3 ms·
More and more I appreciate Signal for what it is. A no nonsense (okay, stickers) messaging tool for people that know each other in real life. I hope it never ch
by barbazoo 6y ago
More and more I appreciate Signal for what it is. A no nonsense (okay, stickers) messaging tool for people that know each other in real life. I hope it never changes into something "social".
- eptcyka 6y agoYeah, but I can't get my family to switch if the UX is subpar.
- rPlayer6554 6y agoHow long ago did you use signal? The UX is on par with WhatsApp. In fact I've found tiny things that signal does better (it groups sending multiple pictures into on "album" message instead of sending one message per picture like WhatsApp) The only place I could agree WhatsApp has a significantly better UX is with backing up messages.
- StavrosK 6y agoWhatsApp does the album thing as well.
- rPlayer6554 6y agoHmmm interesting. It hasn't been doing it for me recently. Maybe it's a setting.
- dawnerd 6y agoTelegram also does “albums”
- rPlayer6554 6y agoYes but UI/UX around E2E is not good.
- fnord123 6y agoSignal on desktop is very slow. It's a very unpleasant experience.
- rPlayer6554 6y agoThat is fair, the startup time takes forever.
- eptcyka 6y agoThe desktop app has managed to corrupt its database multiple times since I started using it a couple of months ago. Its really bad for an app to do that in this day and age, mind you. This is btrfs levels of bad.
- simias 6y agoI've had the same issue multiple times lately. It really wouldn't be so bad if Signal could resynchronize the messages, but here you have to restart from scratch every time. I always found it very dissonant that all I hear coming from the Signal devs is "we know best, you know nothing" but then when it comes to a native client the only thing they manage to implement is a half-assed, bloated-yet-underfeatured electron client (which already suffered at least one significant security vulnerability I might add). If they were a little more open with their development policies they might not be in such an awkward situation right now.
- fnord123 6y agoThis is exactly my sentiment. If the encryption is as potato as their UI then I simply don't buy the security claims.
- sofixa 6y ago> The UX is on par with WhatsApp So as the GP said, subpar.
- isatty 6y agoNo it’s not. Does it even have a native app yet?
- eptcyka 6y agoI use it everyday. Its just not. Video calls are strictly worse, forwarding images is strictly worse, no ability to share history in group chats, the UI is just inferior. Some of these, I can live without, others are really preventing my friends and family from using the app. Also, scheduled messages. Ability to message people without exposing ones phone number (a real blocker from using Signal for some group chats that are privacy minded). Default camera is very bad, image picker is slow and picks images from all dorectories instead of my main camera dir. My gf wasn't even aware its possible to send multiple images in a single message until I pointed it out. Telegram has none of these issues :/ I really want to love signal, its my daily driver. But its incredibly hard.
- jiofih 6y agoI and a ton of friends use Telegram purely for messaging, none of this gets in the way.
- barbazoo 6y agoYou're 100% right. I'm just worried that by going more "social", chances increase of Telegram going the same way as WhatsApp and Instagram.
- tmp538394722 6y agoGetting bought by Facebook for billions?
- barbazoo 6y agoPersonally I rather it didn't, yes. Being sold to Facebook just means I have yet to switch messengers again.
- simias 6y agoI'm all for no-nonsense, but I'd qualify Signal as barebones in some regards. Two features that routinely annoy me: no way to synchronize previous messages when linking a new client, no way to change the spellchecker language in the desktop app. I want Signal to succeed but I always hesitate to recommend it because it always feels like an early beta product to me, not something ready for prime time.
- busymom0 6y ago> no way to synchronize previous messages when linking a new client Isn't this because of how true end to end encryption works and Signal treating each user devices as an independent device and not "syncing"? Here's a discussion on it: https://community.signalusers.org/t/message-history-sync-for-newly-linked-desktop-and-ipad-devices/2839/24 https://community.signalusers.org/t/message-history-sync-for...
- afiori 6y agothe reality is that signal is a secure communication app, not a messaging app. syncing old messages has unavoidable security problems and so signal chooses (as they should given their goals) not to implement it.