4 ms·
> Sorry, but what is that even supposed to mean? I usually frame it as: if something is within reach of our technological capabilities and there's a way to mak
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
> Sorry, but what is that even supposed to mean?
I usually frame it as: if something is within reach of our technological capabilities and there's a way to make money on it, someone will eventually do it, no matter how evil that thing is.
Technology is mostly a ratchet - once something becomes possible, it usually never stops being. So if you want to stop or prevent some wrong behavior, you have to address the economics of it: make it not profitable to pursue.
In this particular case: adtech scoundrels find it profitable to know your core count. Explicit API for this information doesn't change much for them, as it's easy to reliably infer that information with a bit of clever code. That clever code, however, will tax your CPU and battery. They don't care, because they're not paying for your electricity. The solution to this problem isn't to oppose the API (that, beyond saving you battery life, has many beneficial applications). It's to make fingerprinting unprofitable.
To make fingerprinting unprofitable, you can make it harder to perform (removing this API doesn't achieve that). But that's pretty much impossible without completely lobotomizing the browser, or without technologies that don't exist yet. So the best avenue of attack is changing (widely understood) social norms to make adtech fingerprinting unprofitable. In case of as widespread practice as this, pretty much the only effective way is regulatory - try to get your government to make this stuff illegal.
- trulyme 6y agoNice analysis, but you left out another possible solution, by Google: monitor resource consumption of web pages and penalize wasteful ones by giving them worse SE positions. Not sure if this is in G's interest though.