2 ms·
>How do I know it'll stay open for me? How am I supposed to make that determination on whether or not it even is open for me in the first place? Technically an
by pydry 6y ago
>How do I know it'll stay open for me? How am I supposed to make that determination on whether or not it even is open for me in the first place?
Technically any license can be changed if the company holds the copyright. This is why Microsoft makes you sign a CLA. This signals a plan to potentially de-open source in the future and capitalize upon their IP.
Source available licenses are about what you can do NOW and it's usually very very clear. For example, don't set up an elastic search SAAS. Of course, you're not Amazon so you won't.
>With a standard OSI or FSF approved license, I don't have to be a lawyer
Apparently you could do with a bit of training because the thing you were most worried about is enabled by a CLA not a source available license.
You are perfectly correct to be suspicious of Microsoft's CLA when combined with their "we turned over a new leaf with OSS" marketing. I am.
>One might call it "FUD"
Not gonna lie: thats the exactly what I was thinking when I read your comment.
- yellowapple 6y ago> Technically any license can be changed if the company holds the copyright. If a codebase uses a well-defined license - like, say, the GNU GPL or Mozilla MPL or Apache license - then unless the company is the FSF, Mozilla, or Apache (respectively), then I know with reasonable certainty that as long as they're using that license with that name, the terms won't be changing under my eyes. The same can't be said of some product-specific "ElasticSearch License" or "CockroachDB License" or "MongoDB License" or what have you. With these, I'm back to having to read EULAs one by one, because the meaning of "$PRODUCT License" can change at pretty much any time. That is, if you're going to jump immediately to some bald-faced snarky ad hominem like > Apparently you could do with a bit of training it would be a lot more effective if you actually understood and acknowledged what I'm talking about instead of going off on some tangent about Microsoft and CLAs.