9 ms·
> Patients have to be Spanish citizens or legal residents and must be fully conscious when they request the procedures. > A request is to be submitted twice in
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> Patients have to be Spanish citizens or legal residents and must be fully conscious when they request the procedures.
> A request is to be submitted twice in writing, 15 days apart. It must be approved by two separate doctors and an evaluation body, according to AFP news agency.
Given those requirements and safeguards, I'm having a difficult time understanding a rational argument against this law.
- grecy 6y agoAgree 100%. I recently lost my Mum to cancer, and while the end wasn't nearly as bad as it could have been, it should have ended a day or two before it did. After battling for almost 3 years, there was no hope anymore. She couldn't eat or talk for two days, and on the last day wasn't lucid at all. In the proceeding years we had many, many conversations about death, and she was completely aware her cancer was a 100% death sentence. A friend watched his Dad suffer immeasurable pain for 6 months from bone cancer, and the final 2 weeks were inhuman. He was begging the hospital staff, but they couldn't. Three months after his Dad died, my friend committed suicide. NOT allowing assisted suicide for terminally ill people is cruel and THAT should be the crime.
- ogig 6y agoI agree with you, people should have the right to decide about their own death. Sorry about your mother.
- pmiller2 6y agoI don’t think there’s quite enough information in the article to fully evaluate it. Depending on what the precise requirements are, what this “evaluation panel” involves, and how long the panel can take to make a decision, you could certainly have a rational objection there. But, overall, it at least seems pretty good. I have always been incensed that if I were terminally ill in most US states, the law would treat me worse than my dog. Laws like this are a huge step in the right direction, IMO. Edit: I’d be fully satisfied when the law allows me to specify when I want my own suffering ended via advance directive. It really shouldn’t be the burden of a terminally ill person to have to make those decisions at the end of their life.
- benhoyt 6y agoI'll take a stab (I'm against similar laws). It's more a moral and emotive argument than a "rational" one, but many people believe that taking a human life -- apart from certain cases like self defense -- is wrong, even if it's your own. The thinking is that it's too important to be something we should decide individually (and that it should be for nature, or God, to decide). There's also the aspect that suffering sometimes just happens, and we don't usually get to decide when and how it's going to happen to us. I believe humans are inherently different from animals (a philosophical or religious debate), so I believe it is okay to put your dog down. My uncle recently died of Parkinson's and my aunt soon after of cancer. Both suffered immensely (especially my uncle), but they believed it wasn't up to them to end it. Both also had huge support from loving family and friends, the way it should be. I know it's easy to say here at a distance, but there's honour in a valiant fight to the end.
- melenaboija 6y agoLife is so important that anybody should be able to decide how to live it, and if want to live it. Mixing God in the arguments as you do, and the main reason in Spain this law was delayed, is taking freedom away from people who think different.
- benhoyt 6y agoThere are always going to be some things that people believe we shouldn't be able to decide, even for ourselves. Someone else on the thread posted about consensual cannibalism -- most people would consider that over their line. A lot of it comes down to whether you believe we (as gotsa said) "fully own ourselves" or not. Note that religious believers don't "mix" God in their arguments, they're just speaking from their perspective. They believe that God is just there, that he made and guides everything. What you call "mixing God in" we might call "practising what we preach". It's maybe a bit like asking a Native American to stop "mixing their tribal culture into everything". That's just who they are.
