3 ms·
The second wave of the 1918 pandemic was also more deadly to younger people. Various theories have been offered as to why, none of which are proven, including
by lamontcg 6y ago
The second wave of the 1918 pandemic was also more deadly to younger people.
Various theories have been offered as to why, none of which are proven, including that it may have been observational errors or due to overcrowding conditions due to the war and viral dose.
I wonder if it isn't due to the virus coming under pressure due to a large chunk of the population becoming immune, so evolution favors higher transmissibility. And the easy knob the virus has to increase transmissibility is to increase viral load, which has the side effect of increasing virulence/lethality. That is consistent with that fairly well studied mechanism of parasites/viruses, along with being consistent with what we're observing.
At any rate considerations like that are why I'm not letting my guard down until I'm vaccinated and why it seems stupid to do so.
- ionwake 6y agoI dont believe virus ever increase in lethality as pressures increase, I thought the opposite happens, they naturally becomes less lethal to be able to spread more effectively. Also when you said " stupid to do so" what are you referring to? thx
- lamontcg 6y agoThat law doesn't exist. Mostly all the virus cares about is increased transmission, particularly with this virus with a long presymptomatic transmission period, it can evolve to become more lethal if that increases transmission. What would not be selected for would be enhanced virulence that shortens the presymptomatic transmission period. Short term the virus benefits by having higher viral loads and enhanced transmission and enhanced virulence, because it wants those higher viral loads in order to spread more. There's a limit because those higher viral loads are eventually what cause people to feel sick and stay home instead of attend superspreading events, so there's an optimum that its trying to find. As more and more people are immune though, there's probably selection pressure to make the most of whatever superspreading events occur at the expense of non-superspreading transmission. So more people get sick earlier and stay home, but the people who will try to push through a 101F fever the virus wants to have them infecting 100 people instead of 50. Long term the virus is going to evolve to become less lethal though because eventually we're going to hit herd immunity at the point where it can't evolve along the same fitness function to spread epidemically. At that point it needs to make many more mutations to all its epitopes that might be recognized by antibodies and T-cell and achieve enough immune escape to raise its R0 above 1.0 again. There's mutations which slide up and down the existing fitness curve (and some lucky mutations that might make the curve even better) but then there's mutations which are costly which are necessary due to the need for stealth and immune escape. Two different things. Also we have the example of the 1918 pandemic where the later waves were more virulent and lethal than the first wave (but much later it evolved to become seasonal influenza). Got much worse, then got better.
- ionwake 6y agoThank you for taking the time to reply. I don't believe you countered my point. The information in your post was however super interesting and I appreciate that. Why would a virus evolve to be more lethal - if it wanted to increase transmission?