6 ms·
Deconstructing Jackie
- imbnwa 6y agoAs far as influence on contemporary progressivist ideologies, Derrida's impact is rather minimal, likely owing to how difficult reading him is. The historian Michel Foucault is orders of magnitude more influential on American humanities departments and modern progressivist ideologies. Most of the major American writers in the 80s, 90s, 00s, like Wendy Brown, Judith Butler, et al, are big readers of Foucault and the intense use of the word "normalize" you see amongst Left-leaning youth nowadays bears a direct lineage from Foucault as a technical term in his work. Of course, the relationship of an author to his readers is never fidelitous, likely owning to physics, so reading Foucault, then his readers, then modern popular ideologies will always bear striking differences.
- dopidopHN 6y agoFun fact: My first time reading Derrida or Guattari was in a US philo book club. In english. I'm French. I read the books in my mothers tongue of course. But it was really interesting to see how the pedantic translation gets in the way. I'm not the only one the 'teacher' of that group speaks decent french and was using me a lot to 'demistify' some fancy translation. "Does the sentence sound contrived in french? because it's hard to follow in English" It's interesting, I have only the minimal French background in philosophie, it's mandatory to take 2 years in high-school. But I was less lost than some US folks with more comprensive training in that field. ( I did read some Guattari in high school, but nothing comprenhensive )
- ducharmdev 6y agoI would be very curious about your perspective myself if I were in that book club! It's interesting that you say the translation got in the way of understanding the text; I can see how the literary quality of this type of philosophy would not do well with one-to-one translations.
- ralusek 6y agoPostmodernism turns structures into soup. Some corrupted structures need to be deconstructed into soup, and skepticism, cynicism, and criticism are good tools for the job. However, you can't build with soup. And postmodernists are typically horrible builders. And overzealous postmodernists have an underdeveloped sense of when to stop deconstructing. And they seem to be unaware that most structures that come from the soup are unimaginably worse than the one that they just tore down. If a cynical skeptic shows up to fix society with a scalpel, that's a healthy dose of postmodernism; an adult. If a skeptic shows up with an atom bomb, you're dealing with a child. There is no better phrase with which to characterize the current wave of postmodernism than perpetually "throwing the baby out with the bathwater."
- vixen99 6y ago“A writer who says that there are no truths, or that all truth is ‘merely relative,’ is asking you not to believe him. So don’t.” Roger Scruton:
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ducharmdev 6y agoI think this is why I enjoyed Deleuze & Guattari a lot; IMO they seemed to be more aware of the futility of the "burn everything to the ground" approach and overall, their conclusions feel more additive than subtractive.
- tsimionescu 6y agoChomsky had a saying about postmodernism in general: most of their ideas are either absurd or trivial. For example, take moral relativism: it's either a trivial observation - that different cultures have different notions of exactly what is moral or not; or it is an absurd idea, that morality means nothing and you are as justified to pick a flower as you are to rip another human's arms.
- xyzzy_plugh 6y ago
- ducharmdev 6y agoI was always conflicted about poststructural thinkers; on the one hand I was enamored with the creativity of their ideas and analyses, but on the other hand it seemed that their insights were always communicated in the most impenetrable writing. I get that their chosen modes of communication are often interwined with the ideas themselves, but nonetheless it reminds me of engineers that create overly complex solutions to flex how clever they are. Although I always had more fun with the continental philosophers than analytic ones, I do appreciate certain thinkers that can bring clarity to the works of Derrida, Foucault, etc. For example, I've always had an interest in Deleuze & Guattari, but it sure is helpful to have someone like Manuel DeLanda when reading works like A Thousand Plateaus. If not for him, I doubt I would've made sense of the original text at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robocat 6y agoI love this article “How to Deconstruct Almost Anything--My Postmodern Adventure” written by a software engineer: https://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/decon.html https://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/decon.html Edit: it is the best explanation for “it seemed that their insights were always communicated in the most impenetrable writing” I have seen.
- ducharmdev 6y agoThat's interesting, as my experience was the inverse of this; I started in the humanities and later became a software engineer. My background makes my complaint slightly different: it is common in postmodern thought to critique essentialism, and although these criticisms can have a lot of merit, postmodern thinkers can get very meta in their arguments. To the point where even the texts themselves evade essentialism. The trouble with this is that, for better or worse, we typically try to get at the essence of things in the learning process, i.e. we search for fundamental patterns in the domain we're learning. So at the same time that postmodern thinkers are critiquing essentialist assumptions that we may hold, they are also using the text itself to drive this point home. But for someone new to this stuff, it makes it very hard to learn. I believe that there is value in these ideas, but they need to be made more accessible if they're to become popular outside of academia. The tech industry would benefit from exposure to other domains like this; although engineering holds a lot of power afforded to it by economics, I've noticed a lot of developers fall into the notion that their domain is the one to rule them all, and that it is enough to understand the world in it's relation to software alone.
