5 ms·
Why is electroshock therapy still a mainstay of psychiatry?
- Aerroon 6y agoIn any other situation ECT would be considered torture. The doctors knowingly inflict mental and physical anguish on the 'patients' with some vague hope that it'll help them. None of them will bear any responsibility either once the 'treatment' is shown to be a sham.
- tartoran 6y agoWhat is this based on? Old movies?
- kaminar 6y agoSince Drs think it's so great, they should ALL be required to undergo intense treatments themselves, before being allowed to administer. For all those fans who say it works, 1000s suffer and/or die because of it. Y'all are dang crazy.
- elzbardico 6y agoECT doesn't involve pain or anguish. The patients are sedated.
- Aerroon 6y agoExcept for side effects and memory loss. There have also never been any cases where the patient was awake, right? That's why the people mentioned in the article that were waiting in line tried running away, right? It was such a pleasant experience that people who couldn't fully remember it wanted to flee.
- Delk 6y agoI'm not going to advocate, even in the most general sense possible, for a practice that I'm not particularly knowledgeable of. However, you literally said "and physical anguish". Patients being sedated (and given muscle relaxants in order to avoid the patients hurting themselves while under anaesthesia) would address that. GP pointed that out. Nobody will be able to say that there have never been any cases where the patient was awake, even when administered general anaesthetics, but if the anaesthesia for some reason fails, that would not be the doctors knowingly inflicting anguish. If ECT were (still) done without anaesthesia nowadays, you'd be right, but my limited understanding is that it isn't. If your understanding is different, by all means share it, but the sarcastic "no cases ever, right?" rhetoric isn't really an argument. The story of patients trying to run away definitely sounds like an involuntary application of the treatment, which certainly seems inhumane in all but perhaps the most extreme of cases. But the story was from the 1970's. Are the present day practices of administering ECT still the same? If not, present day use should not be judged based on that. I agree that side effects such as memory loss sound scary and severe, and should be taken seriously. Maybe they aren't given enough consideration. I can't really judge that since I don't know the circumstances that lead to ECT being considered. All in all, it's obviously an emotional topic, but I don't think the way you responded to GP was really fair.
- savanaly 6y agoQuoting from https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/16/things-that-sometimes-help-if-youre-depressed/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/16/things-that-sometimes-... on the subject of ECT: "Electroconvulsive therapy gets a bad rap from old movies where we see people who “misbehave” in the mental institution getting what look like very painful electric shocks. Modern electroconvulsive therapy is done with the patient sedated. You are pleasantly asleep, your limbs aren’t flailing about or anything, and it can be done on an outpatient basis with you going home as soon as you’re done. There are a lot of worries about side effects. Some people experience some memory loss, especially of the couple of weeks before the treatment. Most of the time these memories come back. Sometimes they don’t. But how much do you want to remember the week when you were so depressed you needed ECT, anyway? Longer-term side effects are less well-known. Some people think a lot of ECT isn’t good for your brain, but if the effect exists it’s small enough that people are still debating whether or not they’ve really picked it up. But the thing is, ECT really, really works. People get to the point where everything else has failed, and they’ve been on seven hundred different medications without feeling any better, and they’re ready to give up, and then they get ECT and start whistling happy songs and dancing the polka. I won’t say it works 100% of the time, because no medical treatment works 100% of the time. But in psychiatry, where expectations are always low, it’s the closest thing we’ve got to a miracle cure."
- daniellarusso 6y agoHonestly, I thought part of the point of the therapy is to ‘erase’ the most painful of recent memories, helping the person not fixate on such thoughts, since they are gone. I have no idea what I am talking about, though.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> But the thing is, ECT really, really works. According to the article, studies on the subject of efficacy of ECT are few and far between, obsolete and methodologically flawed and there is not sufficient evidence to suggest that ECT "works" (in the sense of improving the patient's condition).
