disqualifies him from being a public figure and leader.
- SilverRed 6y agoI don't think RMS has ever intentionally been an asshole. The event that got him kicked out was him trying to clarify that someone he worked with may not of known all the details of the situation and that people shouldn't witch hunt this person who was not around to defend themself. Sure it was a very risky and emotionally charged email thread but RMS still very much seems like a decent person.
- jolux 6y ago>The event that got him kicked out was him trying to clarify that someone he worked with may not of known all the details of the situation and that people shouldn't witch hunt this person who was not around to defend themselfs. No, it went much further than that: https://www.wired.com/story/richard-stallman-and-the-fall-of-the-clueless-nerd/ https://www.wired.com/story/richard-stallman-and-the-fall-of...
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoDoesn’t look like it did. Looks like another case of cancel culture and nobody reading what he actually said.
- jolux 6y agohttps://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/09/richard-stallman-leaves-mit-after-controversial-remarks-on-rape/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/09/richard-stallman...
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoI encourage you to read what he actually said rather than digest it through hit pieces, because it’s not even controversial. He said that, hypothetically, if someone had sex with a victim of sex trafficking unkowingly - that is, the sex part was knowingly, but the victim of sex trafficking part was unknown, then it would not be fair to charge the man with rape. If I kidnap a woman, sell her has a sex slave, and threaten her and her family that if she doesn’t walk up to you in a bar and act interested, and you mistake her for a willing participant, this obviously does not make you a rapist. I don’t know if this is a willful distortion of what he said or what would motivate such a smear campaign, or if every is just shockingly bad at reading comprehension. But what he said was correct, and we all know it.
- jolux 6y agoI read them this in light of his past statements here, which seem to cast the statements he made around Minsky differently. In particular, "I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily pedophilia harms children. The arguments that it causes harm seem to be based on cases which aren't voluntary, which are then stretched by parents who are horrified by the idea that their little baby is maturing." https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html
- seba_dos1 6y agoAnd what's wrong with that take, exactly? It's a natural conclusion any critical thinker who strongly values individualism will come into before they start to consider the differences of power at play that make giving and recognizing actual consent very tricky (even for adults, let alone children); which actually isn't that obvious to notice at all if you have never been in such situation yourself before. This is a take that is logically coherent and honest - and naturally progresses once you learn new information. Which seems to be exactly what happened in case of Stallman, who retracted his earlier opinion in a logically coherent way. Honestly, I'm amazed at how many bad ideas people can come into just because they don't understand that other people may think with different processes than they do. I'm honestly not sure whether it's intellectual laziness or pure malice (or both).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 6y agoIntend? Who cares. It wasn't one incident but many over many many years. It is not his intentions at question, it is his longstanding pattern of certain behaviors and not learning from them. A standard defense of abusers is that they didn't mean it (intend to) and they're really sorry and ... you get the picture. People are allowed to make mistakes, failure is a part of life, but there's a point when failure becomes a pattern and you aren't right for a job as a leader.
- sebmellen 6y agoThat’s such a ridiculous viewpoint. Someone should be disqualified from being a “public figure” for making bad off-the-cuff remarks? There goes half of Congress, half of Hollywood, many historic figures, and a fair share of executives. How can someone be “disqualified” from being a “public figure” anyway!???!
- darig 6y agoNever heard of executions?!!?!??!^#^#!#$ LOL
- tpush 6y ago> There goes half of Congress, half of Hollywood, many historic figures, and a fair share of executives. I mean, yeah.
- doubleunplussed 6y agoAs if the people who replaced them would be any more pure. Once these are the standards, literally everyone is guilty, and who gets thrown under the bus is a matter of attention rather than guilt.
- yellowapple 6y ago"Half" is one heck of an understatement.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- benatkin 6y ago> disqualifies him from being a public figure and leader A lot of people can't do their jobs if they can't be leaders, depending on how you define it. I think that jobs that don't involve interacting with other people are being automated faster on average than jobs that do. So I think it's better not to be quick to disqualify someone from it.
- colechristensen 6y agoThere are a lot of softer definitions of leader, but we need not go into them as the topic on hand is a man getting a board position at an influential organization.
- pvaldes 6y ago> disqualifies him from being a public figure and leader Well, to be honest the 'imaleader' bar is pretty low at this moment. New leaders should try to distance themselves from most previous leader's behavior. Expectations about public figures are really far from reality.
- konjin 6y agoSo you want no one autistic to ever be in a position of leadership?
- colechristensen 6y agoIndeed autism poses a challenge for a person in a leadership position. One facet of autism is difficulty in certain social interactions and that difficulty can cause real harm to people. You shouldn't prejudge a person because of a diagnosis, nor should you pre-acquit. You can embrace acceptance that people are different and realize that differences make some people better and worse for certain things.
- konjin 6y ago>You can embrace acceptance that people are different and realize that differences make some people better and worse for certain things. I find it astonishing that blatant abelism like yours is acceptable in polite society. >You can embrace acceptance that genders are different and realize that differences make some genders better and worse for certain things. >You can embrace acceptance that races are different and realize that differences make some races better and worse for certain things.
