4 ms·
It is absolutely jaw dropping to me watching that Model Y front-frame come out of that 6k-ton casting machine[1]. Incredible. Had not seen that before. What a p
by rektide 6y ago
It is absolutely jaw dropping to me watching that Model Y front-frame come out of that 6k-ton casting machine[1]. Incredible. Had not seen that before. What a potentially incredibly efficient use of materials & process, to produce a large well constructed, integrated piece.
I do have one reservation, which is that this feels a bit like the creation of a dispose-only car. Trying to bend this unibody back into shape seems like it's going to be incredibly difficult. I'm trying to imagine how if at all we're going to fix a cybertruck, after it slides into a tree or pole. I was so delighted to see the Model Y front-unibody come out of that press, but a second latter, I was shocked, mouth open aghast, trying to imagine these cars as anything other than disposable.
Like the NAND situation on Teslas, there's so much amazing high tech wonders afoot here. But vehicles, over the generations, have had to learn that maintainability, repairability, and sustainability are real factors too: there's many years of engineering that have gone into not just making cars, but making them able to be kept running. I know Tesla's not the only one doing unibody work, that this isn't entirely 100% a novel problem, but I'm still a bit jarred, a bit worried, that we're creating a truck- a vehicle format known for getting beat up a bit- that might not be repairable.
[1] https://twitter.com/Tesla/status/1357503277722718212 https://twitter.com/Tesla/status/1357503277722718212
- extrapickles 6y agoThe alloys used in most modern cars work harden too much to be able to bend them back into shape trivially. Ideally, they would sell you a new front/rear casting and recycle the bent old one. I don't see this happening though as they have more motivation to hide behind "unseen damage" to sell you a new car.
- karlkatzke 6y agoThe same argument was made regarding moving from frame-on-body cars to unibody cars in the first place. It turned out that the weight and assembly savings and the increase in crash safety far outweighed the costs and risks, and that metal is pretty recyclable, so you just end up salvaging the parts you can and junking the rest.
- baybal2 6y ago> What a potentially incredibly efficient use of materials Actually no, casting requires more material for equal strength, and you loose materials in voids. But given Tesla's pricetag, and already huge weight, it might make sense. Even most poorly designed aluminium part is likely to be lighter than steel at least by a tiny bit. It is also not that much faster, as manufacturing from steel is automated so much these days, and cast parts needs further finishing. And, MAYBE, having a huge casting machine, and some finishing is cheaper for Tesla than going with bigger metalworking line with their current scale.
- nickik 6y agoIts not that much faster but Tesla claimed it removes 100s of robots and an incredibly long error prone assembly line. Also, when you weld lots of parts together you have tolerances stack up. Tesla developed its own aluminum that does not need to be heat-treated. It might still need some finishing, but not a very complex process. Check out this video of Musk and Sandy Munro (former Chief Engineer at Ford) talking about it: https://youtu.be/YAtLTLiqNwg?t=1024 https://youtu.be/YAtLTLiqNwg?t=1024
- rklaehn 6y agoSandy Munro has covered this. There are some bars in the front of the front casting. If those were damaged, you would just cut them away and weld replacements in place. If the main part of the casting gets bent, it will have been a very severe accident that you are lucky to walk away from. Repairing the car will be the least of your concerns.
- coryrc 6y agoAlso today, even in body-on-frame vehicles, if the frame is badly distorted, you pull the frame and install a new one. You can't fix it well in-situ.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _ph_ 6y agoAnd a 3D aluminum cast should be way stiffer than steel sheets used so far, so it should be less likely to get a bent frame this way.