3 ms·
> Shouldn't paper forms still be available as a last resort? No, not really. The edge cases are easily resolved by helping out those who cannot use the standar
by mrtksn 6y ago
> Shouldn't paper forms still be available as a last resort?
No, not really. The edge cases are easily resolved by helping out those who cannot use the standard method. A friend, a random stranger or a clerk would gladly fill an online form when someone is having troubles.
Upkeep of a parallel infrastructure is hard and expensive.
If it’s not THAT rare it instantly becomes a service that is provided by a shop close to the place where the papers were supposed to be filled.
I’ve seen that in Bulgaria where clerks would fill online or paper forms for you in exchange of a small fee and in Turkey there’s a bookstore close to official buildings that will help you with all kind of form. There used to be people with typewriters hassling around public offices that would fill forms for you too.
Nowadays in Turkey the online government services are very good(you can do everything online, including everything from health services to subscription cancellations), so these seized to exist and if there’s some who cannot use the online stuff, a local shop or the clerks in a public office would help them out.
- cratermoon 6y agopsst: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26512281 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26512281
- mrtksn 6y agoInteresting edge case that can be solved by booklet or a person with half an hour time explaining how these things work or simply help them out instead of upkeep of a paper processing infrastructure through institutions.
- woodruffw 6y agoMy parents, who have decidedly not been in prison for the last 30 years, can barely fill out most digital forms (especially ones on the Web) on their own. They both have professional degrees and have used computers since the 1980s. Assuming that someone who has likely never touched a computer before can operate at or above that level seems like a fast track towards ensuring that they remain marginalized and even further isolated from social services. That, in turn, has long term expenses that, I'd expect, dwarf the costs of a few hardcopies and a data-entry clerk.
- mrtksn 6y agoI am not unfamiliar with this situation but I still think it is an edge case that the time will take care of. In my case, family fills up the online forms for the elderly. I know that they are not stupid, my father is an Engeneer with masters degree, used to program with punch cards and he still uses Autocad but he is having trouble with online forms. When needed, he sends me a link and I fill up forms for him occasionally. I have other relatives too who are simply not comfortable with computers and we will help them out when needed. When that's not possible, a clerk will help them out. People tend to be nice to old people, even if they are grumpy.
- cratermoon 6y ago"edge case"? Take a look at how many Americans are under the control of the carceral system. Dismissing the reality of how we treat prisoners in the US smacks of elitism.
- blendergeek 6y agoI am only okay with online only if all online forms strictly stick to open standards and protocols and require no data collection besides what is strictly necessary for the forms. When I have to agree to a "Terms of Service" on a third party website to get my drive license and these Terms have a mandatory arbitration clause and leave this private entity with the ability to ban me for any reason, I will understandably be upset. All government forms must be accessibly to all. If internet is required to use government forms, internet access must not be cut off to anyone without due process of law. The same goes to electricity and the ability to use electronic devices. If the main computing devices available are Google Chromebooks, Apple iPads, and Microsoft Tablets, the user's ability to log in can be restricted at the drop of a pin by a faceless corporate entity. While it may still be possible to access the internet on some of these devices without agreeing to the TOS, this can change. If the government certificate expires, then the device will need to be updated. Updates almost always require a TOS agreement. No private corporations should be able to ban people from using government forms without due process of law. So yes, I am okay with online only, but only in a world where all software can be used by all users for any purpose without threat of revocation from extra-judicial private overlords.