4 ms·
>"we should allow developing countries" Not to pick on you, but I often hear this frasing in the 'first world' and surely you dont 'allow' or 'disallow' intern
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
>"we should allow developing countries"
Not to pick on you, but I often hear this frasing in the 'first world' and surely you dont 'allow' or 'disallow' internal policies to an sovereign nation?
It sounds like a Freudianslip or something, the reality is that its easy to bully or bribe officials in developing nations.
- jariel 6y agoWTO has rules, as do nations with agreements in place. 'Allow' implies some degree of forgiveness or allowance of entity on the other side of the table. In this case, Ghana may probably face trade sanction/scrutiny for their protectionism. It will have to play out in terms of other agreements.
- luxuryballs 6y agocollusion for thee but not for me
- bluepizza 6y ago> Not to pick on you, but I often hear this frasing in the 'first world' and surely you dont 'allow' or 'disallow' internal policies to an sovereign nation? Not exactly. Between forcing their hand on disadvantageous trade deals, lodging complaints and enforcing restrictions with the WTO, and outright installing dictators and funding militias - allowing or disallowing is all what the first world ever does.
- edflsafoiewq 6y agoFree trade is usually done on a tit-for-tat basis. I think the GP is saying they should allow protectionist policies without "tatting".
- pydry 6y agoThis is effectively how the US built up the industries of Japan, Taiwan and South Korea. The reason these countries were allowed to do it where others are not was because the US wanted strategically placed powerful allies in the region. There probably wouldn't be a Japanese electronics/car industry, for instance, if the Soviets hadn't spooked the the US in the 40s.
- dominicl 6y agoI'm curious about this argument. Haven't heard the "tiger states" growth attributed solely to US policies. Any links/pointers to those advantages that were granted these states but not other developing countries at the time?
- sct202 6y agoI don't know about solely developed, but South Korea, Taiwan, and Japan did receive substantial amounts of foreign aid in the post-war period. In addition, some of this aid financed land reforms that forced large land owners to break up large holdings and sell to the tenant farmers who previously rented the land. The notoriously small farms in Japan are not a natural free market development.
- Mat342 6y agoThat's absolute BS, asians are smart and hardworking, US didn't build them
- jbay808 6y agoThe US built those industries only in the same sense that they built Germany's. Japan's industrial base was built before the 40s, with an extensive domestic supply of machine tools and industrial equipment, rail infrastructure, and finished manufactured goods. Or else who do you think was building the planes, ships, and submarines that the allies were fighting on the Pacific front? Their industries were temporarily damaged by the war but it's no surprise that they'd be back to building cars within a couple decades. They, rather than the US, were the ones who built up much of the initial industrial base of Taiwan and Korea, as part of their own colonization efforts. Not out of so much benevolence, of course.
- pydry 6y agoThey weren't building walkmans or cars for export. Their skill base was intact but their industry was razed by WW2. Either way they needed raw materials and markets to develop their industrial base and that required favorable American trade policy, $$$ and military support.
- throwaway210222 6y ago"I often hear this [phrasing] in the 'first world' and surely you don't 'allow' or 'disallow' internal policies to an sovereign nation?" Forget about the third-world, right now the USA is not-allowing Germany the right to build a pipeline with Russia! First-world - check, sovereign - check, allies - check.
- madengr 6y agoThe USA is not allowing the USA to build a pipeline.
- dahfizz 6y ago> the USA is not-allowing Germany the right to build a pipeline with Russia! The USA is threatening trade sanctions if Germany builds the pipeline. I would not call that "not-allowing". That seems to be OP's whole point. The US is responding as a sovereign nation to actions of other sovereign nations. Phraseology like "allow" and "disallow" are not accurate. If Germany does the cost-benefit analysis and decides to cancel the pipeline because they don't want trade sanctions, that was their decision as an independent nation. It is not as if we are threatening war.
