7 ms·
Please don't start another podcast. Or if you absolutely must, please provide a text version of the content. Podcasts aren't searchable, they aren't skimmable
by theshrike79 6y ago
Please don't start another podcast. Or if you absolutely must, please provide a text version of the content.
Podcasts aren't searchable, they aren't skimmable and their content isn't indexed in search engines. Text is.
- ddulaney 6y agoOn the other hand, podcasts can be listened to in the background, while text must be actively read. There are pros and cons to each format as a consumer, not to mention differences in production workflow.
- gnzoidberg 6y agoExactly
- judge2020 6y agoTo add, I think we should leave it to the machines to start indexing podcasts automatically. They're some of the easiest mediums for speech recognition and Google has been indexing YouTube transcripts for a few years now.
- danielscrubs 6y agoThey have been doing it badly for a few years know yes, it’s not solved by any stretch of the imagination.
- chillfox 6y agoSure, they keep getting some words wrong all the time, but it is likely good enough to get the general subject of what a podcast is about.
- theshrike79 6y agoThis is why most of the stuff I listen to as a podcast are just random factoids and trivia. (No Such Thing as A Fish, Cautionary Tales, 99pi, etc) If it's something I actually want to learn and retain, I prefer text so that I can go back, pause, skip etc as I please with an intuitive interface - my eyes =) The same thing with interviews of interesting people I may want to store quotes from. With text it's just C-c C-v to copy stuff to my notes. With audio I need to transcribe it by hand, which is tedious work.
- jspash 6y agoNaively I would think that there must be a service out there that auto-generates transcriptions from podcasts. Youtube already do this for (some) videos. The output isn't perfect, but it gets about 99% of the words correct. So my suggestion to OP wouldn't be "don't do the podcast". Instead I would say "do the podcast, but consider that it might not be searchable without a bit of extra effort".
- alexc05 6y ago100% there are services! I believe that Azure ML/AI has a natural text transcription service. In theory I could try and tweet at Seth Juarez@microsoft to see if I can get a sweetheart deal. But the more I think about the previous poster's position on the text, the more I convince myself that it might be worth a few bucks an episode for me to pay out-of-pocket if it means improved accessibility for users with disabilities. Not really because it's good business, but more because I've really come to believe in the value and power of implementing accessibility features. I'm actually starting to get a little teary eyed thinking about that blindness activist's viral video where he broke down physically sobbing the words "thank you" when he saw all of the accessibility features that Naughty Dog added to The Last of Us 2. (I'll hunt the video for people who haven't seen it, but be warned that you will probably bawl your eyes out like a school-child). From a cost perspective, I'll be putting in hundreds of fake dollars worth of time. The people I interview will be effectively donating hundreds of dollars worth of their own time. The least I can do is put some serious thought into plunking down dozens of dollars of pocket money for a transcription service. I'm more sold on the idea than I was in my previous post (5 minutes ago) Edit: the tweet in question. https://twitter.com/stevesaylor/status/1271404306697158659 https://twitter.com/stevesaylor/status/1271404306697158659
- dilyevsky 6y agoI haven’t personally used it but heard good things about Descript (also their demo vids are hilarious)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- alexc05 6y agoI'll take that on board! Thanks. For Episode 0 I did post the full text of my script in the description, but I do think that for the actual interviews I won't be able to afford a transcription service for a while. For the last few years though, I've been getting a fairly significant proportion of my ongoing professional development via the medium. I think it scales well in terms of being able to get access to some of the greatest minds I know without creating an undue burden on my guests OR myself as a father to a 2-year old with a mortgage and a day job. I am 100% willing to commit to writing rich descriptions that address the topics discussed in advance though. As part of the editing process I'll need to rewatch my own interviews a few times anyways, so it isn't a significant amount of extra work to provide a perfectly reasonable value add that I like to see on the pods I listen to. Thanks!
- iamacyborg 6y agoI use Descript for my podcast, £22 a month gets me ~30 hours of transcription. This probably sounds like an ad but really, it’s one of the best software products I’ve used in a very long time. This is the most recent episode I’ve published, giant wall of text took a bit of editing but wouldn’t have been possible without Descript. https://www.mql.fm/005-working-in-martech-dan-graap https://www.mql.fm/005-working-in-martech-dan-graap
- alexc05 6y agoThank you! This is exactly the type of recommendation that I was hoping for. I'd have been happy with the mention even if it was an ad.
- iamacyborg 6y agoIf you give it a try for audio editing make sure you record different podcast guests on separate audio tracks, makes the whole thing significantly better. I wrote a few thoughts on my blog about how I went about starting with the podcast including tools used, might be useful? https://www.jacquescorbytuech.com/writing/starting-a-podcast https://www.jacquescorbytuech.com/writing/starting-a-podcast
- alexc05 6y agoSorry you're getting downvoted on this post. I found your data point useful. Even though I disagree that there are enough podcasts serving the senior developer / corporate programmer niche, being made aware of the existence of "podcast exhaustion" is valuable, and the discussion convinced me that a transcription service is worth it. I'd hate for negative attention to result in a chilling effect on your decision to voice your opinion in future. I can't remove your downvotes, but I can say thank you a second time.
