3 ms·
> The format of numbers is important to how you end up manipulating them. I just pointed out: >> Before the introduction of Arabic numerals to Europe, this ma
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> The format of numbers is important to how you end up manipulating them.
I just pointed out:
>> Before the introduction of Arabic numerals to Europe, this manipulation was already common; that's what an abacus was for.
The abacus doesn't represent numbers in Roman numerals. It represents them positionally. This poses no problems because conversion between representations is trivial.
> How in the hell do you XII/II on paper by showing your work?
That's as easy as it gets; half of X is V and half of II is I. This is like asking "how in the hell do you do 7 - 2 on paper by showing your work?". Dividing by 2 is a primitive that is always easy to do in Roman numerals, and is relied on heavily in the method you'd use to multiply them, which you can in fact read about. I'll do 47x9:
XXXXVII * VIIII
XXIII * XVIII
XI * XXXVI
V * LXXII
II _ CXXXXIIII
I * CCLXXXVIII
CCLXXXVIII + LXXII + XXXVI + XVIII + VIIII =
= CC LL XXXXXXXXX VVVV IIIIIIIIIIIII =
= CC C LXXXX XX XIII =
= CCCCXXIII = 423
- darkwater 6y agoI thought 9 was IX
- thaumasiotes 6y agoYou're free to write it that way if you want, but that just adds an unnecessary step to doing math with it.
- dhosek 6y agoThe prefix = subtraction convention came late in the history of Roman numerals. I think it might even postdate the introduction of Arabic numerals, but I can't say for sure since I'm going from memory here. If I were less lazy, I'd look at wikipedia which doubtless can give a more definitive answer.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoWikipedia has plenty of citations to classical Rome. Colosseum gate 44: XLIIII (not, for whatever reason, XLIV, or XXXXIIII) 18th legion: XIIX 22nd legion: IIXX There was evidently not a strict standard. (Note also that the symbols we use for high values, D and M, weren't really what the Romans used. You can see Roman abaci with columns labeled with place values: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:RomanAbacusRecon.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:RomanAbacusRecon.jpg https://thatsmaths.com/2019/07/04/what-did-the-romans-ever-do-for-maths/ https://thatsmaths.com/2019/07/04/what-did-the-romans-ever-d... Those look the same; I don't know whether the one is a replica of the other or whether the form was just that standardized. But the columns are plainly labeled as, in ascending order, ϴ, I, X, C, ∞, ((|)), (((|))), and |X|. I speculate that ∞ is a fancy way of writing (|); I believe our M descends from Roman (|) and our D from Roman |). )