- finikytou 6y agoIn France, no one reads Derrida. No one ever did. He never really mattered. People never really considered him as an important philosopher neither a second tier one. It always amazed me that americans embraced him. I tried a few times reading him it is just an horrible vain experience full of really vain writing. He was probably the closest to what is modern american philosophy: marketing. no depth and all in appearances. funny that now his thoughts -that contributed to all the skin-color related communitarianism and destructuration that is pushing american middle/lower class into race-centric battles (while educating everyone at the same time that race doesn't exist) instead of focusing on class issues (occupy wall street)- are coming back to france imported from all the american minds and social movements. Just like USA thought they won the cold war going to space while the communists entered their schools and educated their kids we see similar things in france with us fighting the ideas of derrida decades ago not to enter into society just to see them coming back x10 from the american empire through netflix,twitter, facebook and even hacker news of today. and obviously the vicious thing of this americanized destructuring system is that they developed tools to annihilate any alternative thoughts (Censorship on twitter/fb, downvote on HN/Shaming individuals at work or even remove them from their job for daring to think by themselves) deeming them racist,supremacist or whatever is it. even if it comes from minorities - like me- then they will call us uncle tom or "race traitor" because we try to debate instead of siding with the people who think they are right and that destructuring should happen
- dopidopHN 6y agoI had to read Guattari in french high school. It's in the syllabus along with Foucault.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic battle on top of ideological battle. We don't want either of those here, and the two together are toxic. What we want is curious conversation. It's certainly possible to have that on these topics, low-probability though that may be on the internet. Actually the OP is a nice basis for curious conversation—thoughtful, open-minded, interesting, and easy to read. (Though the Althusser bit seems gratuitous.) It's noteworthy for considering Derrida without either subscribing to or denouncing him. That's unusual, and very much in the spirit of curiosity. As long as we're talking about this, we should follow that example. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/xeZ6o https://archive.is/xeZ6o https://web.archive.org/web/20210320182025/https://www.newstatesman.com/an-event-perhaps-biography-jacques-derrida-review https://web.archive.org/web/20210320182025/https://www.newst...
- yowlingcat 6y agoI had a lot of fun with the postmodernist thinkers in college, and they expanded my brain in the same way that Haskell did. Unfortunately, I found that much like Haskell (forgive me, Haskell, for the uncharitable analogy), I did not find much use for it after college. As another comment alludes to here, I found the tools I learned about through the postmodernists most useful for taking things apart -- with some exceptions (Baudrillard, Lyotard, Guattari). However, when it came to putting them back together again and doing something useful, I often felt I was somewhat on my own. Perhaps others have gone through the same realization. There are a couple of thinkers on the math/philosophy side (Gödel, Peirce, Wittgenstein, Cantor, Church), the cultural theory side (McLuhan, Paglia, Lasch), the literary fiction side (Gibson, Borges, Calvino, Tsutsui), the experimental composer side (Webern) and the pop music side (Prince, Martin, Jackson, etc) that I've been able to draw creative inspiration from. But by and large, it's been individuals, not really movements. Maybe that's just how it is with any movement?
- mycologos 6y ago> Prince, Martin, Jackson, etc Assuming Prince is "the" Prince and Jackson is Michael Jackson, if I understand your comment correctly, you're describing them as "postmodern thinkers". If so, why? Or maybe you're just describing inspirational individuals in general?
- yowlingcat 6y agoSorry, I think the way I phrased it was ambiguous. I was phrasing them in contrast to literal "postmodern thinkers" in that they're pop culture creators who achieved significant impact in the postmodern cultural millieu. It's true that you could consider them "postmodern thinkers" but I don't know how much I'd agree with that. For me, it's more they fill in the gaps of what I was looking for (perhaps for guidance, perhaps for inspiration, perhaps just for a role model) when I read the postmodern thinkers, searching for tools I could use to reconstruct -- not just deconstruct. Let me add in another thinker here who in a very literal sense fills in the gaps between the two groups -- Terre Thaemlitz [1], who is both a postmodern thinker and a DJ. I suppose one could also cite early Nick Land [2], given his seminal importance in the establishment of the CCRU at University of Warwick, which straddled the divide of postmodernism and rave culture. Unfortunately, Nick Land does end up moving into less savory territory [3] more recently; I view that era more as a cautionary tale than anything. [1] http://www.comatonse.com/writings/becoming-minor.html http://www.comatonse.com/writings/becoming-minor.html [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10838202-fanged-noumena https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10838202-fanged-noumena [3] https://jacobitemag.com/2017/05/25/a-quick-and-dirty-introduction-to-accelerationism/ https://jacobitemag.com/2017/05/25/a-quick-and-dirty-introdu...