- simias 6y agoI didn't downvote but I think "please don't do X" is really a poor way to frame this opinion. I also don't care much for podcasts and prefer a textual format, but if you think you'd prefer making it a podcast then just make it and theshrike79 and I will find other content to consume. Or maybe it'll be so good and interesting that we'll just listen to it anyway! Deciding to start on such a project is really cool IMO, and I think if I ever attempted to do something like that I'd really find it very demotivating if the feedback I got was "no wait, not like that". But that's just me.
- corytheboyd 6y agoI agree with this 100%, and just want the parent commenter to see that at least one other person cares enough to say so to offset the toxic dismissal. It’s easy to shit on work, but hard to create it. You created something, that’s awesome and I wish you luck! Don’t try to make all the naysayers happy, especially in this community, or you’ll go insane lol.
- Chris2048 6y agoGiven a HN post if just some persons opinion, and a podcast is just some persons opinion, aren't you failing your own logic by calling that post "toxic"? i.e. If you don't like opinion framed this way, find other posts to consume.. Instead you're naysaying a HN comment..
- 6y ago
- chillfox 6y agoNot every format is for everyone. I personally listen to podcasts or audio books every day when driving and in my lunch break.
- ColinWright 6y agoPeople are different, and I like to learn about other people's methods and the potential benefits thereof. So let me ask ... when you're listening to podcasts, do you ever take anything away from them that is actionable? Do you take notes? Do you summarise? How do you ensure that the lessons in the podcast don't get lost? Do you "Listen with attention" or are they mostly just background? I find that podcasts are there, then gone, and nothing remains. When I read I take notes, summarise, and use the results to enhance my personal version of a Zettelkasten. I can't imagine doing that efficiently with podcasts, and I'd be interested to know how I can change that.
- chillfox 6y agoKinda depends upon if it is educational, informational or entertainment. I never use podcasts to just fill out the background, I generally use heavy metal music for that. I tend to either remember how/where to find the information again or the actual thing. So with podcasts I will either remind myself that I can't easily reference it and therefore remember the lesson, or sometimes I will write it down later in the day. What do you use for your Zettelkasten? I still haven't found a notebook software that I actually like, so my notes are kinda spread between a few different solutions.
- ColinWright 6y agoI've been using a ZK-like thing since the mid-90s, so it's very much a "roll your own" solution. Over the past 12 months or so I've started to try to de-couple it from the specifics of my setup so I can share it, but it's proving difficult. It's essentially a wiki, but it's how I use it that makes the difference. A true ZK requires a conversation. You take notes, but then you spend time inter-weaving them into the ZK. Most people use note-taking systems as, well, note-taking systems, and never return to make the connections between the notes. Hence they get lost. Here are my thoughts about that "conversation": https://www.solipsys.co.uk/cgi-bin/DiscDAG.py?DiscussionID=ZettelKasten&SelectOnly=N_20200417173614a_ColinWright&ShowNeighbourhood=True https://www.solipsys.co.uk/cgi-bin/DiscDAG.py?DiscussionID=Z... There's a link in there to take you out of "Neighbourhood Mode" if you want to see the whole thing at once.
- apercu 6y agoBetter yet, feed your podcast to an AI for transcription. And host the transcriptions in a wordpress blog. The cost is minimal.
- njkumarr 6y agoagreed
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe best podcasts in my experience are: 1. Those that are tightly written and edited. That is, there is a script (which can then, of course, be posted). 2. Are discussions (lectures, interviews, conversations) about a text (book, article, concept, etc.) which itself can then be referenced for more detail. 3. Are narrations of short stories. Examples of these would include: - Numerous history podcasts: The History of Philosophy (Without Any Gaps) by Peter Adamson, History of Rome, History of Byzantium, History of China. - The New Books Network, a series of author interviews on recently-published academic books. Here you're listening to the author and an (almost always academic) interviewer discussing the topic, effectively as an advertisement for the book. It's a great way to be introduced to deeper material. - A few deeper / prepared podcasts. WNYC has numerous professionally-scripted podcasts, as do other NPR / public radio / government media affiliates in the US, Canada (Ideas), BBC (Tim Harford, various), and elsewhere. These blur the line between traditional podcast and commercial broadcast, but are quite intelligent and informative. - Stories or nonfiction narrative. "Selected Shorts", "Soundprints", "This American Life", "Reveal", and others come to mind. Here the idea is to simply be entertained or caught up in the narrative. - Various interview programmes. I'm fond of Terry Gross's "Fresh Air", the Santa Fe Institute's "Complexity" podcast, and others. None of these is the proverbial dude/chick (and optionally friends) blabbing incoherently into a mic. All are scripted, most have either transcripts, extensive show notes and references, or both (the fiction / narratives being the exception). For the record, the unorganised / low-content flavour of podcast is one that drives me nuts as well. Sturgeon's Law applies. Seek the non-cruddy end of the spectrum. For times when I'm read out, or otherwise engaged (kitchen, chores, driving), or want to zone out, these are worth listening to. For conveying infotech content, I'd generally agree that podcasts aren't the best medium. I also generally stray away from anything that's strongly focussed on news, current events, or current topics, and the list of academic, historical, and philosophical programmes above have been quite the useful informative distraction from the moment for me, for the past several years.