4 ms·
> Something clearly operated to keep human population in check before its explosion over the last couple of centuries. But it was generally not starvation. The
by littlestymaar 6y ago
> Something clearly operated to keep human population in check before its explosion over the last couple of centuries. But it was generally not starvation. The real problem is that population growth begets population density, and population density, in the absence of sanitation, antiobiotics, and other checks on infection, begets disease and death
That's an interesting opinion, but how does that model explains why eastern Asian countries (where rice was available) where able to achieve and sustain far higher population density than areas fed by wheat?
Also, pre-modern cities like Rome or Baghdad where much more densely populated than the average and have seen such population level for centuries, which means than population density in the rural world was far lower than some hypothetical limit level.
- duxup 6y agoThe article does say that Rome required some level of constant migration into the city to maintain it's population. I can't speak to how true that is but it might explain the population numbers.
- Keysh 6y agoI think that's perhaps rather generically true for premodern times. I've seen estimates of mortality rates for medieval England that have cities consistently higher than rural areas, so you'd have to have migration to the cities.
- TeeMassive 6y agoAnd let's not forget that malnutrition causes disease.
- peterthehacker 6y ago> Asian countries (where rice was available) where able to achieve and sustain far higher population density than areas fed by wheat Do you have any sources/data for that point? I’m curious why rice would impact population density differently than wheat.
- littlestymaar 6y agoSure: https://acoup.blog/2020/09/04/collections-bread-how-did-they-make-it-addendum-rice/ https://acoup.blog/2020/09/04/collections-bread-how-did-they... As usual with Bret Devereaux, this is quite a long read.
- redis_mlc 6y agoIt's believed that an Icelandic volcanic eruption for 20 years caused the Bronze Age extinction of most European cities around 1200 BC. Almost everybody starved to death. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Bronze_Age_collapse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Bronze_Age_collapse The Bronze Age Collapse - Mediterranean Apocalypse https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prlK8iY7blk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prlK8iY7blk Around 1300 AD, there was a century with 10 bubonic plagues. Byzantium - Last of the Romans (Part 1 of 2) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JHCfe86A8U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JHCfe86A8U At the moment, China imports about 50% of its food, which is not sustainable.
- tuatoru 6y agoWhen people are chronically malnourished and undernourished, they succumb to one of the many diseases swirling around. Infectious diseases or deficiency diseases or parasites. Periods labelled "famines" were not all that common, but much of the population was living in a sub-acute famine much the time, primarily for political reasons (power imbalances, unelightened decision-makers). > how does that model explains why eastern Asian [rice-growing areas] ... where able to achieve and sustain far higher population density [than the Eurocentric examples in OP]. The average densities were higher, but until the 20th century, with Beijing* as the primary exception, big cities were in Western Asia, North Africa, and Europe.[1] Many infectious diseases probably need "point" (small area) population sizes greater than those of the villages prevalent in rice-growing areas to take hold. Rice rulers could afford to burn a village to the ground if there were reports of spreading sickness in it. They'd only lose a small fraction of their tax base, which would soon be replaced. Rulers of large cities, not so much. Why did rice-growing areas have villages while wheat areas developed cities? I don't know. Possibly something to do with wheat being being grown in drier areas so it could be stored for years without rotting, making large centralised granaries possible. * And a few other North China cities. I know very little about Beijing, but I don't think the climate there is suitable for rice. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_cities_throughout_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_cities_through...
- Keysh 6y ago> until the 20th century, with Beijing* as the primary exception, big cities were in Western Asia, North Africa, and Europe > Why did rice-growing areas have villages while wheat areas developed cities? I'm sorry but that's simply untrue. There were lots of cities in premodern China. Urbanization probably got started earlier in the Near East, which is why you get early large cities there, but even in the list you link to, from ca. 1000 BC on there are basically always one or more Chinese cities in the list: Haojing, Luoyan, Xiadu, Chang'an/Xian, Nanjing, Kaifeng, Hangzou, .... (And this is ignoring other large cities that were never the largest like Guangzhou.) (Beijing doesn't become really significant until the Mongol Yuan dynasty makes it their capital in the 13th Century.)
- gumby 6y agoSanitation practices may have been more developed in the denser regions of Asia than they were in post-Roman Europe. Anecdotally it feels that way (bathing, certain food handling and disease rituals) from reading historical accounts. I have a parent from each and when they talked about their childhoods (1930s and 1940s), even through war, the differences are stark. But I’m hardly a scholar so this is anecdotal.