3 ms·
> I don’t want websites to be able to send notifications to my phone. You might not, but our users requested desktop and mobile notifications. The notification
by heavyset_go 6y ago
> I don’t want websites to be able to send notifications to my phone.
You might not, but our users requested desktop and mobile notifications. The notifications let sick patients know when their prescriptions are ready, facilitate care-provider check ups, etc.
- Google234 6y agoHave those users download some simple app if this is so important to them. Or let them enter their phone number to get more reliable text notifications. Just because you have a good use doesn’t outweigh the all the bad abuse.
- cforrester 6y ago> Just because you have a good use doesn’t outweigh the all the bad abuse. Personally, this is how I feel about downloading apps to my phone for every individual service and product. I see no need to download a separate app for each individual service I'm interested in, as the potential for abuse is higher than getting the occasional notification from my browser app and visiting their website. However, it sounds to me like the focus should be on minimizing the potential for any avenue of information delivery to be abused, not to remove or decline to add features for fear that they will be. From the user side, I'm not interested in being told by a developer, "download my app if it's so important to you." I'd probably never discover how useful a service can be if I would have to download another app to try it. From the developer side, I'm not interested in telling potential users, "you actually don't want that feature."
- Google234 6y ago99% of apps you download aren’t spam unlike the 99% of web notification requests that are spanmy
- cforrester 6y agoI don't find that very convincing at all. 99% of apps I've ever used add no value beyond what a web interface could do, and most of those send me spammy notifications trying to draw me back into the app. App notification spam is a much greater problem for me and everyone I know than web notification spam, and apps pose a greater privacy and security threat.
- pmontra 6y agoI agree, because I've become picky about what I install. I tend to use only open source apps, especially from F-Droid. However I routinely deny notification requests in Firefox so this is not a problem. I also routinely deny the permission to use canvas image data. Firefox warns it can be used to fingerprint browsers https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-protection-against-fingerprinting https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-protection-agai... Sadly Apple does its best to make more money. If they allow other browser engines they'd end up selling less apps. IMHO they'll care about privacy only until it positively correlates with making money. If it will ever cost them more than it gains, they'll find a way to weaken privacy without losing face. An example, Apple ruthlessly enforcing in app payments for small companies but bowing to Netflix, Amazon and the like. They know they would sell less phones if those apps won't run on iOS. And that's expected. Why would a company care about you and me in this age? No more than what you and me would care about ants.
- zambal 6y agoIn my experience the usage of notifications in native apps is hardly less spammy than web notifications.
- kyriakos 6y agoInstagram, Facebook, Twitter are the biggest offenders here. Its worse cause for these apps if you allow them the send notifications permissions you are automatically opting-in for everything and you need to use their UI to granularly remove the ones you don't want.
- kyriakos 6y agoThen 99% of the websites you visit are spammers, that's a different problem. Removing this feature from all users though is not a good solution either. Chrome allows you to block notifications from all sites so you don't have to dismiss requests anymore which seems like it would suit your needs and at the same time allow others to use this feature.
- endless1234 6y ago>Have those users download some simple app The whole discussion is about it being unnecessary resource use to develop said "simple app" due to Apple's restrictions on mobile Safari..
- fragile_frogs 6y agoAnd not everyone has the resources to build a "simple app" just for iOS.
- kyriakos 6y agoHow is this abused when you have to opt in to get the notifications? If you opt out once the site cannot request it again.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThis is, unfortunately, the route we're going, and was addressed in the OP: > Despite the web app working perfectly on Android and across Windows, Linux and macOS without native integration, we now must dedicate time and resources to develop an additional iOS app just so iOS users, which over half of Americans are, aren't left out. > This is an expensive endeavor time-wise and money-wise, during a pandemic where time is of the essence and resources are stretched thin. It shouldn't be this way, but it is. The end result is that, right now, some sick patients are punished for their wrong choice of phone or tablet because the native app doesn't exist yet, while others don't have a problem.
- watermelon0 6y agoPWA cab be 'installed' to the device, similarly to 'Add to home screen' option. It would be reasonable to allow notifications only to installed PWA, and not just any website you visit.
- tehbeard 6y agoThis is what I've wanted safari/iOS to do. They'd get to claim privacy/user safety (no drive by permissions grab) But, this eats into their walled garden money pit, so yeah it's not going to happen..
- mrtksn 6y agoIt seems like the that’s the obvious solution at first but if you think about it, this will make every site ever to greet you with “add to home screen” popup. Just like aggressively trying to make you install their app from the appstore. The number will increase since there won’t be a barrier of entry. Then there would be people who are trying to make you "install" their PWA at any cost, then sell their install base and the buyers will simply rename the app/website to anything they want. It can actually be another golden age for the web while making users hate their phones.
- danShumway 6y agoRight now, if you go to any website on mobile, you get a big popup telling you to install a native app. What would be different? Getting asked to enable a browser feature is not more annoying than getting asked to exit the app and install a brand new native app with worse sandboxing and privacy. It's at most the same level of annoying.
- mrtksn 6y agoThere's some barrier of entry(buy an account and create documents describing your app) to have a mobile app, with PWA it will be removed and you will have every single website trying to make you "install" their web app, just like every single website is trying to take your e-mail address or make you create an account. The app experience is almost always better because you always have more screen real estate, higher performance, better persistence and the developer has more opportunities to monetise you which eases the need to shove all the adds technologically possible into your face before you leave and never come back. Visiting a new website in 2021 has the following installation process: 0) click a link 1) download the website. Websites are bloated these days, things jump around until you download and execute a few MB of JS, CSS, HTML and so on. 2) accept/deny tracking(usually designed to trick you into accepting) 3) accept/deny subscribing to newsletters(usually the skip button is obscured) 4) try to figure out what is this all about, trying to distinguish site element from ads 5) if you still want to continue you probably will need to create an account for anything that's beyond an article. Many times, you will need to create an account even for an article 6) after all that jazz you can actually try out the app/website or consume the article 7) if you like what you see, you need to bookmark/add to home screen An app experiance is something like this: 0) click a link 1) see screenshots and explanation of what this app is all about, accompanied with reviews and ratings 3) if you like what you se, tap install, make a fingerprint scan or a face scan to download and open the app 4) try out the app. if you like it, it will be on your homescreen to use again. if you don't like it, you can delete it from the same place. For both cases, any use hardware or system API you will get about the same popup asking you to give access to location/microphone/camera/bluetooth. For the mobile app the experience of managing it will be easier since it will have standardised settings in the device settings and you know the permissions are revoked when you delete the app. For web apps you don't have an uninstall process. You need to dive into browser settings to remove history, cookies etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rsj_hn 6y agoCan you send them an SMS? One would think that notifying someone with a phone is a solved problem that doesn't require deep phone-browser integration.