3 ms·
I see, thanks. I am not sure I agree with your characterization of an encyclopedia, nor the continental approach to things, but I do at least grok your argument
by steveklabnik 6y ago
I see, thanks. I am not sure I agree with your characterization of an encyclopedia, nor the continental approach to things, but I do at least grok your argument now.
> why wouldn't he just have written what you wrote?
For one, because it simply wouldn't have been as good at expressing the idea, but also, I'm writing for a very different audience than he was, so it's gonna come out a bit differently.
> etc all write as clearly as possible.
We'll have to agree to disagree :) Also, the "as possible" does a lot of work here, I would imagine that many people would say they're expressing themselves "as possible," and that's where a lot of the argument comes in.
(And yes, what "clear" even means is like, one of the differences between these traditions, for anyone else reading this discussion.)