I'm trying to understand why you would think that it doesn't make sense, and how you think that iOS 3 being replaced serves to contradict it. The observable in

I'm trying to understand why you would think that it doesn't make sense, and how you think that iOS 3 being replaced serves to contradict it. The observable in the first link is about people who bring their phone into the genius bar and need the phone to be replaced. It doesn't say anything about what version they had when they came in, or what version they had when they left. It also says nothing about whether the users even use their phones as iPods - or whether, if they do, they had an existing collection of music before they got the phone. (One can, after all, buy new music over the air). So could you elaborate?