- throwaway210222 6y agoNonsense. The USA would not have gone to all the trouble to pass legislation to sanction Nordstream2 if they didn't think it would be effective. The USA didn't just do it to voice their displeasure: they could have done that with an email. They truly think its enough of a hammer to stop the pipeline. Hence "won't allow"
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoThe US is exploiting its centrality in the international financial system, though. No other country uses secondary sanctions so extensively to dictate to other countries who they may and may not trade with. When the US pulled out of the Iran nuclear deal, for example, it essentially ordered European companies not to trade with Iran. Even European companies that have no business in the US are afraid to do business with Iran, because American secondary sanctions will still hit them. No European bank will lend to a European company that does business with Iran, out of fear of American sanctions. These sorts of actions will eventually provoke a reaction: either the establishment of alternate financial systems or retaliatory sanctions.
- andrepd 6y agoThe point is that yes, economically strong countries can and do dictate internal policies of a sovereign nation.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI get where you're coming from, but in this case they are completely right to use this phrasing, with exactly the connotation you are talking about: the status quo is that the first world is NOT allowing these countries to run their affairs as they want internally. That is, any developing country is presented with 2 options by the developed world: either accept 'free trade' (allow foreign investors to buy up the local industry, commit to IP laws, don't apply tariffs) or no one will be allowed to trade with you or send you aid. In the meantime, powerful countries are taking numerous protectionist measures in their key industries, since that is the only way to actually be prosperous.
- btown 6y ago> either accept 'free trade' (allow foreign investors to buy up the local industry, commit to IP laws, don't apply tariffs) or no one will be allowed to trade with you or send you aid. Do multi-national trade agreements (which I believe are the core mechanism for this) actually penalize signatories for trading with non-signatories? Or is it more that trade between signatories is so advantaged that no company within a signatory state would be competitive were it to trade with a counterpart in a non-signatory state?
- pietrovismara 6y agoThat's what the west does all the time. Blackmail poor countries into selling all of their assets to foreign capital, just to gain access to foreign credit. See what's happening in Cuba. See what Vietnam had to do after the war with the US, see Greece with Europe recently, see countless more. The WTO, IMF and the World Bank are the colonizing arm of capitalism. It's a relatively new form of supernational economic warfare that turned out to be very effective, especially when combined with embargoes and economic sanctions. It's the famous "offer one can't refuse".
- Blackstone4 6y agoThe way you phrase it, makes it sound like theft...surely, they have to buy the assets and that goes to the owner...the owner then can chose to re-invest locally if they choose to...the capital doesnt just disappear...
- pietrovismara 6y ago> the owner then can chose to re-invest locally if they choose to Only at the conditions imposed by the IMF. Usually that means the state has to steer away from anything that could be profitable and focus only on what is not palatable to foreign capital. It also means states can't apply import taxes, thus making their industries instantly obsolete. It's pretty much a huge transfer of wealth from inside to outside.
- viro 6y ago> Only at the conditions imposed by the IMF. Usually that means the state has to steer away from anything that could be profitable and focus only on what is not palatable to foreign capital. Im going to need a direct example please
- pietrovismara 6y agoJust check the IMF page on "Conditionality"[0]. Check the "Prior actions" sections and see "Elimination of price controls" there. Also see this video[1] about Vietnam, around halfway through it explains pretty well how it works. Edit: I realize now you asked about the "forced privatization of industries" sentence. That's thoroughly stressed accross all IMF literature, and you can see it happen in pretty much every country that takes IMF "aid". -[0]: https://www.imf.org/en/About/Factsheets/Sheets/2016/08/02/21/28/IMF-Conditionality https://www.imf.org/en/About/Factsheets/Sheets/2016/08/02/21... -[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMubOw5H-yo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMubOw5H-yo
- grecy 6y ago> Not to pick on you, but I often hear this frasing in the 'first world' and surely you dont 'allow' or 'disallow' internal policies to an sovereign nation? Oh, it's much simpler than that. If an undeveloped (or developing) country doesn't place nice with the "Developed" rules, the IMF will just bankrupt their currency and send them back to the dark ages. Why do you think Switzerland is the world's 3rd biggest exporter of Coffee [1], while not growing a single bean ? .. and Germany is number 5. The IMF doesn't let coffee growing countries like Ethiopia or the Ivory Coast export processed beans, because they want the immense profits going to developed countries. Also the WTO plays a role and just doesn't tax unprocessed raw coffee beans coming out of those poor countries, but taxes processed coffee (and chocolate) goods at astronomical rates. [1] http://www.worldstopexports.com/coffee-exports-country/ http://www.worldstopexports.com/coffee-exports-country/