- mdoms 6y agoIs it ableist to suggest that blind people don't make good air traffic controllers, that paralysed people don't make the best bicycle couriers or that a deaf person is perhaps not a suitable music critic? Everyone works within the limitations of our abilities, and some people are dealt difficult hands - but reality doesn't care about your feelings.
- colechristensen 6y agoThe key to not discriminating based on ability is to be sure you are endeavoring to enable a person to do something to the best of their abilities and not insisting that the only people allowed to do something are those who are best suited for it. But there is a separation between "not an ideal candidate for this job" and "not reasonably able to do this job". Indeed, sometimes the person with the disability can be better at the job because of what they have learned in an effort to overcome - this is why you don't just slap a label on a person and declare them unfit because they match a description. Being tolerant, respecting differences, however you want to put it does not mean being blind to outcomes. People sometimes don't get this.
- snvzz 6y agoSlander, pretty much. Fortunately, there's this review of the facts[0]. [0]: https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/ https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/
- kelnos 6y agoIt's not a great review. First, it focuses on the email exchange about Minksy. I absolutely agree that RMS's words there were blatantly lied about to make him look bad. RMS absolutely should have shut up sooner in that thread, but he didn't say anything terribly objectionable. But I stopped reading your link once the author did exactly what he railed on everyone else for doing: misquoting and taking quotes out of context to support their view. The author tries to defend RMS's views on pedophilia by pointing out that the Dutch article that RMS links to only talks about reducing the age of consent from 16 to 12, and that wouldn't constitute pedophilia. (A conclusion I'm not sure I agree with, but let's pretend I do.) But, nope, shoulda kept on quoting, because two sentences later there's: "The party said it wanted to cut the legal age for sexual relations to 12 and eventually scrap the limit altogether." Nope, not ok. Your linked article also repeatedly says things like, "All those questionable quotes seem very reasonable when put in context." Well, I disagree. After reading the full quotes, I still find most of them unreasonable.
- salawat 6y ago>Being unusual does not free you from the burdens of being a decent person... A decent person is a flawed, inherently subjective target. Obviously, from the fact that you're disagreeing with GP's sentiment demonstrates the two of you have different criteria for that. >...The kind of person RMS has shown himself to be, regardless of diagnosis, disqualifies him from being a public figure and leader. That's kind of funny. RMS has stayed honest to his principles; remained a consistent advocate for the fundamental freedoms of software and computer users; he's taken being made the butt of fantastically, even when i the midst of a highly controversial media circus, advocated for calm, encouraged waiting for the facts to roll in, and stayed true to the tenant of U.S. jurisprudence that someone is innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. That's pretty decent in my book. He has odd proclivities. He clashes. He's weird, he doesn't exactly have a mental pole vault down, but he has the courage to challenge what no one else will, and the presence of mind when confronted with new information to change his views, and preserve his earlier errors for posterity. That's also decency. Frankly, your post strikes me as able-ist. You quite literally made a low-key assertion that the neurodivergent, by virtue of their divergence, don't deserve or should be disqualified from leadership. As a functioning neurodivergent in a leadership position myself, I find that patently offensive. Do you understand just how challenging it can be to just different enough where you see a problem that needs to be stood against when no-one else does? How hard it can be to comprehend and keep up a facade that doesn't come to you naturally? To be successful by everyone else's measure, when objectively speaking you're not just excelling in your field or endeavor, but also doing it without everything everyone else takes for granted, difficulty even recognizing encouragement, no guarantee that any normal gesture of endearment or inclusion amongst normal people will find it's mark, or the pain that comes from having to be 100% up front with people, that you may end up saying something they'll take poorly, and knowing you may not even get a good or fair chance to make amends? That when things do hit the fan, you have to work 140% harder to navigate a world completely unnatural and unituitive to you? I get your message. I reject your assertion, however, that you can measure someone with a disability without taking it into account. I've lived that life. I constantly have to just let things go because "ya just won't get it til you live it." I've fought hard to thrive in a normal world, and with an internal locus of control accepted that more often than not, I'll end up having to be the one to take the high road to maintain the peace. I've had to survive the nights of loved ones being hurt because I just didn't have the energy to take that high road. I've made sacrifices in my personal life to be deemed "appropriate" in everyone else's eyes, and suffered the existential price and inauthenticity, and self-loathing that comes people's poor response to me at my most vulnerable. Which is why your post strikes such a chord. I shouldn't have to. Neither should he. RMS asks. He'll actually ask people whether he can stay, Whether they are comfortable, and when those people say yes, and get exposed to the realities of a neurodivergent unmasked, suddenly change their tune. You can argue he doesn't ask often enough, or that he makes folks uncomfortable by the level of directness required, but that he stays authentic tohimself makes him more worthy of being a leader than even I. He's at least up front about it, and doesn't hide the crazy to the point of being destructive like some tend to. He also doesn't judge others for simply being difficult to understand. So congratulations. Ya got a rise out of me.