- melenaboija 6y agoIMHO you can practice as much as you want as long as that does not affect others, and if I know something that does not fully own me, for sure is someone else beliefs.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Given those requirements and safeguards, I'm having a difficult time understanding a rational argument against this law. Sometimes the inclined plane has a low coefficient of friction: > Evidence of widespread evasion of such safeguards in Belgium and the Netherlands, where assisted suicide had previously been legalized, was dismissed as “anecdotal,” while the widening of its application in those countries, from the consenting adults originally envisaged, to children and the mentally ill, was waved away as the product of a different “medico-legal culture.” In essence, the [Supreme Court of Canada] said, it can’t happen here. > This was not just an incidental point. This was central to the court’s reasoning, the thing that allowed it to ignore the precedent set in Rodriguez. Legalizing assisted suicide, relaxing the prohibition in place for centuries in virtually all Western countries, need not open the floodgates, as feared. It could be limited to consenting adults, of sound mind, in the last agonizing stages of a terminal illness – the sorts of people who had come before the court in Carter and Rodriguez, the sorts of cases that had moved the public to support their cause. > Yet here we are, in 2020, considering whether to legalize assisted suicide for non-terminal cases, for the mentally ill, even for children – sorry, “mature minors.” * https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-on-assisted-suicide-the-slope-is-proving-every-bit-as-slippery-as/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-on-assisted-... * https://archive.is/hFXjJ https://archive.is/hFXjJ (in case of paywall) For that last part: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_euthanasia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_euthanasia
- BugsJustFindMe 6y agoI have a small amount of experience with a similar process that exists in another country. It's easy enough to reason about the people in the last stages of cancer, but there are many other situations that are conceptually much murkier. The first thing we need to make clear is that "severe, incurable, and unbearable" does not necessarily mean terminal or even physical pain. Plenty of psychiatric conditions often accompanying significant trauma are severe, incurable, and unbearable. But they're not terminal (except by suicide), and the reason they're incurable is because we know fuck all about psychic damage, and some might argue that if you've made it this far without killing yourself then it's de-facto bearable. And yet they definitely qualify unless the law specifically says that they don't, because "deemed unbearable by the patient" is not the same as definitively unbearable. The biggest flaw I see in the model is if there's no significant determination of qualifications for whether a particular doctor should be allowed to approve the request (e.g. some might demand that the doctors be trained in appropriate specialties and have detailed knowledge of your history and situation), or whether you can ask 100 doctors who say no until you find 2 who say yes. I've seen firsthand that systems which don't mandate strict selection criteria create additional strife. I think that fundamentally one has to decide whether a person gets to just say "I want to die" one day and forget that there are doctors involved. Because believe me there are many scenarios that basically feel that way to friends and family. Many people with trauma are extremely suicidal but also scared of the process. Do we establish a structure that makes it easy to get help dying or do we want to instead mandate state resources for helping them stay alive? For a lot of people the answer is not so clear _even_ when people want to be ok with letting people make their own choices. [edit: sorry for using british slang, drive-by commenter. "fuck all" does indeed mean "nothing"]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> The biggest flaw I see in the model is if there's no significant determination of qualifications for whether a particular doctor should be allowed to approve the request Living in a country where I have the right to die, there's a formal framework that details the process that a patient goes through. By handing healthcare professionals a framework, it allows them to build hands-on experience and develop best practices in how to actually have an on-going, involved and empathic disucssion with patients and their surroundings. The big flaw in this "model" isn't the qualifications of doctors, it's pulling a moral and emotional conundrum into a set of abstract assertions and reducing the debate to the medical act itself: a doctor euthanizing a patient. > Many people with trauma are extremely suicidal but also scared of the process. Do we establish a structure that makes it easy to get help dying or do we want to instead mandate state resources for helping them stay alive? For a lot of people the answer is not so clear _even_ when people want to be ok with letting people make their own choices. The right to die, paradoxically, keeps patients from committing suicide. The knowledge that you have that right acts as a 'safety net' to open up towards healthcare professionals. Your wish to die is not a taboo, it's not an elephant that nobody wants to discuss. Any openings towards reflection on trauma isn't burdened by the imperative "you can't die, you must live" from the get-go. Taking that away, paradoxically, creates space to reach out and connect. The answer your question, in that regard, isn't "either or". It's both. The right to die can only be implemented in a meaningful fashion if healthcare and social infrastructure provides enough facilities to properly help, guide and reach out to individuals. That's why it's paramount to invest in mental healthcare, hospice care, palliative care, local physicians, nurses, social workers, schooling, education and so on and see all of that as a commons embedded in communities. Even so, the right to die isn't a silver bullet. Neither is healthcare a silver bullet. They don't provide or offer wholesale answers or solutions to social, medical, ethical issues on an individual or societal level. It's fallacious to look at these issues and discuss them in moral absolutes, those are tarpits and they leave no room for moving forward. At the end of the day, death is an intrinsic part of life. However, the vast majority of people will feel uncomfortable discussing their own end of life. It's only when they are personally confronted with the finality of life that they will start to reflect. Personally, I think that a meaningful discussion about the right to die can only begin once you've recognized that your own life and your own health aren't self-evident.
