3 ms·
NASA did great work in its first decade. Then it slowly grew into the bureaucratic pork delivery organization we know now. I think all organizations go that ro
by BurningFrog 6y ago
NASA did great work in its first decade. Then it slowly grew into the bureaucratic pork delivery organization we know now.
I think all organizations go that route over some decades. Private companies get replaced by new spry ones, but government agencies just keep going.
Maybe government agencies should be closed down every 50 years, and replaced by a brand new organization with the same responsibilities?
- ironmagma 6y agoThat sounds insanely wasteful. The new ones get created with the exact same mission as the old ones?
- BurningFrog 6y agoIf it works, it would be insanely profitable. Don't know if it's ever been tried in an organized way.
- afterburner 6y agoIt's been done with police departments, when the old one gets out of hand. Minneapolis is doing this after a litany of problems culminating in George Floyd's murder. https://www.cbs58.com/news/this-city-disbanded-its-police-department-7-years-ago-heres-what-happened-next https://www.cbs58.com/news/this-city-disbanded-its-police-de... Sometimes the only way to really fix a problem is to start over, because the current actors have a stake in resisting change.
- andrewflnr 6y agoI'm sure in practice you would tweak it on each iteration. My worry is more about the incentives around the end of the cycle, knowing that your job and entire organization is about to be scrapped.
- chriswarbo 6y agoNASA is certainly a victim of misaligned incentives and Darwinian selection. Its budgeting process rewards political savvy (e.g. jobs programs and pork), rather than effective delivery of its stated goals. It's tempting to align their incentives more towards outcomes, but we saw how that rewarded risk taking in the Shuttle program (and self-deception about those risks, e.g. Challenger's o-rings). The current two-level model seems like the worst of both worlds, with NASA being budgeted politically, then funneling that money to monopolistic private contractors which are 'too big to fail' (ULA, etc.). The disruption of those contractors by SpaceX, Rocket Lab, Relativity, etc. (and perhaps Blue Origin, if they actually deliver anything) was sorely needed. For NASA, this gives a credible alternative to the pork, without politicians appearing to be 'anti-NASA/science'.