- 6y ago
- etrevino 6y agoThis is anecdata, so take it for what you will, but when my ex-wife needed ECT it was literally a last ditch effort because she refused to return to the hospital. It stabilized her for sure, but the effect was definitely temporary and we had to discontinue the course early because of side effects. While waiting for the procedure I did get to know a lot of the patients and their families. There were a few people who seemed to be getting markedly better. There was also a woman with a brain injury and she claimed the ECT kept her mentally afloat for a few months, until she needed it again. The thing that helped my ex much more ended up being ketamine infusions, but even that has some risks. This is just my experience. I don't know that there's a whole lot to learn from it, but I do know that for some patients it worked, though it's definitely not the permanent fix I've heard people claim it is.
- adamredwoods 6y agoFrom 2016, DIY neurostimulation (caveat: low-voltage, at your own risk): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11238973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11238973
- anecdoodle12 6y agoAnother anecdata post: I knew very little about ECT and was horrified by the idea of it until it saved my mother's life. She was in hospital in a near-catatonic state, which had been preceded by a several years of serious mental illness, eventually including psychosis. The idea of her undergoing this kind of treatment was awful. However, she went from near-catatonia, IV fluids, and literal spoonfeeding to...being responsive, alert, and basically having the will to live again, over the course of intensive treatment (2-3 sessions/week for 2 months). Once she was able to eat and be aware of her surroundings, she was tapered off of ECT and began other interventions like talk therapy, medication, etc. All of this was 3 years ago, and she has not needed ECT again since. She is now in really good mental health. I did a lot of research on ECT before I could come to terms with it. The turning point for me was calling a friend from high school whom I knew I could trust who had become a psychiatrist. She has administered ECT to her patients. I asked her what she would do if it were her own mother, and she said she'd do it. It's not something to take lightly (the memory loss is real), but in this case it sure as hell beat the alternative. My mom credits it with saving her life as well. PS If anyone reading this is struggling or has a loved one who is struggling, I don't have the right words but I'm thinking of you. None of these decisions are easy.
- Engineering-MD 6y agoJohn Read, the author, is a psychologist who is a proponent of the more psychosocial side of the biopsychosocial model of psychiatry. He is a well known opponent of ECT therapy, and this article is not a balanced view of ECT. There are plenty of proponents of ECT, and overall the balance of evidence for most guidelines suggests it is useful in some situations. From my experience working in psychiatry in the UK at least, psychiatrists do just want to help treat patients, and use it as it seems to work in select situations. Its just another treatment option, why demonise it?
- tcj_phx 6y ago> why demonise it? ECT is a palliative treatment that does not address any of the causes of the patients' actual problems. While some patients seem to benefit, some are grievously harmed. The precautionary principle, and ethical guidelines, should eliminate this form of modern bloodletting from the therapeutic arsenal.
- Engineering-MD 6y agoI would disagree. As the pathogenesis of most mental health problems is poorly understood, no treatment can be said to address the cause of the patients actual problems with any degree of validity. All medical interventions including CBT, pharmacological interventions and ECT have risks of harm and side effects. Therefore as with all these treatments a risk/benefit needs to be made, without appeal to the emotional response that ECT seems to produce in those reading about it. Current guidelines by panels of experts and systematic reviews suggests it is helpful in certain cases. Therefore it is reasonable to keep it in the arsenal of therapies while expert opinion and evidence supports it.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> Its just another treatment option, why demonise it? My personal test for any proposed medical treatment is as follows: can any resoning given in support of the treatment be also used to support homeopathy? If so, then the proposed treatment is not necessary (or, equivalently, it can be replaced by homeopathic treatment). Applying the test to your reasoning in support of ECT, I have the following: "There are plenty of proponents of [homeopathy], and overall the balance of evidence for most guidelines suggests it is useful in some situations. From my experience working in [homeopathy] in the UK at least, [homeopaths] do just want to help treat patients, and use it as it seems to work in select situations. Its just another treatment option, why demonise it?" That wouldn't convince me of the merits of homeopathic treatments, so it does not convince me of the merits of ECT.