- paxys 6y agoI don't think they will do anything to change the existing arguments – Religious - life is sacred, suicide is a sin etc. It is unethical for physicians to be assisting in suicide or making decisions about who should live. People (especially the elderly) can be coerced into it, even if they are of sound mind. The healthcare industry & government will be incentivized to push people into this vs. spending money for treatment. (These aren't my own opinions FYI)
- agumonkey 6y ago> incentivized to push people into this vs. spending money for treatment hmm never thought of this perverse effect .. indeed
- maroonblazer 6y ago>The healthcare industry & government will be incentivized to push people into this vs. spending money for treatment. What incentive? The healthcare industry (at least in the U.S.) makes more money be sparing no expense at keeping one alive.
- paxys 6y agoFor most countries in the world healthcare is a public expense rather than a capitalist enterprise
- esturk 6y agoIronic part is the same group that says "life is sacred" are also more likely to be pro-capital punishment. Saying things like no one should have the say to take another's life including themselves but it's OK when it's a collective decision.
- piokoch 6y agoThere is nothing ironic here: capital punishment is supposed to protect life of those who are potential future victims of a crime. It also lifts imbalance between the criminal and the victim. In a country without capital punishment criminals know that their live is protected, while victim does not have such guarantee - even if criminals torture, rape and kill a victim they know that in the worst case they will spend live in prison.
- jxramos 6y agoI thought it was like a pandoras box of slippery slope histories once these things come into being and are accepted. They morph into other cases that don't match the clean and tidy first introduction/nice-first-impression cases but devolve into euthanasia and it's in your best interest to die sort of stuff. Have we seen expansions in euthanasia in countries that wound up adopting it where these initial provisions basically are eroded and replaced with more generous expansive allowances? I thought I read so much at some point somewhere, like Belgium allowing children to be able to request assisted suicide and things like that. Maybe I'm totally off here though.
- dane-pgp 6y agoLet me give some examples from Belgium, to show what sort of difficult scenarios emerge once countries start moving along this slippery slope. As the parent comment says, the law applies to children, and has even applied to a nine year old.[0] I don't think anyone believes that a child that young can meaningfully consent to a decision as significant as ending their own life, so obviously in practice the decision will be made by the parents, who will be influenced by the difficulty of potentially having to support a disabled child, financially and emotionally. Then there are questions of the judgement of medical professionals. A research paper found that "Almost nine out of ten [medical professionals] (89.1%) agreed that in the event of a serious (non‐lethal) neonatal condition, administering drugs with the explicit intention to end neonatal life was acceptable."[1] This suggests that doctors would approve the killing of newborns even without a terminal illness. Beyond the issue of the law applying to children, there are several controversial cases involving adults without terminal illnesses. For example, a man serving a life sentence was allowed to end his life due to his feeling of "anguish"[2], despite the country not allowing the death penalty for criminals. Another adult was given euthanasia due to their opinion about themselves after a sex change operation[3] (which was presumably also approved by medical professionals). Finally, a man requested euthanasia (which has been initially accepted) as a result of his dissatisfaction with his sexuality.[4] [0] https://allthatsinteresting.com/euthanasia-in-belgium https://allthatsinteresting.com/euthanasia-in-belgium [1] https://obgyn.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/aogs.13967?af=R https://obgyn.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/aogs.1... [2] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-29209459 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-29209459 [3] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/belgium/10346616/Belgian-killed-by-euthanasia-after-a-botched-sex-change-operation.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/belgium/10... [4] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-36489090 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-36489090
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wolfretcrap 6y agoAt what point you can't bribe bunch of government doctors and manipulate your enemy enough for them asking for death. You can really easily convince some people to end their life despite them being perfectly reasonable with everything else in life.
- s5300 6y agoYou can also really easily convince some people to drink way more alcohol than their body is capable of processing thus killing them of alcohol poisoning. Like, really easily. Happens a lot completely by accident. Maybe I'm a bit more exposed living in a college town. What exactly is your point?
- rich_sasha 6y agoOld people, or people in immense pain, may not be in full control of their faculties, even if they are not certified so. My wife’s grandfather had dementia, and my wife’s uncle who was technically their carer, sucked them dry of all their money then blocked medical care coming to them. The grandparents wereegally independent. If he could coerce out an assisted suicide, it would have all happened much more quickly. This is second hand info, not enough for the police to bother (they were notified) but knowing the characters involved and enough facts, completely believable. It’s maybe not a show-stopper anec-argument but definitely something to bear in mind.