3 ms·
> IMO if we’re going to have minimum wage in the US then we need to make it work for its intended purpose of requiring companies to pay people a living wage for
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> IMO if we’re going to have minimum wage in the US then we need to make it work for its intended purpose of requiring companies to pay people a living wage for their labor.
The best answer to this is that we shouldn't have a federal minimum wage.
Minimum wage is one of the depression era policies like price controls that were instituted before we knew better. It is a price control.
The reason we still have it is politics. Notice that the advocates of raising the federal minimum wage are overwhelmingly from states that already have a state minimum wage above the federal one, and could set their state's minimum wage to anything higher as they like, since it's a floor, not a ceiling. So why do they care?
They care because the cost of living is different in different regions. $7.25 might be a living wage in El Paso while $15 might not be in San Francisco. But California doesn't want their tax base moving to Texas, so politicians from California want federal laws that make it more expensive to do business in Texas. They want to deprive lower cost of living areas of their competitive advantage.
You can tell something is fishy when most of the supporters of raising the federal minimum wage represent zero people who actually make federal minimum wage, and the representatives of the people who do make federal minimum wage are the opponents.
And actually instituting the policy screws over the people it's supposed to be helping, because then the jobs stay in higher cost of living areas and the higher cost of living causes more harm than the lower wage would have in the lower cost of living area.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> But California doesn't want their tax base moving to Texas, so politicians from California want federal laws that make it more expensive to do business in Texas. They want to deprive lower cost of living areas of their competitive advantage. And politicians from Texas want to institute tariffs on China and other countries with lower labor costs than Texas. Everyone is playing the same game to maintain their outsized share of the pie.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoSo are you in favor of tariffs or are you against the minimum wage?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoFederal UBI and no minimum wage or any other subsidy to anyone. But that’s not going to happen, so it depends what benefits me and my closet tribe members. Currently I’m in a high cost of living area with very high minimum wages, so I’m for high minimum wages.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> it depends what benefits me and my closet tribe members. Currently I’m in a high cost of living area with very high minimum wages, so I’m for high minimum wages. If I could make a suggestion, don't do that. What benefits the tribe's leaders is not the same thing as what benefits the members of the tribe. Elected officials want a larger tax base because once they have enough to provide a basic level of services necessary to prevent the population from revolting, the excess can be diverted to cronies. What that means to you is that you and yours pay more for housing and have a more wasteful government; it's not a benefit to you. Not fighting against it would tend to raise your cost of living by increasing competition for local resources. But also, that mindset is poison. Once you admit to a willingness to be inconsistent for the benefit of tribal conflict, you're no longer engaged in good faith negotiations. You're making a declaration of war against your own countrymen. Then it's might makes right and the strong taking from the weak. And they don't stop at the other tribe. Put kleptocrats in power and they don't just steal for you, they steal from you. If that's not what you want, you have to refuse what causes it. > Federal UBI and no minimum wage or any other subsidy to anyone. > But that’s not going to happen That's what people say about everything, until it does. But it doesn't happen on its own. If you want something you have to work for it.